Who was the definitive actor of each decade?
#52
Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Um, it's 2006 and the general public STILL has no idea who Philip Seymour Hoffman is. Nice try but he doesn't even come close.
#54
DVD Talk Gold Edition
I'll follow-up my earlier "actors" list with this one for "actresses":
1930's - Myrna Loy
1940's - Greer Garson
1950's - Marilyn Monroe
1960's - Angie Dickinson
1970's - Barbra Streisand
1980's - Sigourney Weaver
1930's - Myrna Loy
1940's - Greer Garson
1950's - Marilyn Monroe
1960's - Angie Dickinson
1970's - Barbra Streisand
1980's - Sigourney Weaver
#55
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Jun 2004
Posts: 6,290
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
2000s: Paul Bettany
1990s: Michael Keaton
1980s: Tom Cruise
1970s: Robert Forster
1960s: Marcello Mastroianni
1950s: Leslie Neilson
1940s: Robert Montgomery
1930s: Gary Cooper
1920s: George O'Brian
1910s: Eric Campbell
1990s: Michael Keaton
1980s: Tom Cruise
1970s: Robert Forster
1960s: Marcello Mastroianni
1950s: Leslie Neilson
1940s: Robert Montgomery
1930s: Gary Cooper
1920s: George O'Brian
1910s: Eric Campbell
#58
DVD Talk Limited Edition
This is really hard to say, but:
1920's - Douglas Fairbanks Sr.
1930's - Clark Gable (Gone with the Wind 1939, need I say more)
1940's - Cary Grant (His awards came from 1942 and beyond and he belongs on this list)
1950's - John Wayne (Love his westerns)
1960's - Sidney Poitier (Man with character crossed the color line, changed movies)
1970's - Robert De Niro (God Father and many others)
1980's - Harrison Ford (To many fun, great movies everyone went to see)
1990's - Tom Hanks (To many fun, great movies everyone went to see)
2000's - No one
1920's - Douglas Fairbanks Sr.
1930's - Clark Gable (Gone with the Wind 1939, need I say more)
1940's - Cary Grant (His awards came from 1942 and beyond and he belongs on this list)
1950's - John Wayne (Love his westerns)
1960's - Sidney Poitier (Man with character crossed the color line, changed movies)
1970's - Robert De Niro (God Father and many others)
1980's - Harrison Ford (To many fun, great movies everyone went to see)
1990's - Tom Hanks (To many fun, great movies everyone went to see)
2000's - No one
#59
Originally Posted by Mr. Cinema
That Oscar he won should help. also, this isn't a popularity thread, right?
#60
Premium Member
Joined: Jan 2000
Posts: 25,177
Received 1,221 Likes
on
790 Posts
From: Grazing in a field somewhere...
Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Yeah I'm pretty sure it is. How else would no-talent-acting-wise Harrison Ford be on the top of everyone's list?
#61
Originally Posted by The Cow
pretty much like Brad Pitt and Russell Crowe.
#62
DVD Talk Legend
Some pretty funny responses here and some pretty ridiculous choices also.
I thought this thread was about definitive actors for each decade?
Schwarzenegger, Stallone, Ford, Cruise.....
Granted they were superstars, but in reguards to acting chops nowhere near the definitive actors in their respective decades.
I'll go with.....
40's- Bogart
50's- Brando
60's- Poiter
70's -Nicholson
80's- DeNiro
90's- Hanks
00's- Norton
I thought this thread was about definitive actors for each decade?
Schwarzenegger, Stallone, Ford, Cruise.....
Granted they were superstars, but in reguards to acting chops nowhere near the definitive actors in their respective decades.
I'll go with.....
40's- Bogart
50's- Brando
60's- Poiter
70's -Nicholson
80's- DeNiro
90's- Hanks
00's- Norton
#63
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 5,320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt
I'm not sure I'd pick Harrison Ford for ANY decade. Sure, he made a lot of popular films, but was he really the best ACTOR out there? He's pretty much a one-note actor...he doesn't have a lot of range. I love his movies, but I've never thought of him as a "great" actor.
Harrison Ford IS Jack Ryan
Harrison Ford IS Han Solo
Harrison Ford IS Indiana Jones
And so on, and so on. Ford takes each character and makes them notably different from the others that he plays.
On the other hand, Will Ferrell is.... Will Ferrell.
If you want a one-note actor with no range, Ferrell is your man. Every character he plays is the exact same thing - Will Ferrell playing his usual stupid act in a new set of clothing.
