The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
#26
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Saw it at the late 12:25 AM showing and it was about half full. Decent film with a lot of creepy moments. I did call the ending, though, as I figured
There's a lot of talk about the ending and I think
But the overall feel to the movie was good. It does leave you questioning and wonder what is going to happen next. Kind of like Gone Girl.
Spoiler:
There's a lot of talk about the ending and I think
Spoiler:
But the overall feel to the movie was good. It does leave you questioning and wonder what is going to happen next. Kind of like Gone Girl.
#27
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as achau9598 - Baltimore, MD
Posts: 5,719
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Saw it at the late 12:25 AM showing and it was about half full. Decent film with a lot of creepy moments. I did call the ending, though, as I figured
There's a lot of talk about the ending and I think
But the overall feel to the movie was good. It does leave you questioning and wonder what is going to happen next. Kind of like Gone Girl.
Spoiler:
There's a lot of talk about the ending and I think
Spoiler:
But the overall feel to the movie was good. It does leave you questioning and wonder what is going to happen next. Kind of like Gone Girl.
Spoiler:
As for the ending -
Spoiler:
Bateman is great in this, and I think he really shines in these "under the radar" type films (I loved Bad Words)
#28
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Wasn't as impressed as most here I guess. Was expecting something a little more based on the praise but I thought it was pretty run of the mill.
#29
DVD Talk Legend
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
I had seen a trailer for the film and expected the standard thriller, but this ended up being much more than that. The performances were excellent. I'm not sure if I see myself watching it again, but that doesn't take away from it being a good film.
The only complaint I have is minor:
The only complaint I have is minor:
Spoiler:
#30
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Formerly known as achau9598 - Baltimore, MD
Posts: 5,719
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
I had seen a trailer for the film and expected the standard thriller, but this ended up being much more than that. The performances were excellent. I'm not sure if I see myself watching it again, but that doesn't take away from it being a good film.
The only complaint I have is minor:
The only complaint I have is minor:
Spoiler:
#31
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Pretty much. Bateman didn't get too personal. He asked some questions when they saw each other and then during the dinner, but he didn't want to make him his BFF and just wanted it over. It is interesting, though, as when he is there in the day, they never wonder what he actually does lol.
#32
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Damn good film. Seems like Edgerton is a fan of Korean New Wave.
I'm actually amazed it had the balls to do that. Cuz our films lack the integrity to do things like that and keep it from being too much. Presented it all very well. Hell of a directing debut. Really tense film. Really really good stuff going on in this film. My theater was damn near full and that was a 7:30 showing.
I'm actually amazed it had the balls to do that. Cuz our films lack the integrity to do things like that and keep it from being too much. Presented it all very well. Hell of a directing debut. Really tense film. Really really good stuff going on in this film. My theater was damn near full and that was a 7:30 showing.
#33
DVD Talk Hero
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Just got back from seeing this. Definitely Top-10 of the year material for me. Edgerton can write, produce, and direct worth a damn. I look forward to his next project. It will be added to the Blu-ray collection.
Karma is a bitch and then some.
Karma is a bitch and then some.
#34
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
This was a pretty good film and it was certainly thrilling without relying on cheap scares. But my issue with it was
Technically, well done. Still enjoyed it aside from the above.
Spoiler:
Technically, well done. Still enjoyed it aside from the above.
#35
Banned
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Formerly known as "Solid Snake PAC"/Denton, Tx
Posts: 39,239
Likes: 0
Received 4 Likes
on
4 Posts
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Not every film needs a champion. Sometimes a tale ends with no real winner. Revenge is a bitch. Her placement was clearly taken into consideration. Not everything has to be comfortable. I'm sure Edgerton took it into mind of what he was doing. She was a pawn with unknown placement to her knowledge, that's rough as hell. Sounds like you just wanted to be comfortable with how people get hurt.
