2017 Oscar Nominations
#27
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
#28
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#30
Thread Starter
Moderator
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
#31
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#32
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
#33
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
That's a popular trick that always irks me, other examples being Danny Aiello for Do The Right Thing, Martin Landau for Crimes and Misdemeanors and the girl from True Grit.
#34
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Every objective fashion I can think of (who is the story about, amount of screentime) breaks down with something like Silence of the Lambs. Hannibal Lector is a supporting character in Clarice's story, but Anthony Hopkins' portrayal is so outstanding he dominates the movie and turns it into a leading performance.
#35
Thread Starter
Moderator
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Geoffrey Rush isn't in the first 45 minutes of Shine is he? He won the Best Actor Oscar for his role.
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
#36
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,580
Received 1,659 Likes
on
1,177 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
And while I liked Dev Patel's performance, Sunny Pawar was just as strong with very few words. His expressions really captured the struggle as young Saroo.
#37
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Geoffrey Rush isn't in the first 45 minutes of Shine is he? He won the Best Actor Oscar for his role.
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
#38
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Geoffrey Rush isn't in the first 45 minutes of Shine is he? He won the Best Actor Oscar for his role.
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
I know it will never happen, but there needs to be some objective way to fairly delineate a Lead performance from a Supporting performance.
Viola Davis is probably a lead actress as well.
I think these are the records for least screen time by male and female lead actors who won :
Anthony Hopkins 16 minutes of screen time in SOTL
Patricia Neal 22 minutes of screen time in Hud
#39
DVD Talk God
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
OJ: Made in America being nominated for best documentary feature is an interesting choice.
Besides airing at a few film festivals, did it get any additional theatrical distribution? Plus, the movie would be 7 1/2 hours if played straight through.
I'm sure most who saw it watched it on TV on ABC and ESPN last summer.
Besides airing at a few film festivals, did it get any additional theatrical distribution? Plus, the movie would be 7 1/2 hours if played straight through.
I'm sure most who saw it watched it on TV on ABC and ESPN last summer.
#40
DVD Talk Limited Edition
#41
DVD Talk Hero
#43
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
I'm glad LIFE, ANIMATED got nominated for Best Documentary Feature. It was one of the best films I saw last year. It's about an autistic child who could only communicate through dialogue from Disney animated features and how he became a somewhat functioning adult. The boy's father, Ron Suskind, wrote a book about it and is, of course, in the film. He has some connection to Disney, since he's interviewed a lot in the Walt Disney episode of "American Masters." Disney co-produced the documentary, which includes a lot of clips from Disney movies.
#44
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Not very many surprises in there, aside from Adams' snub. The Academy needs to stop putting Streep up for everything she does.
I am exceedingly happy to see so many people of color represented, though, because now every asshole with a Twitter account can't pretend Oscar nominations are the crux of race relations and only white people get to attend the party. See what happens when people of color make great films that resonate? They get nominated.
I am exceedingly happy to see so many people of color represented, though, because now every asshole with a Twitter account can't pretend Oscar nominations are the crux of race relations and only white people get to attend the party. See what happens when people of color make great films that resonate? They get nominated.
#45
DVD Talk Hero
Joined: Jun 2000
Posts: 39,580
Received 1,659 Likes
on
1,177 Posts
From: Somewhere between Heaven and Hell
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
I am exceedingly happy to see so many people of color represented, though, because now every asshole with a Twitter account can't pretend Oscar nominations are the crux of race relations and only white people get to attend the party. See what happens when people of color make great films that resonate? They get nominated.
There's already a few who noticed there are no Hispanics.
But to agree with you somewhat, I hope it's not blatantly pointed out and made a story. If you're an actor/actress in a great role giving your best performance, it shouldn't matter what your ethnicity/gender/sexual orientation is.. nor should it need to be pointed out.
#46
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Then again, maybe in a less strong year, it would've gotten a nod, but as others have noted, this was a strong year for animation.
#47
DVD Talk Hero
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
I'm in the same boat with the other guy that doesn't really care for Pixar movies all that much, but I do think The Incredibles and Ratatouille deserved their wins, and Cars wasn't as bad as it was made out to be.
Yeah this is a super competitive year, 27 eligible animated pics (25 April, Angry Birds, April and the Extraordinary World, Bilal, Finding Dory, Ice Age: Collision Course, Kingsglaive FF XV, Kubo and the Two Srings, Kung Fu Pand 3, The Little PRince, Long Way North, Miss Hokusai, Moana, Monkey King: Hero is Back, Mune: Guardian of the Mune, Mustafa and the Magician, My Life as a Zucchini, Phantom Boy, Ratchet and Clank, The Red Turtle, Sausage Party, The Secret Life of Pets, Sing!, Snowtime!, Storks, Trolls, Your Name, Zootopia)
Well, there have been 17 total. Not sure how you define "a lot." But anyway, the trend is definitely that Pixar films get at least one nod, and usually win Best Animated Picture. So Dory scoring no noms is noteworthy, and underscores the notion (IMO, anyway) that it ranks closer to Pixar's lesser efforts, in spite of mostly good reviews. I wanted to love it when it first came out, but over time I've come to realize it's not that good.
Then again, maybe in a less strong year, it would've gotten a nod, but as others have noted, this was a strong year for animation.
Then again, maybe in a less strong year, it would've gotten a nod, but as others have noted, this was a strong year for animation.
#48
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Yeah this is a super competitive year, 27 eligible animated pics (25 April, Angry Birds, April and the Extraordinary World, Bilal, Finding Dory, Ice Age: Collision Course, Kingsglaive FF XV, Kubo and the Two Srings, Kung Fu Pand 3, The Little PRince, Long Way North, Miss Hokusai, Moana, Monkey King: Hero is Back, Mune: Guardian of the Mune, Mustafa and the Magician, My Life as a Zucchini, Phantom Boy, Ratchet and Clank, The Red Turtle, Sausage Party, The Secret Life of Pets, Sing!, Snowtime!, Storks, Trolls, Your Name, Zootopia)
#49
DVD Talk Hero
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
Well, there have been 17 total. Not sure how you define "a lot." But anyway, the trend is definitely that Pixar films get at least one nod, and usually win Best Animated Picture. So Dory scoring no noms is noteworthy, and underscores the notion (IMO, anyway) that it ranks closer to Pixar's lesser efforts, in spite of mostly good reviews. I wanted to love it when it first came out, but over time I've come to realize it's not that good.
Then again, maybe in a less strong year, it would've gotten a nod, but as others have noted, this was a strong year for animation.
Then again, maybe in a less strong year, it would've gotten a nod, but as others have noted, this was a strong year for animation.
#50
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 2017 Oscar Nominations
I get your point, but she really is great in Florence Foster Jenkins, and it's a larger-than-life character in an entertaining movie. I'd hoped Hugh Grant would get some recognition for his role, too.



