Director Poll's in Movie Talk
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Can we get rid of all these? A few were fine, but now the front page is flooded with them. Awfully annoying.
And even worse that a moderator is contributing to them.
And even worse that a moderator is contributing to them.
#2
DVD Talk Hero
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Not saying it's a good or bad thing but it's leaking into Otter now.
I say just change the site name to ORtalk
I say just change the site name to ORtalk
#4
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Sorry all. I guess I started it with my Fincher/Nolan poll a week or two back... I then did three more and they were weaved throughout the first page, nothing really out of line. I head over to movie talk today and all hell is breaking loose.
I wish people could come up with a original idea for a thread instead of aping my directors/poll threads.
They're giving my original polls a bad name.
I wish people could come up with a original idea for a thread instead of aping my directors/poll threads.
They're giving my original polls a bad name.
#5
DVD Talk God
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Seriously? After all that shit with the stupid ass character polls now there is this?
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Yeah! Not only are these annoying, what's up with the unnecessary use of apostrophes in thread titles?!
I kid, I kid. But seriously, the fun has been sucked out of Movie Talk, just like it was with those unbearable character polls.
I kid, I kid. But seriously, the fun has been sucked out of Movie Talk, just like it was with those unbearable character polls.
#8
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
And a moderator should know better. A couple by JumpCutz weren't a big deal, but everyone flooding it should be suspended.
#10
DVD Talk Hero - 2023 TOTY Award Winner
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
I am outraged, sir. OUTRAGED!
But seriously, there are way too many of them. These sorts of "contests" should be infrequent and limited to 4 or 5* concurrent threads.
*Numbers yanked from my rectal orifice.
But seriously, there are way too many of them. These sorts of "contests" should be infrequent and limited to 4 or 5* concurrent threads.
*Numbers yanked from my rectal orifice.
#11
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
These complaints are ridiculous. The debates in those threads are more interesting than most of the stuff bumped to the somehow awful second page.
If they don't interest you, ignore them. If the other threads are interesting enough, they'll bounce back up.
If they don't interest you, ignore them. If the other threads are interesting enough, they'll bounce back up.
#14
DVD Talk God
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Yeah totally fair to make eveyone search for threads that are updated with new news about movies. I mean these director threads are providing such valuable information! Please. The only thing more ridiculous than the threads are people like you who defend this crap.
#15
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
it's gone from interesting to beat that dead horse right into the ground, make it a zombie horse and then kill it again. Enough already. Thoughtful threads on the topic get lost in the joke threads.
#16
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
I like how it's not just 1 person creating all these threads, but a whole team of DVD Talk renegades who are contributing. Very creative approach...it can't be said that one person is dominating the forum I suppose.
#17
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk

Like 99% of the threads aren't drivel anyway?
God forbid you have to make one extra click to go to the next page. Or one extra click and hit the new posts button. Or make the minor effort to just subscribe to these apparently great threads that you care so much about.
#18
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
How are 99% of the threads drivel? I don't see how anyone can't see a difference between the forum flooded with polls and discussions about actual movies.
Regardless, looks like they've been deleted
Regardless, looks like they've been deleted
#19
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
Haven't seen that many threads disappear at once since the infamous forum "upgrade" around the first of the year.
Time now to hear from the other side in 3...2...1...
Time now to hear from the other side in 3...2...1...
#20
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jul 2005
Posts: 3,406
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Formerly known as "awil1026"/ Don't Panic
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
#21
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
I just know that I was enjoying the conversations about Eyes Wide Shut in the Kubrick thread, and Knocked Up in the Apatow one. I get why forum members became aggravated over the cluttering of the all-important page 1, but there was some actual conversation going on, you know. About movies. In the movie sub-forum.
God forbid you actually read any of the threads you want removed, or care that people are enjoying themselves having these conversations. But, hey, at least now I don't have to click "page 2" to find my way back to the riveting thread about Twin Sitters. You know, "the best movie EVER MADE."
God forbid you actually read any of the threads you want removed, or care that people are enjoying themselves having these conversations. But, hey, at least now I don't have to click "page 2" to find my way back to the riveting thread about Twin Sitters. You know, "the best movie EVER MADE."
#22
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Godfather
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
You guys should blame the folks that decided to piggy back on the first couple polls and spam the whole forum. 
Given the fact that we JUST WENT THROUGH THIS a couple months ago with the movie tourney and threads were locked, people should know better.

Given the fact that we JUST WENT THROUGH THIS a couple months ago with the movie tourney and threads were locked, people should know better.
#23
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#24
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: Director Poll's in Movie Talk
The hell?
Sure, the polls were overkill, but - with a couple of lame exceptions - they were good matchups. There was some good discussion. I mean, lock 'em if you want, but I don't understand deleting them.
I guess I should count my blessings. The Expendables thread is now back to the first page. So I can read a thousand posts of grown men creaming themselves over the thought of Sly Stallone and Dolph Lundgren reuniting onscreen.
Sure, the polls were overkill, but - with a couple of lame exceptions - they were good matchups. There was some good discussion. I mean, lock 'em if you want, but I don't understand deleting them.
I guess I should count my blessings. The Expendables thread is now back to the first page. So I can read a thousand posts of grown men creaming themselves over the thought of Sly Stallone and Dolph Lundgren reuniting onscreen.



