DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Movie Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk-17/)
-   -   overrated cult classics (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/movie-talk/369376-overrated-cult-classics.html)

FuzzyBallz 06-15-04 08:26 PM

*in mocking tone* Donnie Darko sucks, watch it. That cute chick (Jena Malone) from Saved is in this film.

Original Desmond 06-15-04 08:40 PM

if anyone said Big Trouble in Little CHina, i'll hit em !

Michael Corvin 06-15-04 09:46 PM


Originally posted by Trigger
Chasing Amy
Now see, I thought we were mostly on the same page until now. ;) I guess it is kinda hard to find someone with the EXACT same tastes as you. But we have been very close until this one.

SweetP 06-15-04 11:01 PM


Christopher Lambert? Where does he come in?
I dunno, man. He was rummaging around the garbage cans outside my house again and happened to mention your name.
But then I gave him the rest of my breakfast burrito and he was happier than a pig in shit.

And speaking of pigs in shit, one day I want to start a "Stop Or My Mom Will Shoot!" Fan Club. I know there are fans out there!
Somewhere. Someday.


I agree with this sentiment.
Turds of a feather....

Rival11 06-16-04 12:04 AM


Originally posted by Original Desmond
if anyone said Big Trouble in Little CHina, i'll hit em !
God himself made Big T in little C and nobody on the face of this earth is stupid enough to hate Jack Burton.

FuzzyBallz 06-16-04 12:07 AM

The Raiden in Big Trouble in Little China can kick the crap outta the poser in Mortal Combat's.

Trigger 06-16-04 04:19 AM


Originally posted by Michael Corvin
Now see, I thought we were mostly on the same page until now. ;) I guess it is kinda hard to find someone with the EXACT same tastes as you. But we have been very close until this one.
as amusing as the contrived banter was, I just couldn't accept the stupid stupid idea that a lesbian would go straight for Ben Affleck. The film either showed a complete non-understanding of sexual orientation or else it was trying to suggest that their love was powerful enough to overcome the whole 'gay' thing... which it failed to do. Alot of the conversations were really awful. I hated Jay and Bob Strike Back too... totally unfunny (to me).

you would be hard-pressed to find two people who agreed on every single movie. I'm happy to find someone whose tastes are remotely similar to mine. :)

Trigger 06-16-04 04:21 AM


Originally posted by RyoHazuki
Its ridiculous that so many people rant and rave about a very crappy movie.
which movie is this again? I forgot. Rushmore? Donnie Darko? I think it was one of those, right? I didn't like Darko at all and don't understand the praise really unless it hit people on some spiritual or religious level that escapes me and my athiest going-to-hell self.

Michael Corvin 06-16-04 06:33 AM


Originally posted by Trigger
as amusing as the contrived banter was, I just couldn't accept the stupid stupid idea that a lesbian would go straight for Ben Affleck. The film either showed a complete non-understanding of sexual orientation or else it was trying to suggest that their love was powerful enough to overcome the whole 'gay' thing... which it failed to do. Alot of the conversations were really awful. I hated Jay and Bob Strike Back too... totally unfunny (to me).

you would be hard-pressed to find two people who agreed on every single movie. I'm happy to find someone whose tastes are remotely similar to mine. :)

Agreed. It is nice. But on the CA thing, she was bi, so that makes going for Ben somewhat believable. It had just been a while since she had a guy.

steelpotato 06-16-04 01:39 PM

You are NOT a Peter Jackson fan if you didn't like Braindead(its REAL title, not the crappy American 'Dead Alive' rebrandishing). I bet you just say that based on the Lord Of The Rings, well I've personally gotta say that I have all his movies (Bad Taste, Meet The Feebles, Braindead, Heavenly Creatures, The Frighteners, Forgotten Silver and all 3 LOTR plus extended editions) and that the stuff he made before LOTR gets more rotation in my DVD player.
Getting back to the topic, overrated definitely: Harold & Maude, Mallrats, Rushmore, Night Of The Demons

chanster 06-16-04 02:03 PM


You are NOT a Peter Jackson fan if you didn't like Braindead(its REAL title, not the crappy American 'Dead Alive' rebrandishing). I bet you just say that based on the Lord Of The Rings,
Thanks for telling us who are fans and who are not.