#36
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
I fucking loved this. Right up there with Fury Road as one of the years best so far. So many amazing scenes. Great tension. The way they unraveled and presented Jason Bateman's character was fantastic. Same with Gordo. I'm hard pressed to come up with something I didn't like about this movie. The scene during the dinner party when they end up in the driveway, everything about that scene was fucking great.
4.5/5
PS I was surprised to see Busy Phillips in such an absolute nothing of a role. Yeah shes not cashing Jennifer Lawrence checks. But I thought it was bizarre seeing her play a nameless, faceless dinner party guest.
4.5/5
PS I was surprised to see Busy Phillips in such an absolute nothing of a role. Yeah shes not cashing Jennifer Lawrence checks. But I thought it was bizarre seeing her play a nameless, faceless dinner party guest.
#37
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
I fucking loved this. Right up there with Fury Road as one of the years best so far. So many amazing scenes. Great tension. The way they unraveled and presented Jason Bateman's character was fantastic. Same with Gordo. I'm hard pressed to come up with something I didn't like about this movie. The scene during the dinner party when they end up in the driveway, everything about that scene was fucking great.
4.5/5
PS I was surprised to see Busy Phillips in such an absolute nothing of a role. Yeah shes not cashing Jennifer Lawrence checks. But I thought it was bizarre seeing her play a nameless, faceless dinner party guest.
4.5/5
PS I was surprised to see Busy Phillips in such an absolute nothing of a role. Yeah shes not cashing Jennifer Lawrence checks. But I thought it was bizarre seeing her play a nameless, faceless dinner party guest.
#38
DVD Talk God
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Rented the BD yesterday and just finished it.
I liked it overall, but I don't think I would ever rewatch it. But I was entertained and thought it was a pretty good suspense film. Joel Edgerton was pretty solid as Gordo. And I liked Bateman playing a very different and darker character. Very creepy film. Funny how Gordo got his revenge on the man who tormented him as a youth and basically ruined his life, but didn't resort to any violence to do it.
If you get the BD, watch the alternate "Coda ending" I know it was cut for time & maybe some redundancy, but it helps fill in the blanks for some of the earlier scenes in the film. Especially the video that Gordo made for Simon.
I liked it overall, but I don't think I would ever rewatch it. But I was entertained and thought it was a pretty good suspense film. Joel Edgerton was pretty solid as Gordo. And I liked Bateman playing a very different and darker character. Very creepy film. Funny how Gordo got his revenge on the man who tormented him as a youth and basically ruined his life, but didn't resort to any violence to do it.
If you get the BD, watch the alternate "Coda ending" I know it was cut for time & maybe some redundancy, but it helps fill in the blanks for some of the earlier scenes in the film. Especially the video that Gordo made for Simon.
#39
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
Rented the BD yesterday and just finished it.
I liked it overall, but I don't think I would ever rewatch it. But I was entertained and thought it was a pretty good suspense film. Joel Edgerton was pretty solid as Gordo. And I liked Bateman playing a very different and darker character. Very creepy film. Funny how Gordo got his revenge on the man who tormented him as a youth and basically ruined his life, but didn't resort to any violence to do it.
If you get the BD, watch the alternate "Coda ending" I know it was cut for time & maybe some redundancy, but it helps fill in the blanks for some of the earlier scenes in the film. Especially the video that Gordo made for Simon.
I liked it overall, but I don't think I would ever rewatch it. But I was entertained and thought it was a pretty good suspense film. Joel Edgerton was pretty solid as Gordo. And I liked Bateman playing a very different and darker character. Very creepy film. Funny how Gordo got his revenge on the man who tormented him as a youth and basically ruined his life, but didn't resort to any violence to do it.
If you get the BD, watch the alternate "Coda ending" I know it was cut for time & maybe some redundancy, but it helps fill in the blanks for some of the earlier scenes in the film. Especially the video that Gordo made for Simon.
#40
DVD Talk God
Re: The Gift -- D: Edgerton S: Edgerton, Bateman -- 8/7/15
I went through the disc and there's a pretty good amount of extras for this movie. There's a commentary also with Edgerton.