Who was the definitive actor of each decade?
#1
Who was the definitive actor of each decade?
If you had to pick only one actor that owned each decade & who best encompasses the mood of it, what would it be?
I'd pick
20s: Lon Chaney Sr. (silent king)
30s: Charley Chaplin
40s: Humphrey Bogart (obviously)
50s: Marlon Brando
60s: Sean Connery (Peter Sellers would be second)
70s: Al Pacino
80s: Harrison Ford (Schwarzenneger would be second)
90s: Tom Hanks
I'd pick
20s: Lon Chaney Sr. (silent king)
30s: Charley Chaplin
40s: Humphrey Bogart (obviously)
50s: Marlon Brando
60s: Sean Connery (Peter Sellers would be second)
70s: Al Pacino
80s: Harrison Ford (Schwarzenneger would be second)
90s: Tom Hanks
Last edited by FRwL; 01-15-09 at 02:55 AM.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 20,804
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Sean Connery? I would think someone like Paul Newman was more popular and had way better movies during the 60's.
Newman was the f'ing man.
#5
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Chaplain only made a few movies during the 30s (of very high quality of course) so I'd have to give the 30s title to someone with more credits. Clark Gable, maybe? Cary Grant, perhaps?
#6
Originally Posted by chess
Exactly what I was going to say. All Connery did was play Bond, and Sellers is frankly a bit out of left field.
Newman was the f'ing man.
Newman was the f'ing man.
#10
DVD Talk Legend
I'm not sure I'd pick Harrison Ford for ANY decade. Sure, he made a lot of popular films, but was he really the best ACTOR out there? He's pretty much a one-note actor...he doesn't have a lot of range. I love his movies, but I've never thought of him as a "great" actor.
Might want to give Pacino the 70s (Godfather films, Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon) and bump DeNiro into the 80s (Raging Bull, Once Upon A Time In America, The Untouchables).
EDIT: I guess the original poster was looking for the actors that best personified the decade...in that case, I suggest Stallone for the 80s.
Might want to give Pacino the 70s (Godfather films, Serpico, Dog Day Afternoon) and bump DeNiro into the 80s (Raging Bull, Once Upon A Time In America, The Untouchables).
EDIT: I guess the original poster was looking for the actors that best personified the decade...in that case, I suggest Stallone for the 80s.
Last edited by Shannon Nutt; 08-02-06 at 03:23 PM.
#11
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 20,804
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by FRwL
You'd be surprised at his non-Bond roles, Macbeth, a war film (memorable cameo anyway), a Hitchcock film, The Hill, A Fine Madness, a Western, versatile roles, proving he can go beyond Bond. It is my opinion of course. He's my favorite actor by the way.
#12
DVD Talk Legend
Join Date: Mar 2000
Location: San Antonio
Posts: 20,804
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Agree STRONGLY with the OP on Harrison Ford. Indy and Star Wars alone would make him a lock. I think he's in 5-6 of the top 20 rated films from the 80s on IMDB.
Stallone, with Rocky and Rambo certainly did capture the essence of the 80s though, didn't he?
Stallone, with Rocky and Rambo certainly did capture the essence of the 80s though, didn't he?
#13
Member
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 202
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Nice list and a nice topic to think about.
I would agree in the 30s that Grant would be a stronger pick,
40s and 50s hard to argue ,
While I do like connery a lot I would have to give the nod to probably Henry Fonda or possibly Steve McQueen,
The seventies hard to argue with De Niro, Pacino, or even Nicholson for that matter but I just wanted to get a mention in with Dustin Hoffman who did some of his big name movies in late 60s right through Kramer and Kramer in the late 70s.
The 80s I was trying to think of someone besides Ford. While I dont think he is the "best' actor of the 80s it is hard to argue with his string of AWSOME films. Arnie would not even be on my list, in fact I would consider someone like Bill Murray before him.
90s-- I agree the modern day Jimmy stewart
I would agree in the 30s that Grant would be a stronger pick,
40s and 50s hard to argue ,
While I do like connery a lot I would have to give the nod to probably Henry Fonda or possibly Steve McQueen,
The seventies hard to argue with De Niro, Pacino, or even Nicholson for that matter but I just wanted to get a mention in with Dustin Hoffman who did some of his big name movies in late 60s right through Kramer and Kramer in the late 70s.
The 80s I was trying to think of someone besides Ford. While I dont think he is the "best' actor of the 80s it is hard to argue with his string of AWSOME films. Arnie would not even be on my list, in fact I would consider someone like Bill Murray before him.
90s-- I agree the modern day Jimmy stewart
#15
Originally Posted by Shannon Nutt
I'm not sure I'd pick Harrison Ford for ANY decade. Sure, he made a lot of popular films, but was he really the best ACTOR out there? He's pretty much a one-note actor...he doesn't have a lot of range. I love his movies, but I've never thought of him as a "great" actor.
