I got my Revenge replacement today (early). It came in a plastic.paper case (not the usual style) that was hard to open & there are some small scratches on the disc. Revenge 2d still looks awful. Other than the aspect ratio (full on the Legacy, wide on the blu) the picture quality is better on the dvd than on the blu. At least on my system (Oppo 95 -> Vizio 55").

That was a given since they didn't change the transfer/master at all -- unless you can access the alternate eye file when sounds like it's slightly better

I had hoped as there are some posts on the net mentioning the 2d was better also due to them using a below 2k transfer on the bad disc. Weird that the dvd did have a better looking picture (on the one film only).