Now maybe he'll surprise me and do something different. Jim Carrey had this same problem, a string of comedies where he was basically the same guy in different situations. Then he came out with a damned good performance in Man on the Moon, and some other non-slapstick roles and demonstrated that he did have some range to the characters he could play.
#65
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by JumpCutz
I thought this thread was about definitive actors for each decade?
Schwarzenegger, Stallone, Ford, Cruise.....
Granted they were superstars, but in reguards to acting chops nowhere near the definitive actors in their respective decades.
Schwarzenegger, Stallone, Ford, Cruise.....
Granted they were superstars, but in reguards to acting chops nowhere near the definitive actors in their respective decades.
With that in mind, my list is pretty similar to others. For some there is no question in my mind, but I noted some I had a little trouble deciding on.
1930s: Clark Gable
1940s: Humphrey Bogart
1950s: James Stewart<sup>1</sup>
1960s: Paul Newman
1970s: Jack Nicholson<sup>2</sup>
1980s: Tom Cruise<sup>3</sup>
1990s: Tom Hanks<sup>4</sup>
2000s: Too early to tell
1. I debated quite a bit on this one. I also thought Cary Grant and John Wayne deserved recognition someplace on the list, but ultimately I couldn't find a place.
2. This was tough as well, but I think everyone agrees that it's really just between Nicholson, Pacino, and De Niro. I think just as the '60s began in '63 with Kennedy's assassination, Nicholson's career spans and typifies the '70s "era" in cinema, from Easy Rider to The Shining.
3. Debated a bit on this one, too. Schwarzeneggar could have easily fit here. Since I know this choice might get some flak, think of Cruise in the '80s: Risky Business, Top Gun, Cocktail, Rain Man, Born on the Fourth of July, and I would throw in Days of Thunder in there as well (see my note above).
4. Hate to admit it, but it's true.
Last edited by Breakfast with Girls; 08-06-06 at 12:01 AM.
#66
Senior Member
Originally Posted by MovieExchange
I'd have to disagree there. Ford is one of my favorite comparisons in my "why I hate Will Ferrell movies" rant.
Harrison Ford IS Jack Ryan
Harrison Ford IS Han Solo
Harrison Ford IS Indiana Jones
And so on, and so on. Ford takes each character and makes them notably different from the others that he plays.
On the other hand, Will Ferrell is.... Will Ferrell.
If you want a one-note actor with no range, Ferrell is your man. Every character he plays is the exact same thing - Will Ferrell playing his usual stupid act in a new set of clothing.
Now maybe he'll surprise me and do something different. Jim Carrey had this same problem, a string of comedies where he was basically the same guy in different situations. Then he came out with a damned good performance in Man on the Moon, and some other non-slapstick roles and demonstrated that he did have some range to the characters he could play.
Harrison Ford IS Jack Ryan
Harrison Ford IS Han Solo
Harrison Ford IS Indiana Jones
And so on, and so on. Ford takes each character and makes them notably different from the others that he plays.
On the other hand, Will Ferrell is.... Will Ferrell.
If you want a one-note actor with no range, Ferrell is your man. Every character he plays is the exact same thing - Will Ferrell playing his usual stupid act in a new set of clothing.
Now maybe he'll surprise me and do something different. Jim Carrey had this same problem, a string of comedies where he was basically the same guy in different situations. Then he came out with a damned good performance in Man on the Moon, and some other non-slapstick roles and demonstrated that he did have some range to the characters he could play.
Meh. Ford is definately leagues ahead of Will Ferrel but he's still pretty one-dimensional as far as I'm concerned. Jack Ryan, Han Solo, Indiana Jones... I can already see the vast similarities. Ford is in that same state where he essentially palys himself over and over again, like Tom Cruise or Brad Pitt. They're all still great actors they just don't have the depth and changeling qualities of say... a Johnny Depp or Gary Oldman. To me, the latter is the truer art form that is "acting."
#67
DVD Talk Hero
Originally Posted by MASAMUNE2
Meh. Ford is definately leagues ahead of Will Ferrel but he's still pretty one-dimensional as far as I'm concerned. Jack Ryan, Han Solo, Indiana Jones... I can already see the vast similarities. Ford is in that same state where he essentially palys himself over and over again, like Tom Cruise or Brad Pitt. They're all still great actors they just don't have the depth and changeling qualities of say... a Johnny Depp or Gary Oldman. To me, the latter is the truer art form that is "acting."
