Renting/Buying
#26
DVD Talk Reviewer/ Admin
Join Date: Sep 1999
Location: Greenville, South Cackalack
Posts: 28,803
Received 1,878 Likes
on
1,236 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
I absolutely have a collectors' mentality, and because of that, I buy rather than rent. I can't qualify it anymore than to say I like one and don't find any appeal in the other. It's pretty rare for me to rewatch anything, so renting would clearly make more sense, but I like having lots of movies immediately at my fingertips anyway.
It's not a compulsive thing, though. I'll go a couple of weeks sometimes without buying anything. I never really have much of a backlog, so it's not as if I have shelves and shelves of unwatched stuff.
#27
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Renting/Buying
With the recent addition of vast amounts of titles for Instant Playing on Netflix. The "need to buy to watch right now" is not a very good excuse no more.
So I buy because I'm a collector. Those limited edition sets with books and everything are just too much to resist
PS: just got me the Limited Edition of 300
So I buy because I'm a collector. Those limited edition sets with books and everything are just too much to resist
PS: just got me the Limited Edition of 300
Last edited by nando820; 06-25-10 at 04:24 PM.
#28
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Renting/Buying
For people who own over a thousand dvds, I can't see how you continue purchasing dvds. How often do you expect repeat viewings? Its more compulsive buying than anything else...
I feel sad for people like gutwrencher who had something like over 3 thousand dvds and who justified his spending by claiming it was for his personal library. Its like the core of his existence was centered around his dvds... 3 thousand dvds.... you can watch a movie a day for 10 years without repeating...
I feel sad for people like gutwrencher who had something like over 3 thousand dvds and who justified his spending by claiming it was for his personal library. Its like the core of his existence was centered around his dvds... 3 thousand dvds.... you can watch a movie a day for 10 years without repeating...
I agree with Post 19 and 21. Most of the people in this forum are compulsive shoppers. I have a friend at work who owns almost 2000 DVD's and BR's and never watches any of them. Yet, he still goes to Mom and Pop stores and rents stuff every week.
I like movies just as much as anyone in this forum and still buy alot when I find good deals, but I can't afford everything I want and I simply don't have time to watch everything. I still have to sleep, eat and go to work. Plus, I still have other bills to pay like car payment, rent and other expenses. Rental services like Netflix help alot when I'm bored and want to watch something that I don't need to own permanently.
I like movies just as much as anyone in this forum and still buy alot when I find good deals, but I can't afford everything I want and I simply don't have time to watch everything. I still have to sleep, eat and go to work. Plus, I still have other bills to pay like car payment, rent and other expenses. Rental services like Netflix help alot when I'm bored and want to watch something that I don't need to own permanently.
I own several thousand titles, but I've spent less money on them the past 12 years than some people have spent on renting fewer titles.
I spend less money on DVDs than a smoker spends on cigarettes.
Less than a social drinker spends on alcohol.
Less than a skydiver spends on their hobby.
Less than countless people spend on their various hobbies/passions/addictions.
I enjoy films and DVDs and collecting them, and spend $5-10 a day on my hobby. I have a job with lots of downtime and easily watch the equivalent of two films per day every day. I buy a lot, but I watch, or will watch, pretty much everything I buy.
I like having an extensive library ready to meet any type of viewing desire my family/friends or myself might want that moment. I like having dozens or hundreds of blind buys ready for that day's entertainment. I enjoy the collecting aspect of it.
Obviously, each of us is different and many people prefer to put their time and money into other things. Saying that you 'feel sad' for us strikes me as intolerant and judgmental. Too each their own, as long as what you do makes you happy and doesn't infringe on others.
#29
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Millville, New Jersey
Posts: 3,038
Likes: 0
Received 24 Likes
on
16 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
I don't understand people who refuse to rent. Do you just buy EVERYTHING, or do you not watch that many movies? I like to watch a lot of movies, but only about 5% of new releases are titles that I'd like to have in my permanent collection. I'd miss a lot of decent movies if I limited myself to only buy or skip.
Last edited by JOE29; 06-26-10 at 09:13 AM.
#30
Banned
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: The lonely depths of my mind
Posts: 3,863
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Re: Renting/Buying
I haven't even been in a Blockbuster in about 10 years. Even then, it wasn't to rent. But I mainly buy. It's a lot cheaper than going to the theaters. 10 to 20 dollars for seeing it once, or 10 to 20 for seeing it as much as you want. The last movie I remember renting was Night At The Museum a few years ago. It was from one of those boxes at McDonald's.
