Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
#103
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
The only movie that was ruined for me was the crying game, and that was spoiled by Siskel.
Incidentally, how long do we have to keep using spoiler tags? Is there a time frame that most people should have seen a film by, so that we no longer need to put spoiler warnings? I find it hard to believe that there are people out there that don't know teh twist at the end of Citizen Kane. Even if they havent seen the film, that twist has been mentioned in so many other places, that most people must know it by now.
Incidentally, how long do we have to keep using spoiler tags? Is there a time frame that most people should have seen a film by, so that we no longer need to put spoiler warnings? I find it hard to believe that there are people out there that don't know teh twist at the end of Citizen Kane. Even if they havent seen the film, that twist has been mentioned in so many other places, that most people must know it by now.
#104
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
Here's the Zemeckis quote: "We know from studying the marketing of movies, people really want to know exactly every thing that they are going to see before they go see the movie. It's just one of those things. To me, being a movie lover and film student and a film scholar and a director, I don't. What I relate it to is McDonald's. The reason McDonald's is a tremendous success is that you don't have any surprises. You know exactly what it is going to taste like. Everybody knows the menu."
Screenwriters:
"What if Lawrence of Arabia had vampires?"
"Yeah! Let's make that!"
Marketing department, handling the eventual film:
"Okay, so they're in the desert in WW I, fighting the Turks and they blow up a train...that belongs to vampires? Alright...."
Trailer narration:
"As World War I raged, one man led a revolt in the desert. The world would know him as 'Lawrence of Arabia.' Here now is the untold story of his battle against....
Vampires of the Desert!"
And, no, I don't believe such a film exists, and yes, I'd probably go see it.
#105
Cool New Member
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
Buckleyesque, put spoiler tags in your post!
that's twice buckleyesque has done that in this post! someone want to ban this guy?
that's twice buckleyesque has done that in this post! someone want to ban this guy?
Even though this is a spoiler thread, you still need to use spoiler tags! -Blake
You didn't just give away the ending to a thriller, did you?
Thanks for spoiling that for me.
Why would you not follow the example set by the OP and spoilerize your spoilers?
Oh, c'mon, I thought all of us are familiar with rules here...
I was just browsing through some threads and stumbled upon this one. I'm sorry, this is the epitome of stupidity. Members getting reprimanded for not putting spoiler tags in their posts - in a spoiler thread! Spoiler tags or not, if a member is dumb enough to read or click on spoilers (in a spoiler thread), they deserve to have the movie ruined for them. What right does some moron have to scold someone for giving away the ending of a movie (in a spoiler thread), when they were stupid enough to click on the spoiler in the first place, knowing full well the ending would be revealed (duh!). Rules or no rules, I guess some people are just a few twists short of a slinky. Wow.
#106
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
What are you talking about? A general spoiler thread doesn't give license to reveal spoilers. If this were a discussion thread about a particular film and warning was given that spoilers would be discussed, that's one thing. A general thread discusses all sorts of films not all readers have seen, in which case spoilers should be hidden and the reader has the choice.
#107
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,406
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Formerly known as "awil1026"/ Don't Panic
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I was just browsing through some threads and stumbled upon this one. I'm sorry, this is the epitome of stupidity. Members getting reprimanded for not putting spoiler tags in their posts - in a spoiler thread! Spoiler tags or not, if a member is dumb enough to read or click on spoilers (in a spoiler thread), they deserve to have the movie ruined for them. What right does some moron have to scold someone for giving away the ending of a movie (in a spoiler thread), when they were stupid enough to click on the spoiler in the first place, knowing full well the ending would be revealed (duh!). Rules or no rules, I guess some people are just a few twists short of a slinky. Wow. 

Thanks for your useless post, however.
#108
Cool New Member
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
What are you talking about? A general spoiler thread doesn't give license to reveal spoilers. If this were a discussion thread about a particular film and warning was given that spoilers would be discussed, that's one thing. A general thread discusses all sorts of films not all readers have seen, in which case spoilers should be hidden and the reader has the choice.
