DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Best remake ever (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/550319-best-remake-ever.html)

abe55 02-20-09 09:10 PM

Best remake ever
 
Which movie would you say is the best remake ever made?

tylergfoster 02-20-09 09:18 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
Of the ones you listed, I picked John Carpenter's The Thing.

riotinmyskull 02-20-09 09:39 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
an abe55 poll with THE THING as a choice???? how odd. however, in this case it's the correct answer.

NoirFan 02-20-09 09:43 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978)

DarthVong 02-20-09 09:44 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The Thing

My Other Self 02-20-09 09:45 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
I like a lot of those, but I'd say the best of the bunch is The Thing.

RyoHazuki 02-20-09 09:45 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
:lol: Ocean's Eleven has 20% of the votes.

kevinlord190 02-20-09 09:52 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
oceans eleven without a doubt
its one of my faves of all time

Torchur317 02-20-09 10:06 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The Thing (1982)

Blu Man 02-20-09 10:06 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
I haven't seen a lot of the films you listed, but out of the one's I have seen i'm gonna go with Ocean's 11.

zekeburger1979 02-20-09 10:07 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The Maltese Falcon (1941).

fumanstan 02-20-09 10:10 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 

Originally Posted by RyoHazuki (Post 9280798)
:lol: Ocean's Eleven has 20% of the votes.

What's so funny? It's a great remake.

NiCK Crush 02-20-09 10:18 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
not the best, but I thought the Texas Chainsaw Massacre remake was surprisingly good.

The Antipodean 02-20-09 10:23 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
Sorry, I think The Fly is a way better remake than The Thing (which is also pretty darned good though).

toddly6666 02-20-09 10:24 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The question is: What will be the next big remake for future generations? For example, will Star Wars be re-made in 40 years? Matrix? Clockwork Orange? Amelie? Unforgiven? The Lord of the Rings? What movies may seem sacrilegious to remake now but possibly would be remade in 40-plus years?

dino88 02-20-09 10:33 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
Of these choices I picked The Fly. I've seen all of the originals except The Thing, so that may have gotten another vote had I seen the original.

LickTheABCs 02-20-09 10:36 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 

Originally Posted by toddly6666 (Post 9280860)
The question is: What will be the next big remake for future generations? For example, will Star Wars be re-made in 40 years? Matrix? Clockwork Orange? Amelie? Unforgiven? The Lord of the Rings? What movies may seem sacrilegious to remake now but possibly would be remade in 40-plus years?

At the rate we're going, most of those will be remade around 2012.

My vote is for The Thing. The Fly comes in second.

PopcornTreeCt 02-20-09 10:50 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The Thing

Why it doesn't have 100% of the votes is beyond me. :)

gryffinmaster 02-20-09 10:56 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The Magnificent Seven.

EdTheRipper 02-20-09 11:07 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
The Thing

Abob Teff 02-20-09 11:42 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
I actually went for Dawn of the Dead. I love The Thing, but have never seen the original (It Came From Outerspace?).

As for a contemporary movie that would be sacrelige to remake ... I'll go just a little bit older than modern movies ... I would imagine it will be The Godfather that is going to be remade as a vehicle for Ashton Kutcher's "comeback" as a serious actor.

dino88 02-20-09 11:53 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 

Originally Posted by Abob Teff (Post 9280984)
I would imagine it will be The Godfather that is going to be remade as a vehicle for Ashton Kutcher's "comeback" as a serious actor.

I just threw up in my mouth a little.

Daytripper 02-20-09 11:55 PM

Re: Best remake ever
 
Great thread. And tough list to choose a best. I will admit though, I didn't even know "Ocean's" was a remake. Anyway, I'd pick these. In order.

"The Thing"
"Cape Fear"
"The Fly"
"Dawn of the Dead"

Mondo Kane 02-21-09 12:09 AM

Re: Best remake ever
 
Moby Dick '56 > Moby Dick '30

discostu1337 02-21-09 12:32 AM

Re: Best remake ever
 
that was easy...dawn of the dead was amazingly awesome


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:00 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.