#31
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Renting/Buying
For people who own over a thousand dvds, I can't see how you continue purchasing dvds. How often do you expect repeat viewings? Its more compulsive buying than anything else...
I feel sad for people like gutwrencher who had something like over 3 thousand dvds and who justified his spending by claiming it was for his personal library. Its like the core of his existence was centered around his dvds... 3 thousand dvds.... you can watch a movie a day for 10 years without repeating...
I feel sad for people like gutwrencher who had something like over 3 thousand dvds and who justified his spending by claiming it was for his personal library. Its like the core of his existence was centered around his dvds... 3 thousand dvds.... you can watch a movie a day for 10 years without repeating...
I have a similiar large collection. About 800 items. And that is counting an entire tv season as one single item. It will take me many years to get through the collection, but I enjoy the aspect of being able to choose what to watch. In fact, I developed a routine:
Watch 2 - 5 discs of tv seasons
Watch 1 disc of wrestling dvds
Watch a movie dvd
Watch a super hero movie
Watch a blu-ray
Watch a new release
Then I repeat the cycle. I have fun doing it.
As for renting, I started Netflix a year ago, and I'll admit, it's hard to stop. The Netflix streaming attracts me because they have so many documentaries that I would otherwise not see or purchase. Also, I can watch all the new release
blu-rays without spending the ridiculous $24.99 store price.
But after a year of Netflix, I realize that I've spent well over $100 bucks, and I have nothing to show for it. I could have taken that same $100 bucks and bought several dvds. It's all a matter of perception, I suppose.
#32
Member
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 249
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
For people who own over a thousand dvds, I can't see how you continue purchasing dvds. How often do you expect repeat viewings? Its more compulsive buying than anything else...
I feel sad for people like gutwrencher who had something like over 3 thousand dvds and who justified his spending by claiming it was for his personal library. Its like the core of his existence was centered around his dvds... 3 thousand dvds.... you can watch a movie a day for 10 years without repeating...
I feel sad for people like gutwrencher who had something like over 3 thousand dvds and who justified his spending by claiming it was for his personal library. Its like the core of his existence was centered around his dvds... 3 thousand dvds.... you can watch a movie a day for 10 years without repeating...
It gives one "pleasure" to do such things.
#33
Banned
Re: Renting/Buying
It's a hobby, and I enjoy watching them. Hey, it's better than drugs right?
#34
DVD Talk God
Re: Renting/Buying
As I mentioned earlier, the problem I see is that many who buy constantly just throw them in the closet and never bother watching them.
My friend who has 2,000+ DVD and BR's has an insane amount of unwatched titles, yet he buys 2-5 new releases a week and goes to Mom and Pop stores to rent and also rents from Netflix and watches shit on TV as well. I mean it's a never ending cycle.
I mean yeah great you collect a shit load of DVD's and BR's...But, what good is it going to do you to have all those 2-3 disc special editions with 15 hours of extras sitting in your closet because you just have to have it, but don't actually have time to watch them.
I mean you spend $18-20 a month on Netflix and you can watch alot more and feel gratified that you have actually seen the movie IMO.
I rent 10-12 titles a month (3 out at a time) on Netflix. Do I need to own all of them just to feel gratified that I have some physical possession in my closet...Absolutely Not.
My friend who has 2,000+ DVD and BR's has an insane amount of unwatched titles, yet he buys 2-5 new releases a week and goes to Mom and Pop stores to rent and also rents from Netflix and watches shit on TV as well. I mean it's a never ending cycle.
I mean yeah great you collect a shit load of DVD's and BR's...But, what good is it going to do you to have all those 2-3 disc special editions with 15 hours of extras sitting in your closet because you just have to have it, but don't actually have time to watch them.
I mean you spend $18-20 a month on Netflix and you can watch alot more and feel gratified that you have actually seen the movie IMO.
I rent 10-12 titles a month (3 out at a time) on Netflix. Do I need to own all of them just to feel gratified that I have some physical possession in my closet...Absolutely Not.
Last edited by DJariya; 06-28-10 at 05:27 PM.
#35
Member
Join Date: Jun 2010
Location: Michigan
Posts: 75
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
I never rent, just buy. That said I only buy when the movie in question is on sale or discounted to $10 or less to save money. If it is something I really want, I will go $15 max for a DVD and $20 max for a Blu-ray.
#36
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Renting/Buying
Definitely buying a lot more than I rent nowadays.
I know Netflix is way easier, but I found myself renting more when my local Mom & Pop shop had 5/$5 Thursday's.
I know Netflix is way easier, but I found myself renting more when my local Mom & Pop shop had 5/$5 Thursday's.
