DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   Gans to direct Silent Hill (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/386457-gans-direct-silent-hill.html)

SPiRAL 04-23-06 07:10 PM

I saw the SH poster awhile back and instantly thought the girl looks like Alexis Bledel ( Gilmore Girls ) in her Chilton uniform with her mouth blurred-out. I saw the movie today, and thought it was good visually and atmospherically. I also thought it was kind of boring, and not very scary.

P.S. Another :thumbsup: for Pyramid Head.

sethsez 04-23-06 07:15 PM

Hopefully the sequel (and if it does well, there will be a sequel since everyone involved wants to do one) will be better now that the whole ridiculous "origin of Silent Hill" story has been told.

sureAV421 04-23-06 07:20 PM

'Silent Hill' Scares Off 'Scary Movie'

By DAVID GERMAIN, AP Movie Writer 46 minutes ago

LOS ANGELES - A real scary movie bumped off the spoof variety at the box office. Sony's fright flick "Silent Hill," set in an eerie ghost town, debuted with $20.2 million.
ADVERTISEMENT
Adblock

It took over the top spot from the Weinstein Co. comedy "Scary Movie 4," which slipped to No. 2 with $17 million in its second weekend, according to studio estimates Sunday.

The White House assassination tale "The Sentinel," a 20th Century Fox thriller starring
Michael Douglas,
Kiefer Sutherland and
Eva Longoria, opened in third place with $14.65 million.

The weekend's other new major debut, Universal's George W. Bush-"American Idol" parody "American Dreamz" featuring
Dennis Quaid and
Hugh Grant, debuted a weak No. 8 with $3.7 million.

After two weekends in limited release,
Jennifer Aniston's comic drama "Friends With Money" expanded nationwide and came in at No. 10 with $3.55 million. Aniston plays a down-on-her-luck housecleaner with three well-to-do pals (
Frances McDormand,
Catherine Keener and
Joan Cusack).

Lifted by box-office leaders that included 20th Century Fox's animated hit "Ice Age: The Meltdown" at No. 4 with $12.8 million, Hollywood revenues rose for the fifth-straight weekend.

The top-12 movies took in $100.4 million, up 22 percent from the same weekend last year, when "The Interpreter" debuted at No. 1 with $22.8 million.

After a prolonged dry spell in 2005, when movie attendance fell 8 percent, Hollywood is on solid footing this year heading into a potentially big summer. A surge over the past month has attendance running 4 percent ahead of last year's, said Paul Dergarabedian, president of box-office tracker Exhibitor Relations.

"This is exactly where the industry wants to be as we approach the biggest moviegoing season of the year," Dergarabedian said. "It's night and day from where we were last year."

The industry has a stronger early-summer lineup this time compared to last year, when Hollywood got off to a slow start with "Kingdom of Heaven," "Kicking and Screaming" and "Monster-in-Law."

Coming over the first three weekends this May are
Tom Cruise's "Mission: Impossible III,"
Tom Hanks and
Ron Howard's "The Da Vinci Code," the animated comedy "Over the Hedge" and "Poseidon," a remake of "The Poseidon Adventure."

"Not only has the box office continued to be up, and up significantly the last several weeks, but we're headed into what looks to be a terrific May," said Rory Bruer, head of distribution at Sony, which is releasing "The Da Vinci Code."

Sony scored its fourth No. 1 opening of the year with "Silent Hill," starring
Radha Mitchell as a mom hunting for her ailing daughter in a mysterious town. Along with "Silent Hill," two of Sony's other top debuts were horror movies that were not shown to critics beforehand, part of a growing trend where studios skip critic screenings when they expect bad reviews.

Two-thirds of the audience for "Silent Hill" was under 25, an age group less likely to pay attention to reviews, and the horror genre tends to pull in fans over opening weekend no matter what the critics say.

Estimated ticket sales for Friday through Sunday at U.S. and Canadian theaters, according to Exhibitor Relations Co. Inc. Final figures will be released Monday.

1. "Silent Hill," $20.2 million.

2. "Scary Movie 4," $17 million.

