Anyone get the new Fifth Element yet?
#1
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 1999
Location: Reading, PA
Posts: 1,155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Anyone get the new Fifth Element yet?
I'm surprised there aren't any reviews for this anywhere since it's been out a few days now. I'm waiting for my replacement in the mail, but wondered if anyone had bought it in the stores? I didn't think the first one was that bad looking, but am really interested to see how much better this one looks. I hope they actually sent replacements close to the release date like they said on the phone.
#2
hidefdigest has a review and gave the remaster a 4.5 out of 5 for both PQ & AQ. His review of the original disc was back when he didn't give out stars, so it's hard to compare, but he wasn't terribly impressed with that one.
http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/fift...emastered.html
I'm still waiting for my replacement to come.
http://bluray.highdefdigest.com/fift...emastered.html
I'm still waiting for my replacement to come.
#3
DVD Talk Legend
I'm expecting mine to be delivered today. Assuming it comes as scheduled, I should have a review this weekend.
#4
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: The Edge of Obscurity
Posts: 297
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've had my copy of the remastered version for about a week now. I don't like "star" ratings, but if I did give ratings like that, 4.5 out of 5 sounds about right. maybe a bit better than that when one considers this is not a new film element.
Having seen just about every video version of this film released in the past 10 years, this new Blu-ray master is something beyond anything I have ever seen. I'm not even sure this film looked this good in theatrical release in any but those few pristine reference prints a studio releases.
As great as the video is, the Dolby TrueHD track is an equal or greater revelation. There are subtle tonal textures and details in this soundtrack that have simply never been there on previous versions.
Having seen just about every video version of this film released in the past 10 years, this new Blu-ray master is something beyond anything I have ever seen. I'm not even sure this film looked this good in theatrical release in any but those few pristine reference prints a studio releases.
As great as the video is, the Dolby TrueHD track is an equal or greater revelation. There are subtle tonal textures and details in this soundtrack that have simply never been there on previous versions.
#8
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by davidh777
Is this the first high-def double-dip?
Figures it'd be from Sony
#12
DVD Talk Legend
I can forgive them on this one since I got the original BD free with my BDP-S1. I sold it a few months ago for a few bucks less than I spent on the remaster.
I never watched the first BD all the way through so I can't say to what degree this release is better, but I will say it looks about as good as I would expect a ten year old sci-fi film to look.
It's not the absolutely best Blu-Ray I've ever seen, but it's definitely better than most in terms of PQ/AQ, and well worth the ~$20.
I never watched the first BD all the way through so I can't say to what degree this release is better, but I will say it looks about as good as I would expect a ten year old sci-fi film to look.
It's not the absolutely best Blu-Ray I've ever seen, but it's definitely better than most in terms of PQ/AQ, and well worth the ~$20.
#13
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Watched mine last night and to my eyes, it's one of the best looking titles out there on either format.
I was happy to give Sony and Bd plenty of shit about their first release of this last year- as the issues with it were easily apparent. Not so with this one. No problems whatsoever leaped out at me- including any objectionable EE. Very film like transfer for the vast majority of the run time.
Color on this release looks excellant to me- by design it's a very colorful film, yet the colors themselves buck the recent trend of looking pumped up and over saturated- even when viewed on a Pearl, which itself is supposed to exhibt over saturated primaries. The colors, especially flesh tones, looked 100% natural.
Excellant detail, especially shadow detail, and one of the more dimensional looking films I've seen on either format.
About the only flaw I noticed was film, not disc, related. When the Shuttle takes off for Fhloston Paradise, you can see the garbage matte around it in one shot (similar to the mattes around the TIE fighters in the original SW).
I had a complete blast watching it again last night (one of the few movies in the last 10 years thatgets better every time I watch it) and would Highly Recommend the new disc.
At the very least, it regains its status as a superior demo disc.
I was happy to give Sony and Bd plenty of shit about their first release of this last year- as the issues with it were easily apparent. Not so with this one. No problems whatsoever leaped out at me- including any objectionable EE. Very film like transfer for the vast majority of the run time.
Color on this release looks excellant to me- by design it's a very colorful film, yet the colors themselves buck the recent trend of looking pumped up and over saturated- even when viewed on a Pearl, which itself is supposed to exhibt over saturated primaries. The colors, especially flesh tones, looked 100% natural.