#37
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#39
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Renting/Buying
If you happen to see a forgettable or bad movie in the theatre, at least the experience is over and done with unlike blind buying a bad movie on DVD which sits on your shelf as a constant reminder that you just wasted your money a movie you'll never watch again!
#40
Re: Renting/Buying
In the early days of DVD...certainly more buying. These days, more renting.
When I had just a VCR I rented more than I bought. I did have a fair selection of VHS in my collection, but not a huge amount. I was really picky on the things I bought, and often bought previously viewed or waited until a good sale came along when I did. I see myself swinging back that way now with Blu-Ray. I bought a handful of titles I really wanted when I got my player and have been renting everything else.
My basic rule of thumb is if I haven't watched it more than once on DVD in the past decade, there's really no compelling reason for me to buy it on Blu-Ray over again. I can just rent it if I really want to see something again in high def.
When I had just a VCR I rented more than I bought. I did have a fair selection of VHS in my collection, but not a huge amount. I was really picky on the things I bought, and often bought previously viewed or waited until a good sale came along when I did. I see myself swinging back that way now with Blu-Ray. I bought a handful of titles I really wanted when I got my player and have been renting everything else.
My basic rule of thumb is if I haven't watched it more than once on DVD in the past decade, there's really no compelling reason for me to buy it on Blu-Ray over again. I can just rent it if I really want to see something again in high def.
#41
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Re: Renting/Buying
In the early days of DVD...certainly more buying. These days, more renting.
When I had just a VCR I rented more than I bought. I did have a fair selection of VHS in my collection, but not a huge amount. I was really picky on the things I bought, and often bought previously viewed or waited until a good sale came along when I did. I see myself swinging back that way now with Blu-Ray. I bought a handful of titles I really wanted when I got my player and have been renting everything else.
My basic rule of thumb is if I haven't watched it more than once on DVD in the past decade, there's really no compelling reason for me to buy it on Blu-Ray over again. I can just rent it if I really want to see something again in high def.
When I had just a VCR I rented more than I bought. I did have a fair selection of VHS in my collection, but not a huge amount. I was really picky on the things I bought, and often bought previously viewed or waited until a good sale came along when I did. I see myself swinging back that way now with Blu-Ray. I bought a handful of titles I really wanted when I got my player and have been renting everything else.
My basic rule of thumb is if I haven't watched it more than once on DVD in the past decade, there's really no compelling reason for me to buy it on Blu-Ray over again. I can just rent it if I really want to see something again in high def.
Weren't VHS movies unreasonably expensive too?
I remember them come drastically down in price just before DVD took over and thats when I started to collect movies. Luckily I only bought 10-15 vhs before I got into the dvd phase.
I make sure I watch a movie now before I buy it, and many of the movies in my unwatched pile I have actually seen, but not since I bought it..
Not many blind buys anymore other than cheap ones or ones I know I'll like such as films with my favorite actors, directors. Red Cliff and Shutter Island are the most recent 2.
#42
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Renting/Buying
VHS tapes were generally intended to be sold as rentals, so most new releases had a price tag of $89.95.
Through much of the 1980s you pretty much had to purchase most tapes used from a rental store. I think the very first brand new pre-recorded video tape I remember seeing for sale was Jaws in a K-Mart back in 1985 for $29.95.
Through much of the 1980s you pretty much had to purchase most tapes used from a rental store. I think the very first brand new pre-recorded video tape I remember seeing for sale was Jaws in a K-Mart back in 1985 for $29.95.
#43
Guest
Join Date: Sep 2009
Posts: 900
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
Haven't rented in years, but I'm also not a compulsive buyer.
I rarely blind-buy, and when I do, it's on the cheap - the $5 bin.
My DVD collection is holding steady at about 400 titles, not including TV series (about 50 box sets)
I can honestly say everything I have, I can watch and enjoy repeatedly (although some more than others).
If there's something new I want to see, I see it in theaters. I enjoy the theater-going experience. It's a social thing.
I rarely blind-buy, and when I do, it's on the cheap - the $5 bin.
My DVD collection is holding steady at about 400 titles, not including TV series (about 50 box sets)
I can honestly say everything I have, I can watch and enjoy repeatedly (although some more than others).
If there's something new I want to see, I see it in theaters. I enjoy the theater-going experience. It's a social thing.
#44
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: Millville, New Jersey
Posts: 3,038
Likes: 0
Received 24 Likes
on
16 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
This is true and it's often how I used to justify many DVD/VHS purchases. At the same time it is nice to get out of the house and go to a first-run movie. By the time it comes out on DVD, it's old news. It is a better experience than simply plugging in a disc at home.
