DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   HD Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk-55/)
-   -   Studio Ghibli in HD (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/hd-talk/600843-studio-ghibli-hd.html)

Doctorossi 05-10-12 10:42 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by manicsounds (Post 11226432)
I guess this means credits are in both English and Japanese as well.

I would hope so but, unfortunately, I wouldn't recommend assuming so.

RobLutter 05-10-12 11:19 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
I saw a newly struck print 35MM print of Kiki's Delivery Service during a Ghibli Retrospective that the Alamo Drafthouse showed the past few months. Dubtitles! The same as on the DVD. Disney has rocks for brains.

It did have the Japanese titles. So at least it had that going for it. It really grinds my gears when companies replace the original titles. Even moreso when the credits start with the english dubbed actors in a subtitled version of a film. Bah! :)

Doctorossi 05-10-12 11:20 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by RobLutter (Post 11226612)
I saw a newly struck print 35MM print of Kiki's Delivery Service during a Ghibli Retrospective that the Alamo Drafthouse showed the past few months. Dubtitles! The same as on the DVD. Disney has rocks for brains.

I'm surprised they could even get a subtitled print out of Disney.

RobLutter 05-10-12 11:27 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by Doctorossi (Post 11226615)
I'm surprised they could even get a subtitled print out of Disney.

I believe the prints are touring the US right now in various art house cinemas. The Drafthouse's monthly newsletter mentioned they'd been to NYC, LA, & Chicago before making their way down here.

Check your local listings for time and channel! ;)

Dragon Tattoo 05-10-12 02:51 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by RobLutter (Post 11226612)
I saw a newly struck print 35MM print of Kiki's Delivery Service during a Ghibli Retrospective that the Alamo Drafthouse showed the past few months. Dubtitles! The same as on the DVD. Disney has rocks for brains.

It did have the Japanese titles. So at least it had that going for it. It really grinds my gears when companies replace the original titles. Even moreso when the credits start with the english dubbed actors in a subtitled version of a film. Bah! :)

What the...? Why? The Japanese Blu-rays already have English subtitles! It's just copy and paste. It seems like it would be more work for them to make dubtitles at this point.

Giles 05-10-12 04:58 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by RobLutter (Post 11226629)
I believe the prints are touring the US right now in various art house cinemas. The Drafthouse's monthly newsletter mentioned they'd been to NYC, LA, & Chicago before making their way down here.

Check your local listings for time and channel! ;)


the AFI Silver had it's Ghibli retrospective in April.

manicsounds 05-12-12 10:00 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
"Castle In The Sky" and "Whisper Of The Heart" reviews on BlurayDefinition

Maxflier 05-12-12 01:46 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
Your first link is broken. It takes you to a review of Polanski's Repulsion.

davidh777 05-14-12 03:51 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
Pre-ordered Arrietty and Whisper of the Heart using the $8 discount. I realized I was complaining about the lack of Ghibli on BD but I hadn't bought Nausicaa (I did get Ponyo, though) so this makes me feel a little better.

RocShemp 05-14-12 08:22 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by RobLutter (Post 11226612)
I saw a newly struck print 35MM print of Kiki's Delivery Service during a Ghibli Retrospective that the Alamo Drafthouse showed the past few months. Dubtitles! The same as on the DVD. Disney has rocks for brains.

It did have the Japanese titles. So at least it had that going for it. It really grinds my gears when companies replace the original titles. Even moreso when the credits start with the english dubbed actors in a subtitled version of a film. Bah! :)

That's worrysome since, as I recall, the English language dub of Kiki has additional dialogue (mostly the cat making comments while offscreen) in shots that only play with music in the Japanese language dub.

manicsounds 05-14-12 10:48 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by RocShemp (Post 11231122)
That's worrysome since, as I recall, the English language dub of Kiki has additional dialogue (mostly the cat making comments while offscreen) in shots that only play with music in the Japanese language dub.

The final scene USED TO have an extra line of dialogue with Jiji (which considerably changed the ending) in the VHS English dub, but the Disney DVD reissue deleted it.

