DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Good for Jamie Foxx (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/411926-good-jamie-foxx.html)

PJsig08 02-28-05 04:05 PM

Good for Jamie Foxx
 
He deserved it, what a great movie and great performance. After the Academy snubbed Bill Murray last year, I was happy to see Jamie win it this time. Even in Ali, he was amazing.

Let's hope he doesn't go to crap now...

Cameron 02-28-05 04:16 PM

FIXED


Originally Posted by PJsig08
Let's hope he doesn't go back to crap now...

http://images.amazon.com/images/P/07...1.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

jaeufraser 02-28-05 04:19 PM

Dude, Booty Call was the shit. That crap was funny.

But he is starring in the upcoming movie Stealth, which looks to suck. I'm sure he'll do some quality stuff in the future though.

scott shelton 02-28-05 04:20 PM


Originally Posted by Cameron

:lol:

So very true...

People tend to forget he made THREE movies last year. It wasn't all rosy for him.

And to follow up this Oscar win with STEALTH? Ouch. Not since Michael Caine...

eXcentris 02-28-05 05:09 PM


Originally Posted by PJsig08
Even in Ali, he was amazing.

That was Will Smith.













...;)...

eXcentris 02-28-05 05:13 PM

Personally, I was convinced of Jamie Foxx's talent after seeing
Redemption: The Stan Tookie Williams Story.

Sessa17 02-28-05 05:15 PM

I'm sorry but I think Fox is so overrated I just want to vomit at all of the praise for this guy. I know it's not trendy right now & it's "PC" to be in love with this guy, but anyone, I mean ANYONE who was playing that role in Ray was going to win the Oscar, it's just the way the industy is nowadays.

Fox is a flavor of the month, if he is still getting praise 10 years from now then I take that back. Yeah, he was good in Ray, absolutely, but not the best performance of the year & Collateral was one of the most overrated performances I've ever seen, countless actors could have played that role.

Fok 02-28-05 05:23 PM

I thought he deserved the win, time will tell as to see how well his movies hold up in a few years.

DonnachaOne 02-28-05 05:27 PM


Originally Posted by scott shelton
And to follow up this Oscar win with STEALTH? Ouch. Not since Michael Caine...

Let's not forget Hilary Swank! Who else is looking forward to The Core II?

Spanky BananaPants 02-28-05 05:37 PM


Originally Posted by Sessa17
anyone, I mean ANYONE who was playing that role in Ray was going to win the Oscar, it's just the way the industy is nowadays.

I can guarantee you that if I had been playing Ray, there would've been no Oscar for me.

Sessa17 02-28-05 06:19 PM


Originally Posted by Spanky BananaPants
I can guarantee you that if I had been playing Ray, there would've been no Oscar for me.

If you fit the decription & were an actual actor, then yes, you would have still won the Oscar. In today's movie business, that role was custom made to win an Oscar.

OldBoy 02-28-05 06:33 PM


Originally Posted by eXcentris
That was Will Smith

i hope ur kidding.

InnerCityBlues 02-28-05 06:46 PM


Originally Posted by eXcentris

Originally Posted by PJsig08
Even in Ali, he was amazing.

That was Will Smith.

Jamie Foxx was in Ali, but it was for the role as Drew 'Bundini' Brown. But yes, Will Smith did play the lead role of Muhammad Ali.

I thought Foxx's speech was wonderful and I think he definitely deserved to win for best actor. I also wanted Cheadle to win because I feel he is so underrated and does not get the roles he deserves.

devilshalo 02-28-05 06:52 PM


Originally Posted by Sessa17
If you fit the decription & were an actual actor, then yes, you would have still won the Oscar. In today's movie business, that role was custom made to win an Oscar.

