7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
#101
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 57,813
Received 1,737 Likes
on
1,394 Posts
From: Home of 2013 NFL champion Seahawks
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
The first 75-80% or so of Sunshine is awesome. 
Watching ID4 for the holiday!

Watching ID4 for the holiday!
Highly depressed today, so I want something that doesn't take a lot of concentration. Maybe a scifi cartoon day today. If anyone cares, here is the story of why I am so sad today. We have two outdoor cats, a gray tiger female and a black male. The other day we discovered that Mama had had a couple of kittens. Last night every time I stepped outside, she was just sitting and laying on the porch like she was sad. And since we hadn't seen the kittens in a couple days, I just got this sad feeling with a tightness in my chest wash over me. I just know the kittens were killed or somehow didn't make it.
#102
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
That's a pretty fair assessment. That last bit was where I had most of my issues.
I might just throw that one on as well as it's been a few years since I last did a screening. I saw it in the theater the summer it opened when my wife and I did a dinner/movie "double-date" with one of my cousins and his wife. That was the film selected and my wife actually wanted to see it which was a huge surprise as SF is a genre she normally eschews completely. I had lots and lots of issues with the film but overall thought it was a pretty good turn-off-your-brain "popcorn flick." I watch it now for the over-the-top acting and camp appeal. My grandson is still here and he may enjoy it.
*EDIT*
...and... it's in the player. It was easily found so I threw it in to get his reaction. Now if I can only get his attention away from the "Minecraft" videos (I don't understand the appeal of the game much less watching videos of other people playing...).
I might just throw that one on as well as it's been a few years since I last did a screening. I saw it in the theater the summer it opened when my wife and I did a dinner/movie "double-date" with one of my cousins and his wife. That was the film selected and my wife actually wanted to see it which was a huge surprise as SF is a genre she normally eschews completely. I had lots and lots of issues with the film but overall thought it was a pretty good turn-off-your-brain "popcorn flick." I watch it now for the over-the-top acting and camp appeal. My grandson is still here and he may enjoy it.
*EDIT*
...and... it's in the player. It was easily found so I threw it in to get his reaction. Now if I can only get his attention away from the "Minecraft" videos (I don't understand the appeal of the game much less watching videos of other people playing...).
Last edited by BobO'Link; 07-03-14 at 04:18 PM.
#103
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I've gotten off to a pretty good start, focusing on rewatching Firefly as well as some new acquisitions (Gamera and Flash Gordon). Of course, the show is excellent, and I love the ensemble so very much! The crew of the Serenity is a lovable bunch of misfits.
Flash Gordon is fun in a low budget way. Buster Crabbe is great. Part of me really wishes all the supporting cast were more attractive. There's a lot of bare legs and torso, but all the men are middle-aged and stocky. I want a little more beefcake!
The Gamera series is just as low budget but not as fun. The first two films were paint-by-the-number affairs that focused too much on uninteresting characters. I'm curious about how the series is going to progress.
Flash Gordon is fun in a low budget way. Buster Crabbe is great. Part of me really wishes all the supporting cast were more attractive. There's a lot of bare legs and torso, but all the men are middle-aged and stocky. I want a little more beefcake!
The Gamera series is just as low budget but not as fun. The first two films were paint-by-the-number affairs that focused too much on uninteresting characters. I'm curious about how the series is going to progress.
#104
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Seriously though, you can't put any other good looking men against your star! After all, he's the main reason the ladies watched!

I picked up the 11 film DVD set a few weeks back. I think I've only seen a couple of the Gamera films up until now, mainly focusing on the Godzilla films. I always looked upon Gamera as a poor relation and the ones I've seen appear to be aimed squarely at the above mentioned prepubescent boys. I've always enjoyed the first one, and I'm somewhat excited to finally get to see it in the OAR and language, so we'll see how the series progresses as I get into the ones I've never before seen.
#105
DVD Talk Legend
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
My challenge has been off to a bit of a slow start, though I have managed to watch the Back to the Future trilogy which is always enjoyable. Now I look forward to several days off in the near future with plans to catch up on many things in my unwatched pile.
#106
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
What's worse is purchasing something you've already purchased but forgot! I've done that several times when I'd see a sale on a title I'd wanted and just jump on it before checking the collection properly. A couple of times I called myself checking the unwatched piles (the biggest cause of my accidental double-dips so far) only to come up empty, order the title, and when it comes in put it right on top of the original purchase! I really need to start cataloging stuff when I make the purchase rather than after I watch it..