3. "The Sentinel," $14.65 million.

4. "Ice Age: The Meltdown," $12.8 million.

5. "The Wild," $8.05 million.

6. "The Benchwarmers," $7.3 million.

7. "Take the Lead," $4.25 million.

8 (tie). "American Dreamz," $3.7 million.

8 (tie). "Inside Man," $3.7 million.

10. "Friends With Money," $3.55 million.

vhgong 04-23-06 07:44 PM

Prices for the Silent Hill 1 and 2 is pretty high on Ebay now.

Cardiff Giant11 04-23-06 07:51 PM

Caught it at a matinee today. I vividly remember playing the original Silent Hill on the PSX when it first came out and a few years later I got a chance to play Silent Hill 2 on the XBox. With that in mind, the movie was good but I think it tried to do too much. The whole
Spoiler:
explanantion sequence was tacked on and I feel unneccesarry. Also, the ending sequence with Alessa was a bit over the top. I did however like the non happy ending, very cool

I dug all of the subtle nods to the games (the music, some of the scenes shot for shot were just like the games). Overall it was visually very strong but I feel they made it too long and lost my interest by trying to explain alot. Overall I'd say it was worth seeing theatrically as the sound mix was very good. I was kinda bummed though that the imps didn't have knives like they did in the first game though :)

Joe Molotov 04-23-06 08:00 PM


Originally Posted by vhgong
Prices for the Silent Hill 1 and 2 is pretty high on Ebay now.

Woah, you're not kidding! A sealed copy of the Greatest Hits version of SH1 is selling for $60 with an hour left to go!! -eek- Mint non-GH copies seem to selling for about the same. I'd sell mine while the market's riding high, but now I want to play it again too. :lol:

vhgong 04-23-06 08:35 PM


Originally Posted by Joe Molotov
Woah, you're not kidding! A sealed copy of the Greatest Hits version of SH1 is selling for $60 with an hour left to go!! -eek- Mint non-GH copies seem to selling for about the same. I'd sell mine while the market's riding high, but now I want to play it again too. :lol:

Hahahha...i felt like playing it too....but at this price...i think i can wait till the price cools down and play it later.

Supermallet 04-23-06 11:03 PM


Originally Posted by sethsez
That depends.
Spoiler:
Pyramid Head represents basic, aggressive male sexuality.
Without that aspect of the plot in the second movie, Pyramid Head wouldn't need to be there at all, even if everything else was copied verbatim from the second game. And considering how Chris
Spoiler:
loses his wife
in this movie, it's already unlikely.

It's a good way to set up the second movie, definitely, but there's going to have to be a hell of a lot of additional family backstory because the fundamental reason for what's going on in Silent Hill 2 is already impossible here.

Considering Sean Bean's character was tacked on to please the studios, I think it would be a wonderful turning of the tables to give him and Rose a really cool backstory that would make him a credible main character for the second and also give Pryamid Head the significance he had in the video game.

Spoiler:
Don't forget that Pryamid Head represents not just sexuality, but also the guy's desire to continually punish himself for his wife's death. And since Sean Bean's character had to leave and just sit at home, Pryamid Head could easily represent his desire for punishment at his relative inaction.


Also, I subscribe more to Joe Molotov's interpretation, especially because Gans in an interview (posted in this thread, I believe), mentions that Rose goes unconscious after the car accident, and is transported to the nightmare Silent Hill.
Spoiler:
If she had died, I doubt Gans would have specifically called it a nightmare, which denotes a dream. Furthermore, Sean Bean's character can sense Rose when he's near her, even though she's in the nightmare world, which to me suggests she is still there, just on a different plane of existence. Not dead, though. Furthermore, if the people in Silent Hill were already dead, why would Alessa need retribution? Don't forget, in the flashback, the town still exists and is populated after the fire. Alessa herself is still alive. So I see no indication, other than some references to damnation, that everyone in the town is dead.

