DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/611229-man-steel-reviews-thread.html)

Kal-El 06-07-13 09:00 AM

Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Poster:
https://fbcdn-sphotos-a-a.akamaihd.n...26644359_n.jpg

Theatrical Trailer:
<iframe width="560" height="315" src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/T6DJcgm3wNY" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen></iframe>

From IMDB:
A young boy learns that he has extraordinary powers and is not of this Earth. As a young man, he journeys to discover where he came from and what he was sent here to do. But the hero in him must emerge if he is to save the world from annihilation and become the symbol of hope for all mankind.

There's at least one forum member who's seen the movie and the review embargo gets lifted on Monday at 9PM Pacific Time.

Continue pre-release discussion here

bluetoast 06-07-13 09:06 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
I will continue to answer questions here, but also in spoiler tags. But to summarize my thoughts:

My favorite of the summer blockbusters so far, favorite Supes movie (out of 1,Returns and parts of 3) and I really enjoyed it.

Kal-El 06-07-13 09:07 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
I didn't know how to do the "star" rating on the poll. Mods, feel free to edit as you please.

Geofferson 06-07-13 09:08 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Either way, nice job with the Poll Options Kal-El. :)

bluetoast 06-07-13 09:13 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Yeah, I like those choices. :lol:

RoboDad 06-07-13 10:25 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by Kal-El (Post 11721474)
I didn't know how to do the "star" rating on the poll. Mods, feel free to edit as you please.


Originally Posted by Geofferson (Post 11721478)
Either way, nice job with the Poll Options Kal-El. :)

Yeah, I hope the mods leave the options just as they are. Very fitting for this movie. :thumbsup:

Oh, and it's also very fitting that you got to start the reviews thread, son of Jor-El. :)

RoboDad 06-07-13 10:32 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by bluetoast (Post 11721471)
My favorite of the summer blockbusters so far, favorite Supes movie (out of 1,Returns and parts of 3) and I really enjoyed it.

You say you liked it better than '1' (I assume that refers to the 1978 Donner film). Did you like that film as well, and just like this one more, or did you not like that one. I only ask because it helps to understand your tastes when reading your comments. And does your comment also mean that you have never seen "II" (the 1980 Lester/Donner sequel)?

bluetoast 06-07-13 10:40 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Yeah I did indeed like the first one (1978), despite some of the corny elements. Have never seen II unfortunately. Big fan of the Fleischer shorts though! And I did watch the 50's show as a kid.

jeffkjoe 06-07-13 11:07 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Here's something I've wondered about:

The casting.

How does this movie compare with the (perfect, in my opinion) casting of Superman (1978)?

Amy Adams vs. Margot Kidder
Laurence Fishburne vs. Jackie Cooper
Henry Cavill vs. Christopher Reeve

Cavill's got BIG shoes to fill. I thought Chris Reeve's casting was one of the best casting choices of all time. Ditto with Margot Kidder. Her attitude, husky voice, look all embodied Lois Lane. Amy Adams seems to girl-next-door-ish to me.

bluetoast 06-07-13 11:17 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
I'd say that Cavill certainly delivers, but it's in a way that I haven't seen before in a Superman movie.

Amy Adams did seem girl next door-ish/herself, I don't know much about Lois really, but Amy Adams had a spunky kind of sensibility. My friend is not a fan of hers though so he wasn't as happy.

I don't remember Jackie Cooper much unfortunately, but I think you will be pleased with Laurence Fishburne.

RoboDad 06-07-13 11:53 AM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by bluetoast (Post 11721613)
Yeah I did indeed like the first one (1978), despite some of the corny elements. Have never seen II unfortunately. Big fan of the Fleischer shorts though! And I did watch the 50's show as a kid.

Thanks. That really helps add some perspective. Have you ever seen Bruce Timm's Superman: TAS?

bluetoast 06-07-13 12:01 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Not really but I can vividly remember the animation style, such as the fact that Superman looks like a HOUSE.

jeffkjoe 06-07-13 12:31 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
How's the music score?

I know, I know. I hate comparing so much, but I can't help it. I'm walking in with pre-conceived images of Superman.

Hans Zimmer vs. John Williams.