If Disney retracted it knowing it was a mistake to add that line, why did they have to add the same kind of extra ending dialogue to "Arrietty" as well?!

manicsounds 05-14-12 10:56 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
But not only that, the 2003 Kiki DVD and the 2010 Kiki DVD had some other significant changes to the English dub version

Originally Posted by DVDizzy
Upon doing a synched-up comparison, I noticed that the edits go far beyond that one line of dialogue. The 2010 DVD drops a considerable amount of character dubbing. Most affected is Jiji, for whom Hartman had provided a number of witty ad-libs. Here, unless a character is explicitly shown to be speaking, they're silent. The silence goes even further in few scenes that had score apparently added for the English dub; these now appear without music. Other noticeable losses include Kiki and Jiji's in-flight and in-rain banter (particularly the latter, upon arriving in their new town), some of Tombo's lines, and a radio report. Furthermore, some minor changes occur in the credited titles of certain filmmakers.

Their review also claims that the 2003 DVD had only English credits, but this is wrong. It had both Japanese and English credit sequences, depending on which language you choose at the start.

It'll be interesting to see what will be on the eventual (so far unannounced) Kiki's Delivery Service BD.

manicsounds 05-23-12 01:49 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
Want to voice a concern about "Castle In The Sky" to Disney?
Well, contact them and tell them that the English subtitle script is not a literal translation, and the rescored soundtrack that was on the 2003 DVD is missing. See if they can get it rectified.

Doctorossi 05-23-12 07:10 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by manicsounds (Post 11243685)
the rescored soundtrack that was on the 2003 DVD is missing

Any re-scored soundtrack should be missing.

manicsounds 05-25-12 03:00 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
I personally don't care for dub tracks, but in this case where the 2003 edition had the rescored alternate soundtrack by Joe Hisaishi, and is included on the Japanese and UK editions, why should it be missing from the US release. Either way, fire away at Disney's customer service and tell them that the English subtitle option is an incorrect translation.

batmanrules 05-25-12 04:45 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
I think im the only one I know that prefers the Disney Eng Dubs.

manicsounds 06-24-12 06:50 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
Studio Canal UK Howl's Moving Castle and Tales From Earthsea reviews

manicsounds 07-07-12 05:45 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
BlurayDefinition reviews of Howl's Moving Castle and Tales From Earthsea

manicsounds 07-18-12 06:48 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
My Neighbor Totoro and Grave Of The Fireflies have been announced for UK release on November 12th.

manicsounds 07-20-12 06:08 AM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
Grave Of The Fireflies BD comparison at DVDBeaver

manicsounds 08-09-12 07:05 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
"Kiki's Delivery Service" and "Only Yesterday" have been announced for 12/5/2012

Sondheim 08-09-12 07:14 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by manicsounds (Post 11341084)
"Kiki's Delivery Service" and "Only Yesterday" have been announced for 12/5/2012

Yes! and Yes!

E Unit 08-09-12 08:45 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by manicsounds (Post 11341084)
"Kiki's Delivery Service" and "Only Yesterday" have been announced for 12/5/2012

Awesome! Been waiting for Kiki since the first wave came out. Haven' seen Only Yesterday, so I'm looking foward to that as well.

Giles 08-09-12 09:53 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 

Originally Posted by manicsounds (Post 11341084)
"Kiki's Delivery Service" and "Only Yesterday" have been announced for 12/5/2012

:banana:

manicsounds 08-09-12 10:56 PM

Re: Studio Ghibli in HD
 
Keep in mind those December release dates are for the Japanese releases.
Here are the specs

Kiki's Delivery Service:

Audio:
Japanese dts-HD MA 2.0, English, French, German, Cantonese Dolby 2.0
Subtitles:
Japanese, English, French, Cantonese, Mandarin (sorry, no German?)

-Storyboards
-Voice Over Script
-Ursula's Paintings
-Trailers

Only Yesterday:

Audio:
Japanese dts-HD MA 2.0, German, Mandarin, Cantonese Dolby 2.0, Korean Dolby mono
Subtitles:
Japanese, English, French, German, Korean, Mandarin, Cantonese

-Storyboards
-Voice Over Script
-Making Of "Only Yesterday" (1 hour TV special)
-Trailers

Also, in the UK, Hayao Miyazaki's directorial debut "Lupin The Third: Castle Of Cagliostro" has been announced for Blu-ray on 11/3/2012, same day as Totoro and Grave.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:21 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.