Then where the hell was Eddie Murphy?! :mad:

:p

I don't particularly like characters that are real. Too much reference material on hand to tailor a performance around. It's basically doing an awesome imitation of the person. There's no originality in it. And that Ray Charles actually helped to coach Foxx, it just doesn't seem right that he won an Oscar. I don't doubt his perfomance by any means, but there wasn't anything original about it.

chente 02-28-05 06:55 PM


Originally Posted by Sessa17
I'm sorry but I think Fox is so overrated I just want to vomit at all of the praise for this guy. I know it's not trendy right now & it's "PC" to be in love with this guy, but anyone, I mean ANYONE who was playing that role in Ray was going to win the Oscar, it's just the way the industy is nowadays.

I don't agree, he was very good in Ray. What do you mean by it's "PC" to be in love with this guy?

eXcentris 02-28-05 07:03 PM


Originally Posted by scott1598
i hope ur kidding.


Yes. :)

eXcentris 02-28-05 07:07 PM

Some of you guys are on crack. This silly notion that "anybody playing Ray Charles would have won the Oscar" is just preposterous. He didn't imitate Ray Charles he was Ray Charles. There's a huge difference between the two.

j123vt_99 02-28-05 07:40 PM


Originally Posted by eXcentris
Some of you guys are on crack. This silly notion that "anybody playing Ray Charles would have won the Oscar" is just preposterous. He didn't imitate Ray Charles he was Ray Charles. There's a huge difference between the two.


you are saying people are on crack??? foxx is an actor.. he played somebody else... he pretended... did he do a good job? sure... but he was essentially playing make believe

eXcentris 02-28-05 07:52 PM


Originally Posted by j123vt_99
you are saying people are on crack??? foxx is an actor.. he played somebody else... he pretended... did he do a good job? sure... but he was essentially playing make believe

Noooooooo! Foxx is an actor? So he wasn't REALLY Ray Charles? Thanks for clearing that up!

Now if you could just clear up what the heck this has to do with what I posted previously, that would be great. :)

j123vt_99 02-28-05 08:02 PM


Originally Posted by eXcentris
Noooooooo! Foxx is an actor? So he wasn't REALLY Ray Charles? Thanks for clearing that up!

Now if you could just clear up what the heck this has to do with what I posted previously, that would be great. :)

don't want to get into a fight,.. you said foxx was Ray Charles... i think he was far from it.. he was himself pretending to be Ray.. no biggie

Ketamine 02-28-05 08:27 PM


Originally Posted by j123vt_99
don't want to get into a fight,.. you said foxx was Ray Charles... i think he was far from it.. he was himself pretending to be Ray.. no biggie

Many of Ray's close friends and even his son said Foxx was Ray in this movie. I think that is worth something.

jaeufraser 02-28-05 08:29 PM


Originally Posted by j123vt_99
don't want to get into a fight,.. you said foxx was Ray Charles... i think he was far from it.. he was himself pretending to be Ray.. no biggie

Well, it's a little silly to point out Jamie Foxx was actually acting. Everyone knows that...saying he was Ray Charles is merely a way of saying he fucking nailed the part. I for one agree with that assessment.

Slow Hands 02-28-05 08:42 PM


Originally Posted by eXcentris
That was Will Smith.

Jamie Foxx was in Ali too he was the trainer.

devilshalo 02-28-05 08:55 PM


Originally Posted by Ketamine
Many of Ray's close friends and even his son said Foxx was Ray in this movie. I think that is worth something.


Originally Posted by jaeufraser
Well, it's a little silly to point out Jamie Foxx was actually acting. Everyone knows that...saying he was Ray Charles is merely a way of saying he fucking nailed the part. I for one agree with that assessment.

Would it be a different performance if Ray had died before filming ever started? I mean, if I had Ray Charles coaching me on being Ray Charles, I'd pull off something pretty damn_close.

Ketamine 02-28-05 09:01 PM


Originally Posted by devilshalo
Would it be a different performance if Ray had died before filming ever started? I mean, if I had Ray Charles coaching me on being Ray Charles, I'd pull off something pretty damn_close.

You must be talented enough to win yourself an Oscar then. Good luck to you. Remember your friends at DVDTalk when you make it big.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:55 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.