Blasphemy!!!



Everyone's entitled to their two, though.

I just watched The Color Purple again last night. It's amazing how much work Opera has had done. Or is that natural change?

I know it's an unpopular opinion around here (kinda strange when you consider how many people get pissed over the Academy supposedly giving "make up" awards for when they have supposedly passed over that actor in the past), but ROTK should be judged on its own merits and not the other movies. After all, it is nominated, not all three as a whole. They were already up and had their chance.

cue the music on the Chernobyl chick ....

But you see, this is more of an honor for the entire LOTR trilogy.

Meh, to each his own. I thought Lost was just okay myself.

Jason

Yes, I could agree with that.

A political speach in the documentary Catagory should be a yearly tradition. Nobody booed him, though.

Well that dude had nothing on Michael Moore.

I disagree, but I will agree that this is what most voters are doing.

That's what the voters always do. if the film has a chance to win the following year they go for the final chance. That's the main reason it hasn't won the last two years.

Humm, like Hope and Hep, I think Peck deserved an extended tribute...but that's just me.

Sorry...OT...but:

at the AE Tiger Woods commercial...

doesn't anybody find it ironic how they applauded the Bush bash, yet they give applause to Hitler's propogandist?

I agree.

Also, looks like Jonathan Brandis was forgotten.

If they didn't award FOTR or TTT because they were waiting for ROTK, then a "cumulative" award is more than justified.

shhhhhh everyone .... Phil Collins

If you'd actually listened you would've noticed the aplause suddenly became very t entative and then died out completely once people realized who they were applauding.

for the Bush bashing i might add. Thank god we live in a free country.

Clean sweep by LOTR?

Jason

Correct me if I am wrong, but wasn't Shore not eligable for the Award under new Oscar rules? (Hence why he was not nominated for the Two Towers)

Whats the new rule?

I didn't hear any lapse, but my surround isn't on, so I'll take your word for it.

As for bashing Bush, you bet I'm glad we live in a free country. I just believe in balance.

And damn it! Phil Collins is on the show...and I was just listening to THE LAMB LIES DOWN ON BROADWAY on the way home today! Man could he drum in his day!

Not only do I feel that's a bad way to do it, because it is supposed to be about the film nominated this year and not any others, but it also paints them in a corner. What if ROTK turned out to be not worthy of Best Picture (as I and some others feel), then they have passed up honoring more deserving pictures in favor of giving the award to a lesser one just because they wanted to honor those first two. Just vote for the films and performers up this year and leave it at that.

and RotK for film editing ... guess the academy didn't see the ending, eh?

That music used in a sequel would not be eligable for awards because themes used are from the previous film/s/