I thought about going with this answer, but passed on it for one I thought would be more obvious.

If you picked Citizen Kane, get ready to be very happy

Glad to see a handful of others picked up on this as a good option for this question.

I was very pleased to see our top scorer. A great selection. As a fan of Ebert’s commentaries, one on this film would have been a lot of fun

Screw you guys ... this is a great answer.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_98fDQM0sAo

WTF? Nobody else said The Shining for the alcoholic one?

I'm glad I at least didn't choose City Lights or Chungking Express for the commentary question like I considered at first.

Rocket1312 -129
Jules Winfield -121
Howie2000 -112
Shannon Nutt -108
TBC -106
sauce07 -106
Obi-Wan Jabroni -102
Kal Varnsen -101
Groucho -98
ivelostr2 -96
Cruzness -92
hasslein -85
wishbone -82
Fist of Doom -82
dhmac -77
Palaver -75
Tommyp007 -74
bootsy -73
brainee -72
Auto -72
Super X -70
Tarantino -61
Arpeggi -56
Rbrown498 -42
sleepyhead55 -35
Drexel -25
Cardsfan111 -14

Rocket1312 and Jules Winfeld continue to hold the lead! But with more big questions coming up, will it last, or will other Sheep out graze them?

S:11 -When a Russ Myers biopic was announced, Ebert wrote the actor he would like to see play himself was Phillip Seymour Hoffman. Name a movie not directed by Paul Thomas Anderson featuring Philip Seymour Hoffman.

Some people decided to go with PTA anyway. How did it work out?

I missed a very important word on this question.

Phillip worked with Tom Cruise a couple of times. How did that go?

Now I'm nervous about my answer because he had a minor role (but in a film with a big following).

Which was picked higher? His work with Cameron Crowe or the Coen Bros?

So that leaves only two types of answers...

If Capote ends up being a good answer, I'm going to be mad. At the last second I changed because I thought Almost Famous was pretty beloved in these parts.

edit: Damn.

Same here, but for TBL.

Capote seemed like the sheepy answer to me, since that's the one that won him the Oscar.

Rocket1312 -131
Jules Winfield -127
Howie2000 -120
Shannon Nutt -116
TBC -112
Obi-Wan Jabroni -110
sauce07 -109
Cruzness -104
Kal Varnsen -104
ivelostr2 -102
Groucho -98
hasslein -93
wishbone -82
Fist of Doom -82
bootsy -81
brainee -80
dhmac -77
Super X -26
Palaver -75
Auto -75
Tommyp007 -74
Tarantino -69
Arpeggi -59
Rbrown498 -50
sleepyhead55 -35
Drexel -28
Cardsfan111 -20

Phillip Seymour Hoffman scores Tarantino a 69! The Cruzness's slamdunk puts him into the -100 club!

Me, PSH, and a 69. Dinner for two!

Which is what I was thinking originally, but then I over thought it and decided that despite the Oscar, Capote seems like a pretty forgotten film.

I'm gaining on you, Drexel! You should be very afraid.

A little bit of funky ordering in the 70's.

S:12 -Each year, Ebert compiled a list of the year’s best film. Name a movie on his list of the year’s best from between 1990-1999.



First up is Rbrown498, who would have gotten a match for himself and a fellow Sheep on the previous question.

Fixed!