Rogue588

I got this tidbit of information from a newletter i'm subscribed to. They're usually pretty accurate, so i'd be surprised if this was false.

Decker

Worst. Idea. Ever.

The Black

The Doors of the 21st century started it.

reverie

I told my fiancee that the Outfield guy had some Sting characteristics in his voice, but she didn't think so! But I agree. This has got to be one of the worst ideas in the past decade of music. I do think it'd be great to see the trio back together, but it's not the Police without all three of them.. to me it was odd hearing backing vocalists on the Live Synchronicity disc.

If Sting doesn't want to do it, then fine. I wish he would though.. The funny thing about this story is, in the past, it's never been about money, at least to Stewart. He's said that if they just did a few shows and gave all the money to charity, he'd be delighted to be playing with Andy and Sting again in the group. The "New Police" idea just sounds... off.

j123vt_99

even worse, since the original lead singer (sting) is STILL ALIVE,... just stupid

darqleo

Well as far as band's reforming with new singers, I believe there were other before them. The Misfits..... Dead Kennedys...... Journey.....

Rogue588

Guess it's 'cuz he's too busy making AC music..

GuessWho

Styx is missing Dennis DeYoung, Iron Maiden had a new singer for a while, and who can forget Sammy Hagar replacing Dave in Van Halen?

The WORST idea is actually what INXS is doing... finding a new singer using an American Idol-type talent show on TV

A-aron

and Gary Cherone replacing him ....

Brain Stew

I heard that due to a lot of lineup changes, the Thin Lizzy that toured a few years ago had no original members.

tonyc3742

I actually preferred the 'new' Misfits to the 'old' Misfits. I won't deny the Danzig 'fits had a greater impact on music/punk/alternative, but to me, the new Misfits were better musically and just more fun to listen to.
But it is kind of weird, to think of a 'band' that is missing some or all of the members of the band. Where do you draw the line?

AC/DC had Bon Scott and Brian Johnson [who did sound like Bon, at least at first.]
the Rollins Band [currently] is basically Henry and whatever musicians he can find for that album.
And of course GWAR changes members all the time; the roles stay the same, but not the inhabitants of those roles.

That INXS thing is pretty bad. Will the band still be called INXS? Then again, I'd rather have actual musicians do some sort of open casting thing like that and give opportunity to some nobodies, than the 'real' American Idol show.

slop101

As bad as this sounds, I'm sure it'll be far better than most of Sting's solo work.

benedict

Much as I love those first two albums, I'm not sure whether Paul DiAnno would really cut the mustard these days.

[]

Hollowgen

well, there was "The Heads" without david byrne...

Decker

Yes, but they were "Just Heads, No Talking". This would be like hiring the lead singer from Survivor to take over his vocals. It's just wrong.

Or like the "reunited" Journey that tours now without Steve Perry. Seriously, what's the point? Who does that appeal to?

Numanoid

I know a thousand middle-aged white women who are going to kick your ass for that.

Hollowgen

ok ok, what about CCR(evisited)?

reverie

Am I the only person alive who loves the Police and Sting's solo work?

I could never quite get into Andy's solo stuff, granted I only tried two albums, and I'm not familiar with anything Stewart's done outside of the one Animal Logic cd I've got.

As far as new members in old bands go, it usually only feels right (or more okay I guess) if the band has a long history of changing members. The easy example being Fleetwood Mac, who's gone through what, like 16 line-up changes?

cungar

There's a lot of people out there who couldn't care less about the personalities in a band. All they want to do is get stoned and go to a concert to hear some party tunes, dude. Speaking of Steve Perry and Journey anyone see their induction into the walk of fame. Steve Perry and Neil Schon and the new lead singer were there. Not a comfortable situation.

Spiderbite

You guys are overlooking the worst offenders in the music business as far as "replacements" go...Motown and other "oldies" groups.

Groups like The Four Tops, The Temptations, The Platters and others send out these groups on tours with maybe one old original member (who is barely alive and has to sit in a rocking chair or use a walker onstage while breathing oxygen) or a grandson of the original member and then 2 or 3 other normal singers who call themselves The Temptations or whatever group they are singing in this week.

These groups are truly pathetic and are even worse if you see them live.

Chrisedge

Nope, I'm a big fan, since every Police AND Sting tour since 1981.

JAA

What's the NEW lead singer doing there? He had NOTHING to do with that accomplishment.

wendersfan

That's great for Stew and Andy, but whose songs are they going to perform? Sting was the primary songwriter in the group.

kmcrowl

I got it.

paulringodaman

....and lynyrd skynyrd

We currently have two original members in the band, an original member who died about 2 years ago that played with the current band, two more originals that are alive and well and doing stuff with their own bands, and the brother of the lead singer singing.

Also, I don't feel AC/DC replacing Brian Johnson with Bon Scott was a bad move....No one that sees AC/DC live ever says, "He's no Bon Scott." To me, Brian is "original" and he is AC/DC (not to disrespect Bon Scott).