Before calling the actions of others stupid, you might want to take a look at your own thought process. You see, this is a GENERAL thread. In order to facilitate discussion, specific spoilers need to be spoilerized. This thread covers any movie that has a plot element which should be left unknown to the viewer prior to screening the film. This encompasses pretty much everything.

If you don't want to know the end of a movie, it's quite simple; don't click the little button! What would someone expect to hear if they were told this beforehand:
When The Sixth Sense was in theaters I was going to watch it, and one day before I went there I was talking to my then-girlfriend and she had already seen it by that point. So she said:
Spoiler:
When I asked her about why she had done this to me, she replied someone had also spoiled it to her beforehand so she felt an urge to do the same thing to someone else... No need to mention we're no longer together
Next occasion was before I was going to watch Saw. I was reading something on imdb forums about it and came across a thread named "READ THIS!" I was dumb enough to open it and what I read was:
Spoiler:
Spoiler:
When I asked her about why she had done this to me, she replied someone had also spoiled it to her beforehand so she felt an urge to do the same thing to someone else... No need to mention we're no longer together
Next occasion was before I was going to watch Saw. I was reading something on imdb forums about it and came across a thread named "READ THIS!" I was dumb enough to open it and what I read was:
Spoiler:
HELLO! McFly!
Last edited by Bärpfeife; 03-29-09 at 07:40 PM.
#109
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
What little button? The quotes you scoffed at were from those complaining that various posters did not put spoiler tags on their posts and openly spoiled movies. No one complained because they clicked the spoiler button for what was clearly a spoiler and got despoiled. Unless you are considering going into the thread itself as "clicking the button", in which case the posts stand.
#110
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I was just browsing through some threads and stumbled upon this one. I'm sorry, this is the epitome of stupidity. Members getting reprimanded for not putting spoiler tags in their posts - in a spoiler thread! Spoiler tags or not, if a member is dumb enough to read or click on spoilers (in a spoiler thread), they deserve to have the movie ruined for them. What right does some moron have to scold someone for giving away the ending of a movie (in a spoiler thread), when they were stupid enough to click on the spoiler in the first place, knowing full well the ending would be revealed (duh!). Rules or no rules, I guess some people are just a few twists short of a slinky. Wow. 

You won't last very long here insulting forum members, standards or rules. I suggest lightening up a tad.
That having been said, a general thread ABOUT spoilers is NOT a license to spoil movies without reserve. Otherwise, I'd have no inhibition to tell everyone the aliens in MONSTERS VS. ALIENS were actually clones of monsters the government kept in hiding, the ghost in THE HAUNTING IN CONNECTICUT is actually the neighbor's still-alive missing son, the premonitions in KNOWING are actually not from the past but from a parallel Earth, the secret of the WATCHMEN is that the killer is actually a separate identity constructed by Dr. Manhatten, and that the guy who actually arranged for the kidnapping in TAKEN was Liam Neeson's old Army buddy.
And in case you're shocked and flabbergasted, all the spoilers in the previous paragraph are bullshit. I made them up outta nothing just to make a point.
#111
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 2,712
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Seattle
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I guess it would be The Sixth Sense or The Crying Game for me, even though I wasn't particularly bothered by it. I'm not the type of person to go all apoplectic over being "spoiled."
The odd thing is that even to this day I don't really think the shock from The Crying Game is worthy of all the attention it received. I think The Sixth Sense was much more of a trick on the viewer which completely makes or breaks the movie.
The odd thing is that even to this day I don't really think the shock from The Crying Game is worthy of all the attention it received. I think The Sixth Sense was much more of a trick on the viewer which completely makes or breaks the movie.
#112
DVD Talk Reviewer/Moderator
Joined: Jul 2007
Posts: 17,322
Received 2,732 Likes
on
1,760 Posts
From: Formerly known as L. Ron zyzzle - On a cloud of Judgement
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
Friendly piece of advice?
You won't last very long here insulting forum members, standards or rules. I suggest lightening up a tad.
