Really, really glad to see City Lights go so high. A wonderful film. Top five material actually.

I really figured Shawshank would be in the top 20.

City Lights and The Searchers moved a ton, so maybe there is hope for Fargo.

Where is Raging Bull? Is it going to make the top 10 or is it gone?

Is that what it is? Thanks.

Yeah, good for Searchers and City Lights, they'd both be in my Top 10.

City Lights deserves it, but did they bump The Third Man??

raging bull is probably in the top 10.. both the graduate and on the waterfront dropped from the top 10.

With the exception of a few position changes ("Deer Hunter" moving up, "Dr. Strangelove" moving down, etc.) that I disagree with, I like this new list much better than the original one.

Spielberg's on the show, so I don't think Schindler's got bumped.

Here's a list of movies that look like were bumped from the last list.

Guess Who's Coming to Dinner?
Fargo
A Place in the Sun
The Jazz Singer
Patton
Frankenstein
Mutiny on the Bounty
Giant
Dances With Wolves
Wuthering Heights
An American in Paris
The Manchurian Candidate
Stagecoach
A Rebel Without a Cause
All Quiet on the Western Front
Fantasia
Amadeus
From Here to Eternity
Doctor Zhivago
The Third Man

Maybe Eternal Sunshine of the Spotless Mind made the list, what do you guys think?

Nope, it was made after LOTR

Good up for Vertigo, my favorite H. movie.

oh I didn't read all the posts in there, did they mention that LOTR was the most recent movie out there?

yeah they did

The Godfather to be the new no.1

Wouldn't be surprised, they already showed a commercial for the box set that's been out for years.

yeah, or Casablanca

I think it will be Casablanca

whoo raging bull #5

or #4 actually

#3, actually fell a spot. Still my #1

So I'm assuming it's Citizen Kane vs. The Godfather for #1?

Can't believe they dumped The Third Man. Maybe they figured it wasn't American? And why no love for James Dean? They bumped 2 of his movies off the list. Giant is a great movie, it's a shame.

Please be the Godfather, I think Citizen Kane is amazing but their is only one Godfather (well actually 3...2 in some minds)