Sex Fiend 04-24-06 01:45 AM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
Also, I subscribe more to Joe Molotov's interpretation, especially because Gans in an interview (posted in this thread, I believe), mentions that Rose goes unconscious after the car accident, and is transported to the nightmare Silent Hill.
Spoiler:
If she had died, I doubt Gans would have specifically called it a nightmare, which denotes a dream. Furthermore, Sean Bean's character can sense Rose when he's near her, even though she's in the nightmare world, which to me suggests she is still there, just on a different plane of existence. Not dead, though. Furthermore, if the people in Silent Hill were already dead, why would Alessa need retribution? Don't forget, in the flashback, the town still exists and is populated after the fire. Alessa herself is still alive. So I see no indication, other than some references to damnation, that everyone in the town is dead.

I agree 100% with your second spoiler, Suprmallet (and by extension, Joe Molotov's as well). In fact, I had posted something similar earlier today, but my browser crashed and I said heck with it. But your take is right on - having played through all of the games several times, and read extensively other folks interpretations of the Silent Hill mythology, I think I have a pretty good grasp on how the game designers intended us to understand Silent Hill. And I definitely believe the filmmakers' intentions were consistent with that, so the interpretation you have spelled out seems right on to me (and was definitely how I interpreted the plot and ending of the film).

Spoiler:
The part of Silent Hill where Rose, Cybill, and the cultists are throughout the film is clearly meant to be a kind of otherwordly limbo, but they are most definitely not dead (or at least until the Alessa/demon attacks the cult members). I think the ending was supposed to imply that for whatever reason, Rose can never really return from the limbo of Silent Hill, or perhaps not without some further "setting things right" - which is the major theme of all of the Silent Hill games. It definitely seems to suggest the plotline for the potential sequel, as many have noted
.

Supermallet 04-24-06 03:41 AM

Does anyone know who does the song at the end of the film and what it's called?

slavetotherave 04-24-06 09:51 AM

Melissa Williamson - "You're Not Here"

It's also the Silent Hill 3 intro song, so it might come up under Silent Hill 3 - "You're Not Here" or whatever.

DonnachaOne 04-24-06 12:28 PM


Originally Posted by sethsez
Spoiler:
The only CGI gore sequence that I remember was the end.
The rest of the violent bits were all makeup and practical effects.

Um,
Spoiler:
crappy ash babies?


How about the very silly rat-like bugs? Oh wow they did that in LITTLE NICKY.


Originally Posted by SPiRAL
I saw the SH poster awhile back and instantly thought the girl looks like Alexis Bledel ( Gilmore Girls ) in her Chilton uniform with her mouth blurred-out.

Yeah, what was the point of that? There's no girl like that in the film.


Originally Posted by sureAV421, quoting AP
Two-thirds of the audience for "Silent Hill" was under 25, an age group less likely to pay attention to reviews, and the horror genre tends to pull in fans over opening weekend no matter what the critics say.

So what harm could reviews have done?
Idiots...

Giles 04-24-06 01:21 PM


Originally Posted by Seantn
A lot of people on here loved it, are you only going by his review?


apparently...

I won't pay full price for it... maybe matinee.

RichC2 04-24-06 01:42 PM


Yeah, what was the point of that? There's no girl like that in the film.
Was a fan poster wasn't it? It's silent hill, get it, silent? ha ha ha... yeah.

Apparently they confused I Have No Mouth and Must Scream, but whatever.

DonnachaOne 04-24-06 02:23 PM


Originally Posted by RichC2
Apparently they confused I Have No Mouth and Must Scream, but whatever.

Hmm. Radha Mitchell in a computer having sex with a gay monkeyman with giant genitals? Interesting. You could carry over the whole hell metaphor...

Diabolita23 04-24-06 04:48 PM

I'm a big fan of the game, but still haven't seen the movie. I heard that as of today it’s #1 at the Box Office. Anyone seen or have this: http://www.konami.com/silenthill/she/ ? It's a PSP "game" that has lots of Silent Hill extras, like the two comics, lots of behind the scenes-type stuff from the movie, and I guess music from the movie and games too.