That having been said, a general thread ABOUT spoilers is NOT a license to spoil movies without reserve. Otherwise, I'd have no inhibition to tell everyone the aliens in MONSTERS VS. ALIENS were actually clones of monsters the government kept in hiding, the ghost in THE HAUNTING IN CONNECTICUT is actually the neighbor's still-alive missing son, the premonitions in KNOWING are actually not from the past but from a parallel Earth, the secret of the WATCHMEN is that the killer is actually a separate identity constructed by Dr. Manhatten, and that the guy who actually arranged for the kidnapping in TAKEN was Liam Neeson's old Army buddy.
And in case you're shocked and flabbergasted, all the spoilers in the previous paragraph are bullshit. I made them up outta nothing just to make a point.
You won't last very long here insulting forum members, standards or rules. I suggest lightening up a tad.
That having been said, a general thread ABOUT spoilers is NOT a license to spoil movies without reserve. Otherwise, I'd have no inhibition to tell everyone the aliens in MONSTERS VS. ALIENS were actually clones of monsters the government kept in hiding, the ghost in THE HAUNTING IN CONNECTICUT is actually the neighbor's still-alive missing son, the premonitions in KNOWING are actually not from the past but from a parallel Earth, the secret of the WATCHMEN is that the killer is actually a separate identity constructed by Dr. Manhatten, and that the guy who actually arranged for the kidnapping in TAKEN was Liam Neeson's old Army buddy.
And in case you're shocked and flabbergasted, all the spoilers in the previous paragraph are bullshit. I made them up outta nothing just to make a point.
Damn! I thought I'd just gotten a free pass to skip some of those movies (esp. Haunting in Connecticut - your version sounds much better than what's apparently in theaters now).
#113
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
Saw 3
I was reading Comic Con news on Zap2it. They had a page of topics/headlines listed of the day's news. One of them was for Saw 4, but they mentioned a Saw 3 spoiler. The spoiler was in the headline. So it's not like I wanted to read news on Saw 4 and set up myself for a Saw 3 spoiler. They just put it out there.
not too terrible, but shameful for Zap2it.
Spoiler:
I was reading Comic Con news on Zap2it. They had a page of topics/headlines listed of the day's news. One of them was for Saw 4, but they mentioned a Saw 3 spoiler. The spoiler was in the headline. So it's not like I wanted to read news on Saw 4 and set up myself for a Saw 3 spoiler. They just put it out there.
not too terrible, but shameful for Zap2it.
#114
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I was reminded of a somewhat subtle spoiler from my childhood recently. In the poster for The Transformers: The Movie,
Granted, it's kind of small and your attention really isn't drawn to it at first. And, going into the movie, no one knew what his transformed mode looked like, anyway; by the time we saw it in the film, we had long since forgotten what it looked like in the poster.
Still, after I saw the movie, I eyed that poster image until eventually my seven year old brain realized the spoiler. I was annoyed, even then, that they would show something from the end of the movie like that.
Spoiler:
Granted, it's kind of small and your attention really isn't drawn to it at first. And, going into the movie, no one knew what his transformed mode looked like, anyway; by the time we saw it in the film, we had long since forgotten what it looked like in the poster.
Still, after I saw the movie, I eyed that poster image until eventually my seven year old brain realized the spoiler. I was annoyed, even then, that they would show something from the end of the movie like that.
#115
Banned by request
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
Mod Note: Bärpfeife, it is unacceptable to insult or attack other members of this forum. Calling people "morons" is not a good way to get started at DVD Talk. Reconsider your posting choices or your stay here will be short lived.
#116
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I thought it was really stupid that Entertainment Weekly revealed the ending of I believe "LOST" Season 4 on the front cover the summer after it had aired. I don't watch the show, and in the magazine would be one thing, but on the cover? Not everyone is able to catch the episodes on TV.
I can't say I felt too bad about it, but I remember being in a Sam Goody in late April 1999 and there was an Episode I children's book sitting on the rack, so I was idly flipping through it, and the last page was
and I said "damn it" to myself.
