DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   COLLATERAL review thread... (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/378504-collateral-review-thread.html)

V-ism 08-16-04 06:30 PM

What I liked most about the film is the true representation of Los Angeles it shows. Even the three clubs they shot in are real, even maintaining their names. Fever and El Rodeo really do exist, I'm not sure about the Jazz club.

marty888 08-19-04 02:54 PM

Just saw this yesterday - and a big :up:

I can overlook some "convenient coincidences" when the situations and plot are as involving as this, and two solid actors create strong characters. Add in stunning photography (saw it digital) and smooth "effortless" direction, and it adds up to one terrific movie!

db27 08-19-04 11:41 PM

yup, great flick!

Frank TJ Mackey 08-20-04 11:59 AM

Hopefully this continues to hang around at the box office. It definitely deserves it because most people really seem to like it.

Bacon 08-23-04 03:42 AM

:up: Loved it, but the ending could've been better.

Josh H 08-23-04 05:06 PM

Saw this Saturday and loved. Best movie I've seen so far this year (may be short lived as I'm seeing Garden State this week).

It has some flaws and cliche's as disussed above, but nothing to really keep me from enjoying it.

3.5/4.0 for me.

Me007gold 09-01-04 05:56 PM

i saw it last night, and what really bothred me was, when vincent took out the power in the building, the elevaders still worked and the lighting in the loby was way to bright to be back up lighting.



i did get a good laugh out of the scean where vincent killed those two punks, and just shot that last guy just because.

Random 09-01-04 06:15 PM

he only cut power and phone lines to that floor, thats why the lobby was still lit, elevators are probably not tied to that floors power lines anyways.

he shot the guy because the guy was still writhing, on the floor, I guess he didnt die fast enough.

Me007gold 09-01-04 06:54 PM


Originally posted by Random
he only cut power and phone lines to that floor, thats why the lobby was still lit, elevators are probably not tied to that floors power lines anyways.

he shot the guy because the guy was still writhing, on the floor, I guess he didnt die fast enough.

ah, nether the less it was still funny, i felt so bad for laughin, and my lady friend slaped me, but i just couldnt help it

Rival11 01-05-05 10:41 PM

Man, this flick was terrible. Great performances and direction but I honestly can't remember seeing a flick this cheesy since 1988.

And what the hell was that music playing when Mark Ruffalo arrived on the scene? God that was awful and talk about cliches.............holy shit.

MasterCXtreme 01-06-05 12:08 AM

I rented it a few weeks back when it was released, and absoultley loved it. Some of the music was questionable, and had some obvious cliches.... but I thought it all worked perfectly. In my opinion, it's one of the best movies of 2004.

Rivero 01-06-05 02:06 AM


Originally Posted by Rival11
And what the hell was that music playing when Mark Ruffalo arrived on the scene? God that was awful and talk about cliches.............holy shit.

If you just view the film as a kind of Terminator 4 starring Tom Cruise then it becomes much much better and the shitload of coincidences, cliches, and predictable story turns become that much easier to accept.

QuikSilver 01-06-05 04:47 PM

I saw the movie recently and it was a bit overrated. Don't get me wrong, its a great film, but some people and critics are gushing all over this movie. The main problem I had was the ending. It was anticlimatic.

tommyp007 01-06-05 05:34 PM

Got this for X-mas and LOVED it. Cruise and Foxx were great and Mann really set up a fantastic story. Actually, i may watch it again tonight for even better appreciation!

Joe Molotov 01-06-05 05:34 PM


Originally Posted by QuikSilver
I saw the movie recently and it was a bit overrated. Don't get me wrong, its a great film, but some people and critics are gushing all over this movie. The main problem I had was the ending. It was anticlimatic.

The ending fit in well with the dismal theme of the movie...

Spoiler:
That life has no meaning or value at all. You can be the predator and take what you want at any cost, or you can be the prey and just accept what ever you're given, but in the end you're still going to die and no one is going to care.

Legolas 01-06-05 05:45 PM


Originally Posted by Abob Teff
Yeah, what was up with Statham? I kept waiting for him to pop back up. And Mark Ruffalo . . . please damnit! He is the one this year. Every year there is some actor who was good in many of the bit parts that they played, but then all of the sudden they turn in up in EVERY DAMN MOVIE! Enough already . . . I like him, he is a great "blend" actor (you are never really sure that it is him). But I am sick of seeing him everywhere!


Statham will return as the star of Collateral 2: The Transporter Hunts Down Max. :)

As for Ruffalo, he's only in the movie because Val Kilmer's commitment to Alexander forced him to pull out.

Geofferson 01-06-05 09:27 PM

I liked the music. Hell, I even bought the soundtrack.

Ralph Wiggum 01-06-05 09:41 PM


Originally Posted by Geofferson
I liked the music. Hell, I even bought the soundtrack.

Same here; I thought the soundtrack was a real highlight (as usual with Mann).

thegame370 01-08-05 12:49 PM

Saw it for the 1st time on DVD and thought it was wonderful! Cruise was great in it, a total badass! Theres a certain scene when they get stopped by the cops and he tells Max (Jamie), "Dont corner me, you dont have the trunk space." Awesome :thumbsup:

Rival11 01-08-05 03:15 PM


Originally Posted by Rivero
If you just view the film as a kind of Terminator 4 starring Tom Cruise then it becomes much much better and the shitload of coincidences, cliches, and predictable story turns become that much easier to accept.

Ha, no shit. Right after the car flip, I gave up all hope. Once again, I honestly did think the acting and Michael Mann's direction were awesome but other than that...........well, you already read it.

Da Thrilla 01-21-05 09:03 PM

Rented it a few nights ago...that movie was Fantastic!
Cruise plays a GREAT bad guy!

jaeufraser 01-21-05 10:01 PM

I agree, this was definately an entertianing movie. I don't think the movie really tried to be anything more than an effective action/thriller, and with that in mind it did it very well. The plot was at times perhaps a little over the top, but I don't mind, and the fantastic performances and assured direction by Mann made for a rollicking good time. And, quite frankly, sometimes it's fun to watch a film where lots of people get shot, especially when the filmmaking behind it is of such high quality.

island007 01-22-05 03:04 PM

It was an ok movie with a bad ending. The movie was good up to the heroics at the end. That ruined a good movie and made it just ok.

If Vincent ...

jas722 01-22-05 04:38 PM


Originally Posted by island007
It was an ok movie with a bad ending. The movie was good up to the heroics at the end. That ruined a good movie and made it just ok.

If Vincent ...

agree 100 %, especially after the club scene. Max had no prob taking out a dozen or so police and security but a lawyer and a taxi driver gave him problems, cmon.

Mr. Salty 01-22-05 04:50 PM


Originally Posted by Me007gold
i did get a good laugh out of the scean where vincent killed those two punks, and just shot that last guy just because.

I don't understand how people don't get this. Vincent was a hit man. There is no way he would leave a witness. The guy was still moving, so he had to make sure he was dead.

Michael Mann even touched on this after the armored car robbery in "Heat." Once you've murdered one person, you might as well kill everybody. The punishment is the same and there are no witnesses left alive to pick you out of a lineup.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:21 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.