Highly depressed today, so I want something that doesn't take a lot of concentration. Maybe a scifi cartoon day today. If anyone cares, here is the story of why I am so sad today. We have two outdoor cats, a gray tiger female and a black male. The other day we discovered that Mama had had a couple of kittens. Last night every time I stepped outside, she was just sitting and laying on the porch like she was sad. And since we hadn't seen the kittens in a couple days, I just got this sad feeling with a tightness in my chest wash over me. I just know the kittens were killed or somehow didn't make it.

As for Hansel & Gretel I picked that up Black Friday and I'm glad you mentioned it because I think I would have forgotten about it. I mainly picked it up because Jeremy Renner is in it and I've become...attached... since the Avengers movie.
I am just hoping it's not so bad as to be unwatchable and I'll be happy with the investment.I've gotten off to a pretty good start, focusing on rewatching Firefly as well as some new acquisitions (Gamera and Flash Gordon). Of course, the show is excellent, and I love the ensemble so very much! The crew of the Serenity is a lovable bunch of misfits.
Flash Gordon is fun in a low budget way. Buster Crabbe is great. Part of me really wishes all the supporting cast were more attractive. There's a lot of bare legs and torso, but all the men are middle-aged and stocky. I want a little more beefcake!
Flash Gordon is fun in a low budget way. Buster Crabbe is great. Part of me really wishes all the supporting cast were more attractive. There's a lot of bare legs and torso, but all the men are middle-aged and stocky. I want a little more beefcake!
I enjoy the '80s Flash Gordon myself. Such a fun watch. I remember it playing all the time on TV back then and eventually I made a copy, commercials and all. I love the winged guys and the battle on that platform with the spikes. Don't ask me why! I've long since lost the VHS copy, but have picked up the DVD...hmm, this may also go on the list...
I just finished watching Jack and the Giant Slayer. This one has gotten some negative press, if I remember right, but I found it entertaining. I wasn't looking for Oscar material and didn't get it, but I enjoyed what was presented. I'd watch it again. I don't know that I need to own it, but if I came across it in a bargain bin, I'd pick it up.
#107
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
All this talk of Hansel and Gretel makes me want to give it another shot, as I see it on quite a few channels on Roku. Maybe even the Asylum ripoff, Hansel and Gretel: Warriors of Witchcraft. Not tonight though. After taking most of the day off the challenge due to sadness, ready to get back into it, with something easy. Maybe kaiju or sci fi cartoons.
#108
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
For those who have cable, Encore is doing an Independence Day marathon.
Last edited by Gobear; 07-04-14 at 02:12 PM.
#109
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#110
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
It's almost criminal the way Fox treated Firefly. I stopped trying to watch it during the original run. The DVDs made the difference and proved it to be a quality show that *should* have run for several years had it not been bungled, both in scheduling *and* marketing. It's one of my favorites.
Those were produced primarily for prepubescent boys who want action, adventure, and a good looking girl or two. They couldn't care less about "beefcake!"
Seriously though, you can't put any other good looking men against your star! After all, he's the main reason the ladies watched!
Seriously though, you can't put any other good looking men against your star! After all, he's the main reason the ladies watched!

I'm pretty busy this weekend, but hopefully I will find the time to finish up the first set of serials. No one in my family shares my interest in such things, so I'll have to sneak away.
I enjoy the '80s Flash Gordon myself. Such a fun watch. I remember it playing all the time on TV back then and eventually I made a copy, commercials and all. I love the winged guys and the battle on that platform with the spikes. Don't ask me why! I've long since lost the VHS copy, but have picked up the DVD...hmm, this may also go on the list...
#111
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
While a lot of people watched Independence Day today, I opted for the alien invasion movie that came out around the same time (and the one I liked a lot more), Mars Attacks!. Such a great cast (Jack Nicholson (playing two different roles for no particular reason), Glenn Close, Pierce Brosnan, Danny Devito, Natalie Portman, a young Jack Black, Joe Don Baker (MITCHELL!!), and even Tom freakin' Jones! I personally found it much more enjoyable then ID4, and just as plausible when you think about it.
