Let's get some wrong answers out of the way! Wrong answers are all scored as +6 points.

Legend (1985): not in top 250
T-bone22

Willow (1988): not in top 250
sleepyhead55
Giles

Brazil (1985): not in top 250 (but really really close, and used to be in it)
Rex Power Colt-Robot Man

You are correct sir! If you're going to be wrong, be spectacularly wrong

Some correct uniques (all worth -1 points):

Groundhog Day
mortalplague

It's a Wonderful Life
Mountain Biker

The Princess Bride
dhmac

The Seventh Seal
Cabman Gray

V for Vendetta
AaronHernandez

It's Pop.

Surely a movie nominated for 11 Oscars (winning 4 of them) this year wouldn't go unmentioned?

And what of one of the most beloved fantasies of all-time?

Here's a movie we'll see more of later in the game:

oh shit

I just realized that the tree there in that Pan's Labyrinth poster looks like the female reproductive system.

The sheep did well at picking most of the uniques. Here are the unchosen uniques left over:

The remaining answers come from three popular series: Star Wars, Harry Potter, and Lord of the Rings. Let's begin with Star Wars. Most think of it as science fiction ... will all of the movies even have fantasy as one of their genres on imdb? [Hint: no, they do not]

Damn, I figured POTC would be too sheepy. I guess so did everyone else.

I didn't know what the top 250 was. I assumed it was money makers.

Let's look at Harry Potter answers:

Finally, Peter Jackson's Middle-earth movies (all of which are in the top 250):

PoA is the only HP movie I would bother watching again.

Will anyone start to pull away? Will the big train ever move out of the station into negative scores with everyone else?

Standings after question 7:

Rex Power Colt-Robot Man -84
Cellar Door -82
Drexl -79
wishbone -79
Mountain Biker -78
Palaver -78
sleepyhead55 -75
Giles -66
bunkaroo -63
hasslein -60
mrcellophane -58
T-bone22 -56
mortalplague -54
dhmac -52
Crocker Jarmen -46
devilshalo -45
rocket1312 -45
davidh777 -44
ivelostr2 -41
Kal-El -38
maxfisher -38
dalbowski -36
AaronHernandez -34
Cabman Gray -33
Fist of Doom -31
story -29
Rockmjd23 -26
cnicholls44 -24
Obi-Wan Jabroni -22
ruddiger_718 -18
DaveNinja -16
the big train 5

8. S: Fairy tales have been the source of many fantasy movies. What is your favorite movie based on a fairy tale?

A lot of spread for this one, but there a number of matches (and a couple of decently scoring answers). These are not them (all scoring zero):

It was a good move to go with a Disney animated classic:

Standings after question 8:

Cellar Door -91
Rex Power Colt-Robot Man -90
Mountain Biker -87
Drexl -84
sleepyhead55 -84
wishbone -84
Palaver -83
bunkaroo -72
Giles -69
mrcellophane -63
dhmac -61
hasslein -60
T-bone22 -56
devilshalo -54
mortalplague -54
davidh777 -50
rocket1312 -48
ivelostr2 -47
maxfisher -47
Crocker Jarmen -46
Cabman Gray -39
Kal-El -38
AaronHernandez -37
Fist of Doom -37
dalbowski -36
Rockmjd23 -35
Obi-Wan Jabroni -32
cnicholls44 -30
story -29
ruddiger_718 -18
DaveNinja -16
the big train -4

Whew. I put down Red Riding Hood first, try to go with something current. Glad I changed my answer.

9. R: Hayao Miyazaki has changed how many think of animated features with his works of fantasy. Name a feature (not a short or series episode) directed by him.

Though Miyazaki clearly did not make much of an impression on these sheep:

Who?: +8
cnicholls44
Mountain Biker

At least these sheep were in the right ballpark (though still wrong answers, scoring +8):

Akira (directed by Katsuhiro Ohtomo)
T-bone22

Metropolis (directed by Rintaro)
hasslein

The Cat Returns (directed by Hiroyuki Morita)
Giles