Excellant detail, especially shadow detail, and one of the more dimensional looking films I've seen on either format.
About the only flaw I noticed was film, not disc, related. When the Shuttle takes off for Fhloston Paradise, you can see the garbage matte around it in one shot (similar to the mattes around the TIE fighters in the original SW).
I had a complete blast watching it again last night (one of the few movies in the last 10 years thatgets better every time I watch it) and would Highly Recommend the new disc.
At the very least, it regains its status as a superior demo disc.
#14
DVD Talk Special Edition
Thread Starter
Join Date: Nov 1999
Location: Reading, PA
Posts: 1,155
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sounds great. Hopefully I won't have to wait weeks for it. And doubledip? I praise Sony for giving free replacements to everyone. I've never heard of that for any non-defective product.
#15
Political Exile
I need to be patient since Sony has been having a Buy 1 Get 1 free sales every couple weeks for most of their catalog titles at Fry's and Best Buy. I'm glad I held off on Hellboy and Cruel Intentions, so I'm trying to hold off on Fifth Element and Wild Things for now.
#16
Member
Join Date: May 2006
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
It is fantastic! I love the new transfer! I have been waiting to get this since the old release and it was absolutely worth the wait. Honestly I think I would probably give it a 4.5...there are some issues in dark areas, and a little grain here and there...but nothing that stands out and hinders the overall image. The sound as well will knock your socks off. Even one of the first scenes when she falls from the building running away is stunning! Can't wait to watch it again.
Matt
Matt
#17
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Still waiting on mine. I hope Sony decides to do the exchange for a few more early titles, especially House of Flying Daggers. I'm glad I got it free at Fry's but it looks crummy.
#18
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Mpls, MN
Posts: 6,830
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by El Kabong
Sounds great. Hopefully I won't have to wait weeks for it. And doubledip? I praise Sony for giving free replacements to everyone. I've never heard of that for any non-defective product.
#19
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by Spiky
But this was a defective product. So I guess that applies.
#20
I just watched it & thoroughly enjoyed it on my 133" screen, HUGE improvement over the 1st BD release, major props to Sony. Now if only Universal would likewise issue replacements for the extremely crappy Traffic & 40-Year-Old-Virgin HD DVDs that I have, I would be happy.
There is some minor EE present on this release (as others have reported), but nothing that is too annoying. The TrueHD track is outstanding, best TrueHD yet. I know I'm not comparing similar movies/apples to apples, but this just reinforces my belief that something isn't quite up to snuff with HD DVD/Toshiba's TrueHD... once again, I REALLY wish a superior brand (other than Toshiba) would put out a stand-alone HD DVD player, as I STILL find the audio lacking overall compared to my BD titles. I hope that Onkyo (?) is coming out soon.
There is some minor EE present on this release (as others have reported), but nothing that is too annoying. The TrueHD track is outstanding, best TrueHD yet. I know I'm not comparing similar movies/apples to apples, but this just reinforces my belief that something isn't quite up to snuff with HD DVD/Toshiba's TrueHD... once again, I REALLY wish a superior brand (other than Toshiba) would put out a stand-alone HD DVD player, as I STILL find the audio lacking overall compared to my BD titles. I hope that Onkyo (?) is coming out soon.
#21
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by RockyMtnBri
Still waiting on mine. I hope Sony decides to do the exchange for a few more early titles, especially House of Flying Daggers. I'm glad I got it free at Fry's but it looks crummy.
#22
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Hammer99
The TrueHD track is outstanding, best TrueHD yet. I know I'm not comparing similar movies/apples to apples, but this just reinforces my belief that something isn't quite up to snuff with HD DVD/Toshiba's TrueHD...
Sony remixes all of their movies for near-field home theater, while most other studios like Warner provide the original theatrical soundtracks, which were mixed with larger auditoriums in mind. That in itself will have a much greater impact on the sound quality through your home speakers than what audio codec the disc uses.
#24
DVD Talk Legend
So is it safe to buy any BD of Fifth Element you see if the price is right or are both versions still out
I do not want to end up with the older version
I do not want to end up with the older version