That's the one thing that The Dark Knight didn't have over Tim Burton's Batman. Danny Elfman's score.

Kal-El 06-07-13 12:40 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by jeffkjoe (Post 11721769)
How's the music score?

I know, I know. I hate comparing so much, but I can't help it. I'm walking in with pre-conceived images of Superman.

Hans Zimmer vs. John Williams.




That's the one thing that The Dark Knight didn't have over Tim Burton's Batman. Danny Elfman's score.

Great question. Do you walk out of the theater and easily recognize the music or was it more atmospheric?

I listened the 90-second previews the other day and my one takeaway was there seemed to be too much percussion.

thelwig14 06-07-13 01:34 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by bluetoast (Post 11721471)
I will continue to answer questions here, but also in spoiler tags. But to summarize my thoughts:

My favorite of the summer blockbusters so far, favorite Supes movie (out of 1,Returns and parts of 3) and I really enjoyed it.


Just need one question answered.

What was your honest immediate reaction after walking out of Returns?

Thanks!

EddieMoney 06-07-13 01:38 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by thelwig14 (Post 11721868)
Just need one question answered.

What was your honest immediate reaction after walking out of Returns?

Thanks!

If he's like the rest of us, he probably either puked or shit his pants.

thelwig14 06-07-13 02:03 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by EddieMoney (Post 11721872)
If he's like the rest of us, he probably either puked or shit his pants.


Disagree. There was a strong contingent of people who thought it was really good.

Like Indy 4, I walked out thinking I was the victim of an awful prank.

Just curious about his gut reaction to Returns. If he hated it and loved MoS, I will get more hyped.

EddieMoney 06-07-13 02:06 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by thelwig14 (Post 11721912)
Disagree. There was a strong contingent of people who thought it was really good.

Like Indy 4, I walked out thinking I was the victim of an awful prank.

Just curious about his gut reaction to Returns. If he hated it and loved MoS, I will get more hyped.

I didn't know that so many people like it.

I was one of those, however, who shit my pants after seeing it. The awfulness of it made my bowels loosen and lose all control.

thelwig14 06-07-13 02:11 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by EddieMoney (Post 11721913)
I didn't know that so many people like it.

I was one of those, however, who shit my pants after seeing it. The awfulness of it made my bowels loosen and lose all control.

Superman Returns is comfortably fresh on rt.

Unfortunately there was a ton of post release hype.

EddieMoney 06-07-13 02:14 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Weird. It felt like a remake of the original film to me, and just bored me. Or it could have been because the first time I watched it was on the horrible Blu-ray disc.

Double_Oh_7 06-07-13 02:28 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
I'm hearing the movie is deadly serious, no humor whatsoever, boring, and simply rehashes the origin story we've already seen a couple of times.

bluetoast 06-07-13 02:34 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by thelwig14 (Post 11721868)
Just need one question answered.

What was your honest immediate reaction after walking out of Returns?

Thanks!

I thought it was okay. I remember really not liking the kid aspect. Never saw it again, or had any intentions of buying it, if that's a good gauge. This one I would certainly see again.



Originally Posted by Double_Oh_7 (Post 11721948)
I'm hearing the movie is deadly serious, no humor whatsoever, boring, and simply rehashes the origin story we've already seen a couple of times.

There were definitely more than a few laughs. The origin is done in a way that I thought was unique, I think you'll see what I mean.

Kal-El 06-07-13 02:53 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by Double_Oh_7 (Post 11721948)
I'm hearing the movie is deadly serious, no humor whatsoever, boring, and simply rehashes the origin story we've already seen a couple of times.

Whoever you're hearing these from obviously have not seen any footage WB has released since the 3rd trailer. A year ago I might have agreed with this, but I've been completely turned around since.

Dragon Tattoo 06-07-13 03:00 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 

Originally Posted by Double_Oh_7 (Post 11721948)
I'm hearing the movie is deadly serious, no humor whatsoever, boring, and simply rehashes the origin story we've already seen a couple of times.

Well, we already know from the trailers than none of that is true.

thelwig14 06-07-13 04:14 PM

Re: Man of Steel - The Reviews Thread
 
Thanks, Blue. All I needed to know.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:48 AM.


Copyright 2018 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.