#17
DVD Talk Legend
From a mainstream, overall popularity perspective:
For comedies:
60s - Jerry Lewis (alt. Peter Sellers)
70s - Richard Pryor (alt. Gene Wilder)
80s - Eddie Murphy (alt. Bill Murray)
90s - Jim Carrey (alt. Mike Myers)
00s - Ben Stiller (alt. Adam Sandler)
For comedies:
60s - Jerry Lewis (alt. Peter Sellers)
70s - Richard Pryor (alt. Gene Wilder)
80s - Eddie Murphy (alt. Bill Murray)
90s - Jim Carrey (alt. Mike Myers)
00s - Ben Stiller (alt. Adam Sandler)
#18
Senior Member
Join Date: Apr 1999
Location: AnyTown, AnyState USA
Posts: 717
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
When I think of 80's movies superstar, first name to pop up is Stallone & Arnold. Yeah Ford was in all the blockbusters, but you saw them because it was a Star Wars or Indy movie. You put any other actor, you'd still go see it because it was SW or Indy. Plus Indy had Spielberg's name on it. But Stallone & Arnold you went to see the movie for them, not the movie itself. Cobra, Over the Top would be straight to video if it wasn't for Stallone.
#19
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
Sean Connery? I would think someone like Paul Newman was more popular and had way better movies during the 60's.
#20
Changes I'd make to the first list:
Cary Grant for the 30's
Chaplin is still on the list ... for the 10's (that's when he made most of those "Little Tramp" films)
60's I'm not sure of, but I wouldn't say Connery. Newman and McQueen are good choices.
80's -- definitely Arnold ... quintesential 80's.
Cary Grant for the 30's
Chaplin is still on the list ... for the 10's (that's when he made most of those "Little Tramp" films)
60's I'm not sure of, but I wouldn't say Connery. Newman and McQueen are good choices.
80's -- definitely Arnold ... quintesential 80's.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by FRwL
He's my favorite actor by the way.
1930s
Charlie Chaplin made two silent films during the 1930s. He was an anachronism.
Apart from the Sound vs Silent issue, he was an artist pursuing a personal vision in his filmmaking during a deacde in which film production was dominated by the factory mentality of the studios.
You may have heard of an actor named Clark Gable, the King of Hollywood.
1940s
No argument with Bogie.
1950s
Any answer that is not Marlon Brando is ridiculous.
Not answering Marlon Brando to the question "What actor owned the 50s?" is like not answering Hitler to the question "What dictator owned the 30s?".
1960s
Sean Connery? He played James Bond, and that means he owned the decade?
How about maybe Steve McQueen or, as a previously suggested, Paul Newman.
1970s
DeNiro is a great actor, but what mood of the 70s does he encompass?
The mood of the 70s?
How about: Disillusionment with, distrust of, cynicism about-- the establishment, the government, authority of any kind.
I could go with Pacino, who has a resume of great films that address those themes...
But I'll take Nicholson because he has the same kind of resume, and with Carnal Knowledge, he also has a film that addresses the questions about sexuality that are a part of the mood of the 70s.
And in his personal life, Jack was a personification of the "If it feels good, do it" sexual ethos.
#22
DVD Talk Limited Edition
1940's: Sure Bogart, why not.
1950's: I wasn't alive but from everything I've ever heard Brando was it.
1960's: I'm not sure, not Sean Connery though. Probably Steve McQueen.
1970's: Al Pacino. I know at the time I thought he was the greatest actor, maybe ever. Too bad he sucks now. Jack Nicholson is actually a pretty good choice too, especially if you could throw in some of his 60's stuff.
For the 80's: Arnold was the man--every movie he was in was an event.
For the 90's: I guess it has to be Tom Hanks as much as anyone, but that seems like such a boring choice.
For the 2000's: I have no idea.
1950's: I wasn't alive but from everything I've ever heard Brando was it.
1960's: I'm not sure, not Sean Connery though. Probably Steve McQueen.
1970's: Al Pacino. I know at the time I thought he was the greatest actor, maybe ever. Too bad he sucks now. Jack Nicholson is actually a pretty good choice too, especially if you could throw in some of his 60's stuff.
For the 80's: Arnold was the man--every movie he was in was an event.
For the 90's: I guess it has to be Tom Hanks as much as anyone, but that seems like such a boring choice.
For the 2000's: I have no idea.
Last edited by Ginwen; 08-02-06 at 04:56 PM.
#23
Originally Posted by masbrad
The seventies hard to argue with De Niro, Pacino, or even Nicholson for that matter but I just wanted to get a mention in with Dustin Hoffman who did some of his big name movies in late 60s right through Kramer and Kramer in the late 70s.
#25
Originally Posted by Count Dooku
So, you're not actually interested the question you put forth --"actor that owned each decade & who best encompasses the mood of it"-- but instead wanted an opportunity to post a Things I Like list.
I'd swap off Chaplin from the 30s now, and it's a close one with the #2 (Stewart) and #3 (Brando) greatest actors on AFI's list both having their best decade during the 50s, however there can only be one and i'd still give it to Stewart, one of the rare actors to achieve greatness without taking the dark, moody, and gritty route.