The endings to The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, The Village, Lady in the Water and The Happening were all revealed to me prior to my seeing them (although I still haven't actually seen Lady in the Water or The Happening). I was most disappointed knowing the ending to Unbreakable.
A "Mystery Science Theater 3000" episode (I think "Time Chasers", a great episode) spoils the ending to The Usual Suspects. I can't actually remember my first viewing of the movie very clearly, but I feel like I knew the ending, and I know that episode spoils it, so it was probably for that reason, but I'm not sure.
I can't say I felt too bad about it, but I remember being in a Sam Goody in late April 1999 and there was an Episode I children's book sitting on the rack, so I was idly flipping through it, and the last page was
Spoiler:
The endings to The Sixth Sense, Unbreakable, The Village, Lady in the Water and The Happening were all revealed to me prior to my seeing them (although I still haven't actually seen Lady in the Water or The Happening). I was most disappointed knowing the ending to Unbreakable.
A "Mystery Science Theater 3000" episode (I think "Time Chasers", a great episode) spoils the ending to The Usual Suspects. I can't actually remember my first viewing of the movie very clearly, but I feel like I knew the ending, and I know that episode spoils it, so it was probably for that reason, but I'm not sure.
Last edited by tylergfoster; 03-30-09 at 05:54 AM.
#117
DVD Talk Godfather
#118
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I was watching Reno 911 and in one scene a guy was talking to the Jones and Dangle about movies and he started talking about a sounded like a surprise ending for "Don't Look Now". I fumbled for the remote and changed it real quick. I still don't know if the film has a shocking ending but since i'm an idiot and have waited so long to watch such a horror classic I honestly don't want it ruined.
#119
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Jun 2002
Posts: 8,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I was watching Reno 911 and in one scene a guy was talking to the Jones and Dangle about movies and he started talking about a sounded like a surprise ending for "Don't Look Now". I fumbled for the remote and changed it real quick. I still don't know if the film has a shocking ending but since i'm an idiot and have waited so long to watch such a horror classic I honestly don't want it ruined.
#120
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
I was watching Reno 911 and in one scene a guy was talking to the Jones and Dangle about movies and he started talking about a sounded like a surprise ending for "Don't Look Now". I fumbled for the remote and changed it real quick. I still don't know if the film has a shocking ending but since i'm an idiot and have waited so long to watch such a horror classic I honestly don't want it ruined.
* Total BS spoiler again. I'm on a roll here...
#121
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
DONT LOOK NOW is a great movie, but I don't think knowing anything abuot the ending can significantly impact one's enjoyment of it. It's more about tone and foreshadowing and subtle, psychological terror than what the big "plot twist" is (if there is one, and I'm not saying one way or another). Although I must say, I love when Donald Sutherland is revealed as being his own uncle. That scene ROCKS! *
#122
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
A classic twist, indeed. Almost as good as "Murder On The Orient Express", where EVERYBODY on the train turned out to be Kaiser Soze.
#123
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
^A yes a classic twist indeed. How about The Departed, when at the end Leo and Matt Damon get totally gay on eachother and Jack Nicholsan films it? That was something intriguing that I never thought I'd see in a Scorcese flick.
#125
Cool New Member
Joined: Mar 2009
Posts: 26
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Your most terrible experiences of films being spoiled
Originally posted by Suprmallet
Mod Note: Bärpfeife, it is unacceptable to insult or attack other members of this forum. Calling people "morons" is not a good way to get started at DVD Talk. Reconsider your posting choices or your stay here will be short lived.
Mod Note: Bärpfeife, it is unacceptable to insult or attack other members of this forum. Calling people "morons" is not a good way to get started at DVD Talk. Reconsider your posting choices or your stay here will be short lived.
I don't recall attacking anyone, I was merely making a general observation. Even so, I will indulge you and rearticulate the word moron, and employ oxymoron in its place. And yes, I see it as oxymoronic to admonish someone for spoiling a spoiler; as it were. And those who are hypersensitive to being spoiled should perhaps distance themselves from high risk spoiler thread spoilers
. Anyway, most should be able to handle this small insignificant pustule of basic common sense.



