"this is my third stillborn"

why was the room reversed???

The most important thing to remember in this scene is that it shows how Evan is affected by the present more than any other scene from jumping back and forth: He was responsible for K's death when she blew up, he went crazy after that and ended up in the hospital, he woke up crazy (paranoid holding the sheets to his mouth) although not fully because it was during his time travel (just like all the other times to an extent) with that said, the journals and the time travel AT THAT POINT BECAUSE OF THE EVENT THAT HAPPENEDwere all made up in his head once more to clarify, when K died because of the explosion, he went nuts and never created the journals or time travel at that point..... It was just in his head as an excuse for what happened, but since he knew where he was (just like any other time when he traveled) he asked the doctors for the journals at which point he told him there were never any journals (and that he made up all the time travel) the biggest clue here is Evans reaction, he freaked out and spit up a little (a sign that he's nuts). The doctor then replys that his Father was the same way, always talking about some photo album, that's because his father made the same wrong move (on accident of course) and was labeled as crazy (and he was crazy at the time). watch it again, you'll see it. I know what you're thinking "but he started the journals when he was the very young Evan" you're right, but here's the thing, when he was the young Evan he only wrote "I'm going over Tommy and K's house to see what a real Father is like" and "I'm going to visit my dad today, he's crazy" nothing that shows any unusual activity. Then we get to the writing "I never wanted to take my clothes off" but it ended there because he didn't remember what happened after that - would it cause alarm, of course, but it wouldn't help anything because he didn't remember what immediately happened after, buuuuuuuuuuut that leads to the next huge fact, K blew up in the basement so more than likely, young Evan prob. never even wrote anything about what happened before that in his journal........we are then immeidately taken to the setup - Evan waking up insane in the hospital

the head natzi dude from prison

They went to a palm reader that tells Evan that he should have never been born at all and that he has no lifeline. Then his mom freaks out and tells him that there were two stillbirths before him

if he injured his hands when he was a kid, wouldn't the timeline have been changed and he would have gone into prison w/ those scars?

a hard core federal prison for defending himself on campus. So he killed the guy, big deal, the nut had already hit him like 5 times with the bat. He might have gottan probation at worst. Hell, if he really wanted to change that event he could have just written a new journal entry and then read it back to himself like 2 weeks later. Then just stop himself from taking that last skull crushing swing at Tommy. That first reality was the best for him until that point.

hooker just because she saw her brother get killed. People see tragedy all the time, it doesn't mean they become street walker, druggies.

Blockbuster was first intruduced when Tommy found it in the coffee thermos when the boys were about 12. He said he knew his dad always hid it or kept hiding it placed in the basement. Evan later goes back to age 6 when the naked video was being shot and gets if out of the same coffee thermos. Are we to believe that blockbuster was in the thermos for 6+ yrs? And why the hell would Evan light it in the basement in the first place? That was sure to injure someone or them all.

after he kills his fetus self, the new timeline flashed by. His mom is showned with a new baby girl and the father seems to be OK as well. How come Evan never being born somehow caused his dad never to go insane?

shouldn't be assumed to be the same one 6 years later. He said that his dad "always keeps them in the basement" or something similar, correct? Implying that his dad regulary gets/uses/keeps these type of fireworks or explosives.

I agree that this one makes little sense. One possible explanation is that the dad learned his lesson and going insane was a result of stressing about controlling his son's power. That or the dad just randomly hit the good future and decided to cut his losses