RyoHazuki 06-16-04 02:08 PM


Originally posted by Trigger
which movie is this again? I forgot. Rushmore? Donnie Darko? I think it was one of those, right? I didn't like Darko at all and don't understand the praise really unless it hit people on some spiritual or religious level that escapes me and my athiest going-to-hell self.
It was Donnie Darko. I don't know how anyone could find that spiritual. Me my catholic-going-to-heaven self hates that movie.

SomeVoices 06-16-04 03:30 PM


Originally posted by shaggy
Wow this thread is killing me. You guys are picking overrated films, and it reads like my top 10 list. I love Rushmore, Donnie Darko , Ginger Snaps, Full Metal Jacket, Holy Grail, and Evil Dead 2.

I do agree NOTLD is overrated. Dawn of the Dead is way better.

:lol: I was thinking the exact same thing.

rennervision 06-16-04 03:32 PM


Originally posted by island007
All this talk about Donnie Darko piqued my interest.
A friend recommended this to me months ago, and I sort of just blew off his suggestion. But now that every other person in this thread mentions it, and it appeared as the subject of a recent article in Entertainment Weekly, I can no longer ignore this movie either.

RyoHazuki 06-16-04 03:34 PM

If anyone needs a copy, I'll sell you it for $7 shipped.

natesfortune 06-16-04 04:34 PM

Easy Rider is the most overrated movie ever.

Donnie Darko is a kind of "faux intellectual" hodgepodge - not a terrible movie, but certainly not a successful movie either - it just fools people into thinking it's "deep" by being weird.

Dead Alive, I must defend, however. Hilariously creative. Just make sure you don't accidentally watch "The rated version" - this version is out there in many incarnations, and it destroys the movie - by cutting out lots of the best bits in the film. It's the first version I saw, and I didn't think much of the film until I saw the actual, uncut version.

If it says "Rated Version" or "Rated R" anywhere on the tape/disc - then avoid it like the plague - only watch it uncut.

Daytripper 06-16-04 06:26 PM


Originally posted by RyoHazuki
It was Donnie Darko. I don't know how anyone could find that spiritual. Me my catholic-going-to-heaven self hates that movie.
We get it Ryo, you hate the movie. This is only your fourth post saying as much in this thread alone. Time to move on.

RyoHazuki 06-16-04 06:33 PM


Originally posted by Daytripper
We get it Ryo, you hate the movie. This is only your fourth post saying as much in this thread alone. Time to move on.
My post was in response to Trigger's question.

island007 06-16-04 06:45 PM


Originally posted by RyoHazuki
If anyone needs a copy, I'll sell you it for $7 shipped.
I ordered it from bestbuy.com for $6.66 shipped.

RyoHazuki 06-16-04 06:49 PM


Originally posted by island007
I ordered it from bestbuy.com for $6.66 shipped.
<i> NO :crap: !</i>

fumanstan 06-16-04 07:27 PM


Originally posted by RyoHazuki
Uh......... your mom.
-rolleyes-

Daytripper 06-17-04 08:30 AM

The Landmark Theaters in my area are now running midnight shows. And on it's current list is, and I quote, "Teens track treasure in the cult favorite 'The Goonies' " Certainly never would have considered that a cult movie. Nor did I ever expect to see it pop up at a midnight show. Kind of cool actually. Not to derail the thread, but are they still planning a sequel?

Giles 06-17-04 08:45 AM


Originally posted by Daytripper
The Landmark Theaters in my area are now running midnight shows. And on it's current list is, and I quote, "Teens track treasure in the cult favorite 'The Goonies' " Certainly never would have considered that a cult movie. Nor did I ever expect to see it pop up at a midnight show. Kind of cool actually. Not to derail the thread, but are they still planning a sequel?
How bout that Hervé Villechaize film, the 1980: Forbidden Zone - now that looks like one mind-**** of a film.

Daytripper 06-17-04 09:08 AM

O.K., Hervé Villechaize alone is a mind-**** ;)

Giles 06-17-04 09:12 AM


Originally posted by Daytripper
O.K., Hervé Villechaize alone is a mind-**** ;)
rotfl


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:47 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.