But I have to disagree with you about Tom Cruise. As weird as he may be in real life, I think he's one of the best actors of our generation! See Born of the Fourth of July, Magnolia, The Color of Money, The Firm for just a few examples.
#68
Originally Posted by MASAMUNE2
Meh. Ford is definately leagues ahead of Will Ferrel but he's still pretty one-dimensional as far as I'm concerned. Jack Ryan, Han Solo, Indiana Jones... I can already see the vast similarities. Ford is in that same state where he essentially palys himself over and over again, like Tom Cruise or Brad Pitt. They're all still great actors they just don't have the depth and changeling qualities of say... a Johnny Depp or Gary Oldman. To me, the latter is the truer art form that is "acting."
#69
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally Posted by rw2516
They may not have been very artistic but Bond movies owned the 60s. The release of a Connery Bond was as big a deal as Empire Strikes Back in '80 or Jedi in '81. Stores would have an entire aisle devoted to James Bond toys and action figures. The media blitz was so huge Connery couldn't take a shit without the whole world knowing about it.Ticket sales, adjusted for inflation come to nearly $1 billion in world wide gross per movie for Thunderball through Diamonds Are Forever. The 60s was the spy decade do to the success of Bond with all kinds of imitation movies and tv series. From 64 to the end of the decade Connery was the biggest movie star in the world, and one of the highest paid. When he agreed to play Bond in Diamonds Are Forever, his $1 million fee was the highest ever paid to an actor to appear in a movie.
I think that people are just putting the actor they happen to like into the slots.
It's not the best actor in the decade that's the issue here. The guy that ruled the decade, defines it.
And Connery ruled the 60's. It's not even close. Thunderball played for several MONTHS at movie houses. Goldfinger was huge with lines going around the block in London and NYC. Immigrants in London demonstrated against what they felt were high tickets prices to the film.
Guys wanted to be Connery and women wanted to be with him. Star power through the roof.
Btw, props to the OP. Well thought out initial list.
Last edited by ctyankee; 08-06-06 at 05:51 PM.
#72
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Matt Millheiser
I've said it before and I will say it until the end of time. If Harrison Ford had not turned down the Michael Douglas role in Traffic, he would have won an Oscar that year.

Surely you jest.
#73
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by JumpCutz

Surely you jest.
Generally beloved actor who specialized in larger-than-life action-hero roles doing a "serious" role in a "serious" movie with a "serious" director? It would have been a LOCK. Money in the bank, I'm telling you.
Nah, but he made the right move, doing K-19: The Widowmaker instead.
#74
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 761
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why are people mentioning Ed Norton for the 2000s?
Keeping The Faith
The Score
Death to Smoochy
Red Dragon
25th Hour
Italian Job
I doubt more than 2 of those will even be remembered in 20 years.
Keeping The Faith
The Score
Death to Smoochy
Red Dragon
25th Hour
Italian Job
I doubt more than 2 of those will even be remembered in 20 years.
#75
DVD Talk Special Edition
Actually now that I think about it, Johnny Depp is by far the most popular actor of this decade.
Here's how I break down the 80's, 90's and 00s:
Early 80's: Harrison Ford
Mid 80's: Sylvester Stallone, Eddie Murphy, Tom Cruise and Arnold Schwarzenegger
Late 80's: Tom Cruise, Eddie Murphy and Arnold Schwarzenegger
Early 90's: Kevin Costner and Arnold Schwarenegger
Mid 90's: Tom Hanks and Tom Cruise
Late 90's: Jim Carrey and Will Smith
Early '00s: Russell Crowe and Johnny Depp
Mid '00s: Johnny Depp rules everybody.
Here's how I break down the 80's, 90's and 00s:
Early 80's: Harrison Ford
Mid 80's: Sylvester Stallone, Eddie Murphy, Tom Cruise and Arnold Schwarzenegger
Late 80's: Tom Cruise, Eddie Murphy and Arnold Schwarzenegger
Early 90's: Kevin Costner and Arnold Schwarenegger
Mid 90's: Tom Hanks and Tom Cruise
Late 90's: Jim Carrey and Will Smith
Early '00s: Russell Crowe and Johnny Depp
Mid '00s: Johnny Depp rules everybody.
Last edited by Yeti4623; 10-01-06 at 03:36 AM.