#112
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I ordered a TCM Sci-Fi Greatest Hits with 4 classic sci-fi movies from Amazon today. The set contains 2001: A Space Odyssey, Soylent Green, Forbidden Planet, and the 1960 Time Machine. Hopefully, this time when I watch 2001, I might be able to understand the ending, as last time I saw it, it went right over my head.
#113
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I ordered a TCM Sci-Fi Greatest Hits with 4 classic sci-fi movies from Amazon today. The set contains 2001: A Space Odyssey, Soylent Green, Forbidden Planet, and the 1960 Time Machine. Hopefully, this time when I watch 2001, I might be able to understand the ending, as last time I saw it, it went right over my head.
#114
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
While a lot of people watched Independence Day today, I opted for the alien invasion movie that came out around the same time (and the one I liked a lot more), Mars Attacks!. Such a great cast (Jack Nicholson (playing two different roles for no particular reason), Glenn Close, Pierce Brosnan, Danny Devito, Natalie Portman, a young Jack Black, Joe Don Baker (MITCHELL!!), and even Tom freakin' Jones! I personally found it much more enjoyable then ID4, and just as plausible when you think about it.
I also decided against Independence Day, opting instead for Captain America: The First Avenger as my patriotic selection. I watched it with my grandparents who were extremely entertained. It's my favorite of the first wave of Marvel films. I sometimes prefer my superheroes less pompous than Iron Man or Thor and more memorable than the Incredible Hulk. (For the life of me, I can't remember that movie. I think Liv Tyler runs around reacting to things.)
#115
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Well, I ended up watching a movie tonight that I thought I'd never see and wasn't on my list to watch. My brother convinced me to watch "Rise of the Planet of the Apes" which I had no desire to ever see. I have to admit it wasn't as bad as I was fearing (hate James Franco and the CGI wasn't very consistent) but I doubt I'll watch the sequel or even feel the need to. I admit, I'm not a fan of the originals or the other remake that Burton? did.
It's funny that "Mars Attacks" is being mentioned as I had planned on watching that tonight, but perhaps I'll get to it later. I love all of it. It's such a fun watch.
It's funny that "Mars Attacks" is being mentioned as I had planned on watching that tonight, but perhaps I'll get to it later. I love all of it. It's such a fun watch.
#116
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
We watched I Am Legend last night, the first (and I expect only) time with the alternate ending. I don't think they could have come up with a worse ending. If I had seen the alternate ending version first, I don't think I would have ever watched the movie again.
#117
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
While searching for my copy of The Last Unicorn the other day, I came across my set with the trilogy of the first 3 Resident Evil movies, so I decided to watch them today. Milla really kicks some serious ***. Just finished the first movie. Seen the first two, but never seen any mire after that. May watch Afterlife after that, as I see it online.
#118
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Went to the theater and saw Snowpiercer today. What an interesting film. It was worth the price of admission to watch Chris Evans slip on a fish during a fight scene. I think I read that the graphic novel the film is based on has been translated into English, I think I'll pick it up.
#119
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Went to the theater and saw Snowpiercer today. What an interesting film. It was worth the price of admission to watch Chris Evans slip on a fish during a fight scene. I think I read that the graphic novel the film is based on has been translated into English, I think I'll pick it up.
#120
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Orphan Black's on Amazon Prime, and it's really good. 
I lowered my expectations as far as I could, and still thought it was terrible a year or so ago..!
But the underlined part is my problem, certainly. Why call it Catwoman if you aren't going to base it on Catwoman?!
It's the steampunk effect, certainly.. although I enjoyed it quite a lot more than I'd thought I would when I saw it. I actually thought that without the 'modern' touches it wouldn't have been as enjoyable as it was..

..I sucked it up and put in the copy of Catwoman (2004) I'd picked up on sale at BL over the winter. Yes... I purchased a copy in spite of all the bad reviews and comments. Kind of like a train wreck - I had to see for myself so picked up a copy for ~$1. I was expecting the worst and got a little better than my expectations - as long as I didn't think too much. If you strip away that it's supposedly based on the DC comics character it's a passable, although generic and cliched, super hero type origin story. I kept thinking how the back story seemed more similar to Spider-Man than Catwoman but had to remind myself that she didn't get her abilities from dropping in the goop in the factory but rather from this mystical cat who has seemingly lived since ancient Egyptian times. There were several what I'd consider to be plot holes but, again, if you don't think too hard they are easily overlooked. I gave it 4 stars out of 10 and would watch it again if someone came over and really wanted to see it. Still... It's pretty much a dog of a film if you watch with a critical eye.