Dr. DVD 04-24-06 07:00 PM

I am not certain if I saw these in this movie or not, but I can't help but think I did. It seems that when Rose is in the school she sees pictures of saints on a wall. I distinctly remember the last two being Joan of Arc with the word "Duty" written below it and the other one seeming to be the Virgin Mary with the word "Love" written below. It wasn't anything major, just a "blink and you'll miss it" type thing.
If these were the images I saw in this movie, that could actually be interpreted as symbols for Rose and the Cop lady. It was love driving Rose, and duty driving the Cop.
Spoiler:
Not to mention the cop and Joan have a very similar style of death, but I digress.
Again, maybe it's just me seeing or remembering something that wasn't there, but if it was, it adds more to the whole symbolic thing.

Supermallet 04-24-06 07:06 PM

Those pictures actually creeped me out. :lol:

Dr. DVD 04-24-06 08:29 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
Those pictures actually creeped me out. :lol:


So they were there?

clemente 04-24-06 09:17 PM


Originally Posted by Dr. DVD
So they were there?

They were there...and despite being of a "spiritual" nature, they were rather creepy.

thegame370 04-24-06 09:18 PM


Originally Posted by vhgong
Prices for the Silent Hill 1 and 2 is pretty high on Ebay now.

Last night i saw a copy of Silent Hill for PSone go for $110.00 :O Wish i had a second copy to sell :)

SteveGo 04-24-06 09:24 PM

I just got back from this movie, very creepy and messed up images. But I was suprised at how bad some of the dialogue was considering how well done the other aspects of the movie were.

I loved the creatures though, and although I've never played the games, I understood and followed the story fine, even though its apparent the ending is up for debate.

Though to tell you the truth, I dunno what was more disturbing, the movie itself, or the fact that I saw a man bring his two young kids with him, who couldn't have been older than 4-5. And also a family with an infant walked in midway through the flick. Gotta love going to the theaters every once and while, its an experience in how mind-blowingly dumb people can be.

Dr. DVD 04-24-06 09:28 PM

Steve: you pretty much summed up why I choose to see certain things first showing available wheter it be matinee or midnight showing. You're almost guaranteed to get an audience of people who know what's going on and won't pull anything stupid like bringing kids.
I remember meeting a kid over this past summer who wanted to go see The Devil's Rejects, and he couldn't have been more than eight years old! Apparently he had actually seen the Chainsaw Massacre remake, so I guess parents don't care what their kids watch anymore as long as it keeps them quiet.

Giantrobo 04-24-06 10:25 PM

Saw it today at a 4:15 showing. I had the whole back row to myself then I'll be damned if a Family of four with Mom , Dad, and two teens didn't sit one seat away from me in "my" row. :grunt: Of course the Boy(15 or 16) who sat nearest to me had to be "chatty'. BASTARD! Then 3 teens(boy and 2 girls) sat in the row ahead of me and naturally the two bitches were talking THROUGH THE WHOLE MOVIE. I mean how can you watch an intense flick like this and get totally into it with 2 bitches running their mouths and not even trying to lower their voices? Sigh--- I really hate people...


Anyway, I liked the movie although I couldn't get into the games. I would like to get more into the Mythos of the Silent Hill World.

DonnachaOne 04-25-06 12:33 AM


Originally Posted by Dr. DVD
I am not certain if I saw these in this movie or not, but I can't help but think I did. It seems that when Rose is in the school she sees pictures of saints on a wall. I distinctly remember the last two being Joan of Arc with the word "Duty" written below it and the other one seeming to be the Virgin Mary with the word "Love" written below. It wasn't anything major, just a "blink and you'll miss it" type thing.
If these were the images I saw in this movie, that could actually be interpreted as symbols for Rose and the Cop lady. It was love driving Rose, and duty driving the Cop.
Spoiler:
Not to mention the cop and Joan have a very similar style of death, but I digress.
Again, maybe it's just me seeing or remembering something that wasn't there, but if it was, it adds more to the whole symbolic thing.

I'll have to check that out.

I remember how "God" was a picture of a woman looking very much like Christabella...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:37 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.