The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
#76
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
I read somewhere Netflix is going to jack up the price of their streaming+disc plans by as much as 25% soon.
#77
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
No. DVDs. 99% of my viewing is my personal, physical, collection. I rarely stream and then mainly use Amazon if what I want is available "free" with Prime. I do a occasional Youtube or Hulu session if I can't get what I want free from Amazon and they have it free.
I read somewhere Netflix is going to jack up the price of their streaming+disc plans by as much as 25% soon.
I read somewhere Netflix is going to jack up the price of their streaming+disc plans by as much as 25% soon.
#78
Moderator
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
I missed the reason why some folk are starting their lists as early as May 26th ?? clue me in here.
#79
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
#80
Moderator
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
funny you should mention Ancient Aliens since I began this challenge and my 'Animal' themed challenge with an episode of the series.
#81
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
Have you seen Citizenfour? Thanks to http://cryptome.org/ I was able to watch it online and it was pretty interesting. It follows Snowden from before the data is released through him ending up in Russia.
The worst part about the entire thing was the crap from the director at the very beginning talking about she might be taken out by the government because of the films she makes. It was really hard to not turn it off through that stuff but she eventually shuts up and gets on with the story.
The worst part about the entire thing was the crap from the director at the very beginning talking about she might be taken out by the government because of the films she makes. It was really hard to not turn it off through that stuff but she eventually shuts up and gets on with the story.
#82
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
Finally broke down and "double-dipped" on The Man With No Name Trilogy, picking it up on Blu-ray for $15 (CDN) yesterday. I have to pretty much blame this challenge for that!
#83
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
I have a question for people who might be more knowledgeable. I remember hearing that in previous challenges, at least one person watched sports. Does that mean that besides movies about sports, events are also eligible? Also, what would people think about news, since the stories are history making?
#84
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
I wouldn't count news for the same reason I wouldn't count movies and shows based on current events. It's not history yet.
If we're talking about watching stuff like CBS reports from the 80s on the Cold War, that's a different story.
If we're talking about watching stuff like CBS reports from the 80s on the Cold War, that's a different story.
#85
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
Today, I plan to watch some aviation documentaries, as I'm excited about my annual vacation to Oshkosh next month.
#86
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
We got into a somewhat heated discussion a few years back on just what should be allowed. I'm not keen on a repeat visit so I'll just say I'm against Sporting Events or "Hard" News Programs being included no matter *when* they were recorded/aired/played. There's so much that *is* allowed that if you can't find something that fits you aren't trying very hard. Save those two for the MYO challenge.
Last edited by BobO'Link; 06-03-15 at 12:49 PM.
#87
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
I thought so too, which always bogged my puny brain that someone xggfcounted sffdfpoggygorts.
#88
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
OK... I have to somewhat amend my comments about Mankind: The Story of All of Us where I said:
I played back that part of the first episode and the comment was 14 *Billion* years and I'd heard 14 *Million* instead. That number works.
It still moves *very* quickly with some events getting the briefest of mentions. Events I consider somewhat significant (or at least worth a mention) are ignored. I attribute much of that to the overall short time allotted to get this information out but then they spend lots of time on Rome's attempt to get China's secret to silk and ignore Julius Caesar, Augustus Caesar, the Mayans, and more. It's also a bit disconcerting that their on-screen "experts" are people like Anthony Bordon and a former Navy Seal. It's entertaining but because of its omissions so far I have to be somewhat mistrusting of its "facts" and put it in much the same category as Ancient Aliens. It also feels *very* biased towards Western/European Civilization and leaves out much information because of this.
A comment that hit me early in the first episode was that man appeared 4 million years after the Earth was formed.
It still moves *very* quickly with some events getting the briefest of mentions. Events I consider somewhat significant (or at least worth a mention) are ignored. I attribute much of that to the overall short time allotted to get this information out but then they spend lots of time on Rome's attempt to get China's secret to silk and ignore Julius Caesar, Augustus Caesar, the Mayans, and more. It's also a bit disconcerting that their on-screen "experts" are people like Anthony Bordon and a former Navy Seal. It's entertaining but because of its omissions so far I have to be somewhat mistrusting of its "facts" and put it in much the same category as Ancient Aliens. It also feels *very* biased towards Western/European Civilization and leaves out much information because of this.
#89
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
#90
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
We got into a somewhat heated discussion a few years back on just what should be allowed. I'm not keen on a repeat visit so I'll just say I'm against Sporting Events or "Hard" News Programs being included no matter *when* they were recorded/aired/played. There's so much that *is* allowed that if you can't find something that fits you aren't trying very hard. Save those two for the MYO challenge.
Exactly my thoughts, even as a newcomer. I even just got two more things today to add to my watch list. The Blue Max, which I rented off of Amazon Instant Video, for $3, which btw, I love that movie, having seen it twice before. I also bought One Six Right off of Amazon Instant Video too, a documentary I had seen once before, about Van Nuys Airport I believe. Been years since I've seen it, so don't quote me.
#91
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
An update for the book I am reading. I'm currently in the fighter aircraft section, and just today finished reading the section on some of the more famous WW1 Aces.
#93
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
Just finished a great episode of Flying Through Time on Amazon Prime about the F-104 Starfighter. It may not have been successful in the U.S., but up till the mid 80s, it was almost the standard NATO fighter, and still serves in Turkey.
#94
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
#95
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
That's a favorite of mine too. My copy is in the 20th Century Fox "Studio Classics" set (aka Classic Quad #11) I picked up when it first came out (*5* years ago!?!) and *still* haven't opened it! It has: The Blue Max, The Desert Fox, Immortal Sergeant, and Sink the Bismarck all of which are among my most favorite war films. I plan to finally open and watch that set this year! 

#96
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
I'm of the mindset that older sport events and newscasts are perfect for this Challenge.
Current stuff? Eh. Unless you're 'challenging' yourself to watch stuff you hate, no.
Current stuff? Eh. Unless you're 'challenging' yourself to watch stuff you hate, no.
#97
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
After a day and a half of video games, I finally got bored and was ready to watch TV. I just finished an episode of Forensic Files on HLN. Not only did the murder suspect plead guilty, but at the sentencing, he asked for the death penalty. The jury was only too happy to oblige.
#98
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread

I'm still reading a history of Silent American Films, but I'm interspersing with fiction, so it's taken/taking ages...
#99
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
Aren't all documentaries also theoretically eligible, regardless of historical-ness..? Or did I imagine that?! If that's the case, I'd certainly argue that Westerns and War are more 'history" than many documentaries, even if they lack the "Truth" (theoretically) included in the docs. So those things (war/western vs. documentaries) would be two different sides of the History Challenge square/triangle/whatever. Both fine and in the spirit of things, but very different from each other.
#100
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The 6th Annual Historical Appreciation Challenge Discussion Thread
Here's one - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Joan_Pujol_Garcia
Possibly the only person who became a spy on their own, solely to become a self-made double agent, because he didn't like the Nazis. And was so effective in his chosen role that he was paid/extorted money to fund a vast fictional network of spies... sowed misinformation critical (so they say) in keeping many troops away from the D-Day landings, and the ultimate clincher: he won top awards from BOTH SIDES for services rendered, Even though half those services were fake!



