Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I'll throw my name into the hat to keep score.

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I'll probably be super busy around that time, but I can also help keep score if needed (I love stats and do it all the time on my own forum, so it's fun for me :D )

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

I really want to watch Killer Tongue now :(

Also, for that horror list I made The Nightmare Before Christmas is ranked at 584. On the other hand, people [not too many] also voted for stuff like The Sound of Music, One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest, Hunger, Winter's Bone etc.. I don't think there has to be an overlap between what you consider horror and what has actual horror conventions/elements in it. I think something like The Nightmare Before Christmas has enough horror elements to be considered horror (the tone, atmosphere, Halloween, ghouls etc), whether you actually personally think of it as a horror film or not. I consider Psycho a pure thriller and not a horror film, but there are enough elements of horror in it, that I'm not bothered by labelling it as such.

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I never knew that you had a horror challenge facebook page. I'll have to look at it now.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

Exactly. I knew there were some genres that had to be in there but would not be for everyone. 70s porn, for instance. It's a legit exploitation genre but not everyone's cup of tea. The Drive-in Checklist is primarily definitional.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

Do it!

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

Is there any reason to have a FB page? Is it used during the challenge? I am not on Facebook so I have no knowledge of what it is used for in the challenge.

I figured this challenge helps steer some people to the slowly dying DVD talk and would hope all activity and comments happen here and not on Facebook at all.

But that could be just me.

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I would guess that the OHMC is the only thing that brings new members in, aside from the spammers. It seems as if there are new folks that join every year to participate.

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

This is a great idea, and I think it works the best. I am down to be assigned a category and tabilate it the end of the comp.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

For what it's worth I like the subsets and theme days without actively participating in them usually. It's something cool that adds to the challenge. I hope people don't think it is only about that when it's really about viewing as much horror as you can and celebrating the genre.

If Chad has to cut back on his contributions this year I feel like we can all pick up a little bit of slack to help him out. He's been a constant in this thing since it started and the 6+ years I've been around he's been amazing. This challenge has given me friends to talk to and supporters for my site/blog Celluloid Terror that I otherwise wouldn't have so I owe a debt of gratitude on a personal and semi-professional level to it. We're hopefully launching the new and vastly improved full version of CT by Halloween so this challenge will be special to me

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

I love the theme nights, subsets, and checklist... they're a great way to encourage variety and discussion.

Regarding stuff that is not horror, those occasionally sneak up but I feel like by far that's the exception to the rule - I agree the horror challenge should be horror focused including whatever optional components (seemingly no one is arguing for non-horror entries) but even that leaves a lot of 'gray areas' (ex: people defending Nightmare Before Xmas as horror).

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I'm happy to help in whatever facility - I'll volunteer for calculating 'films by decade' and 'total time watched' for all participants.

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

Just for the record, my enthusiasm for the challenge itself hasn't diminished a bit. It's also not just the monotony of the stats, but also the really time-consuming aspects of it. I've worked past Thanksgiving on more than one occasion and I just wanna enjoy the holidays. :)

There's quite a few that aren't active posters here aside from the challenge and it's really their main line of communication. And there's not much in the way of discussion aside from a few comments for the respective posts. It's mainly for announcing when new threads go up, sponsors coming on board, to announce the preparation of the optional lists, trivia questions, etc.

Appreciate it!

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

Awesome, I was worried you were burnt out on horror, which of course is cray cray.

But yeah assign them out and then just plug and play, distributed statistics yo.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

Now people are going to throw out It's a Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown soon too...

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

Anything Halloween-related should stay in, even if it's not strictly horror. I watch the Paul Lynde Halloween Special every year, along with Charlie Brown.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

There wouldn't even be an horror challenge in October if not for Halloween.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

We have to keep the Subsets, Theme Nights and Checklists. They have been a part of the challenege for a while, and help find new movies to watch. They are optional and should remain optional, just for people who want to strive to figure everything out.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

I think the request is just that Halloween only (non-horror) material not be placed into subset lists.

I support keeping the subset and theme nights horror focused even if Halloween only items do count for lists. If a movie isn't listed as "horror" on IMDB and/or other reliable database then it shouldn't be suggested viewing for a horror challenge. Halloween themed stuff should always be fine for lists, there's just some debate over how much Halloween only stuff should game for included as subset films.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

I'm fine with Halloween stuff being in any optional list since it's the month for Halloween and if there was no Halloween, there'd be no month dedicated to horror and this challenge wouldn't exist as it does.

Is there some example of a subset list filled with non-horror Halloween related films because I can't seem to remember any.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

People were debating how "horror" Nightmare Before Christmas is...

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I would state right from the get go that each person has to tabulate their own stats (whatever the agreed upon stats are at the very beginning of the challenge).

For those that do not complete their stats by the end of the 1st week of November (or however long you want to let it run), then they cannot expect to be up for any prizes.

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

I remember when some people were trying to qualify E.T. and Spider-man for the horror challenge.

That's the kind of stuff that gets on my nerves...but I still try to stay out of it.

Re: About this year's Horror Challenge...
 

I second Spiderbite's suggestion!

re: Comments, Suggestions & Feedback for the 2015 Horror Challenge
 

I never worry about other people's choices. Everybody has their own definitions of what they believe horror to be. I prefer my horror films to be strictly supernatural, but other folks might include suspense films, like Dressed to Kill or Se7en.

Me either.

For me, horror films have vampires, ghouls, witches, ghosts, werewolves and Lovecraftian entities from the spaces outside the universe.

For other people, horror might mean bunnies.

http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lz...x3d4o5_250.gif