But the underlined part is my problem, certainly. Why call it Catwoman if you aren't going to base it on Catwoman?!After that: Hansel & Gretel: Witch Hunters (2013). I really wanted to like this more than I did. While it was enjoyable it's just another attempt to spice up a gothic type horror tale with "modern" weapons and fighting styles. I've really grown tired of the current trend to turn everything into some type of action flick with endless ninja style fights. Had this been done in a more "traditional" style I think they'd have had a really good film. As it is, it's a fun diversion but nothing really memorable.
#121
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread

Because of your post I got out my copy and watched a couple of chapters with my grandson. He really enjoyed what he saw before falling asleep (in all fairness I *did* wait until 9:30 or so before I started them). I hope to get the entire first serial in with him before the challenge ends.
I, too, like Mars Attacks better than ID4.
Well, I ended up watching a movie tonight that I thought I'd never see and wasn't on my list to watch. My brother convinced me to watch "Rise of the Planet of the Apes" which I had no desire to ever see. I have to admit it wasn't as bad as I was fearing (hate James Franco and the CGI wasn't very consistent) but I doubt I'll watch the sequel or even feel the need to. I admit, I'm not a fan of the originals or the other remake that Burton? did.
But you surely are not including the original POTA with Charlton Heston? That one is a SF classic!
On that note, my grandson and I watched "Beneath...", "Escape from...", and "Conquest of...", yesterday in a mini-marathon. I'm waiting on him to come back over to watch "Battle for..." (IMHO the absolute worst one made - even worse than the Burton film) and will probably watch the Burton version and the new relaunch series. He's really enjoying them, which is understandable as those last 4 were primarily aimed at the kid market.
I'm not much of a fan of the sequels but had wanted a copy of "Beneath...", even though it's not truly all that good, mainly for the bit of closure it provides (until someone figured out how to get around that for the third film). I got all 5 in a set for less than the cost of "Beneath..." alone so figured "Why not?"
I watched the set's bonus documentary (checklist item!), Behind the Planet of the Apes, this morning and found it to be quite good and highly entertaining. Over half of the 2 hour + (!) run time was devoted to the original with the sequels and TV shows each getting about as much attention as they truly deserve.
#122
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
I watched the new version of The Lost World (1925) that came as a bonus feature with the 1962 film. Honestly I didn't see too much difference in what I recall from the Legend copy I already own. But I'm not too familiar with the film and would need to screen both simultaneously to see the differences. No matter - it's still a good film and better than the 1960 version.
#123
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
My feelings exactly. I watched a bit of the mini-documentary on the disc because it had Julie Newmar and Lee Meriwether doing some of the talking head stuff. At some point someone (don't recall just who) said it deviated from the "origin" as Catwoman never really had one and every era has a different version of Catwoman. I guess that kind of works - *but* when the majority of people going to see the film are expecting the Selina Kyle version but get a all new interpretation you're just asking for trouble! I guess someone didn't pay attention to Burton's reimagined POTA, eh?
#124
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
To whomever mentioned/recommended The Mighty Peking Man in one of the challenge threads the past few months:
THANK YOU!
I did a blind buy based on the comments that were made and finally watched it this morning. What a hoot! It's one of the funniest films I've seen this year!
THANK YOU!
I did a blind buy based on the comments that were made and finally watched it this morning. What a hoot! It's one of the funniest films I've seen this year!
#125
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: 7th Annual Sci-Fi/Fantasy Challenge Discussion Thread
Well, I've used up my second wildcard already, although I don't think I necessarily should have needed to, for Terry Gilliam's Tideland. Neither IMDB nor allmovie.com mentioned fantasy in their genres but Wikipedia calls it a "fantasy thriller". I didn't know anything about it before watching it but assumed it would qualify, being a Gilliam picture after all. It definitely had fantasy elements in it.
I'm going on a bit of a Gilliam kick this week, because Zero Theorem starts here on Friday! Man! I can't wait to see that!
I'm going on a bit of a Gilliam kick this week, because Zero Theorem starts here on Friday! Man! I can't wait to see that!