If you happen to see a forgettable or bad movie in the theatre, at least the experience is over and done with unlike blind buying a bad movie on DVD which sits on your shelf as a constant reminder that you just wasted your money a movie you'll never watch again!
If you happen to see a forgettable or bad movie in the theatre, at least the experience is over and done with unlike blind buying a bad movie on DVD which sits on your shelf as a constant reminder that you just wasted your money a movie you'll never watch again!
As for a blind buy, bad movie purchase I have made several of those over the years but I have had the luxury of trading them back in or selling them off to get rid of the bad ones. I only keep the ones that I like and that I feel that some point in the future, I will re- watch them. If I had kept everything that I ever bought, man, my collection would have been double of what i have now.
#46
DVD Talk Special Edition
Re: Renting/Buying
I guess it's a form of denial. You always think you may watch it again or a friend or relative may want to see it someday but it never happens.
Considering you'll probably only get a buck for it anyway, you end up keeping it instead.
Considering you'll probably only get a buck for it anyway, you end up keeping it instead.
#47
Cool New Member
Join Date: Jul 2009
Location: CA
Posts: 49
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
Good topic and one that made me come to the realization that i just dont have enough time to watch anymore movies do to other activities and spending time posting on here lol so i signed up with blockbuster online. I have dvds but not movie wise as those are in blu ray. Im more of a cartoon collector so i have dvd sets that range from simpsons, ducktales, to the old school stuff i love like voltron heman thundercats etc. i try to watch an hour worth of different cartoons before i go to sleep hahah. I have never bought anything on release date and picked up good deals on the sets either through sites like gohastings, amazon, and ebay. btw how do you post pics i wanna post so you guys can see what i have
#48
DVD Talk Legend
Re: Renting/Buying
I've recently decided I'd rather have the buck and get it out of my sight than keep it out of some bizarre sense of denial and it also creates more space for titles I truly want to keep.
Last edited by milo bloom; 07-01-10 at 09:31 AM.
#49
Senior Member
Join Date: Feb 1999
Location: Durham, NC USA
Posts: 994
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Renting/Buying
Most of the DVDs I buy are not something you could rent. Film noir classics? Hammer Pirate films from the 50s? Haven't seen these locally to rent.. and it is much more efficient for box sets to buy - it will take me literally months to go through a typical boxset (i watch all the special features and listen to the commentaries). Renting this even at Redbox at $1/day would end up being more than the box set!
Box sets aside, my taste and time available to see anything is very varied. Sometime I may only have 45 minutes to watch something (TV episode fits nicely), 90 minutes (an older film, probably), or 2 hours (modern film). Or my mood might be for horror, comedy, etc...never know... Renting for me is nuts. I use to do it and then found days until I got around to watching something, and wasn't in the mood for that genre at that time!
But I don't like to pay more than $5 for any single movie.. $3 or 4 is better.. For those prices, I save money from renting (redbox excluded).
I cancelled cable long ago..Still some far less money per month buying DVDs than I ever would getting cable.
So, no brainer to me..
Box sets aside, my taste and time available to see anything is very varied. Sometime I may only have 45 minutes to watch something (TV episode fits nicely), 90 minutes (an older film, probably), or 2 hours (modern film). Or my mood might be for horror, comedy, etc...never know... Renting for me is nuts. I use to do it and then found days until I got around to watching something, and wasn't in the mood for that genre at that time!
But I don't like to pay more than $5 for any single movie.. $3 or 4 is better.. For those prices, I save money from renting (redbox excluded).
I cancelled cable long ago..Still some far less money per month buying DVDs than I ever would getting cable.
So, no brainer to me..
#50
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
Re: Renting/Buying
There is probably a primer on it in the forum FAQ or feedback thread somewhere. But basically, one key point is to not hotlink to images on general sites, but first save the picture to an image sharing site like photobucket and then link it from there. There is a picture button on the editing toolbar of every post you make.
Most of the DVDs I buy are not something you could rent. Film noir classics? Hammer Pirate films from the 50s? Haven't seen these locally to rent.. and it is much more efficient for box sets to buy - it will take me literally months to go through a typical boxset (i watch all the special features and listen to the commentaries). Renting this even at Redbox at $1/day would end up being more than the box set!
Box sets aside, my taste and time available to see anything is very varied. Sometime I may only have 45 minutes to watch something (TV episode fits nicely), 90 minutes (an older film, probably), or 2 hours (modern film). Or my mood might be for horror, comedy, etc...never know... Renting for me is nuts. I use to do it and then found days until I got around to watching something, and wasn't in the mood for that genre at that time!
But I don't like to pay more than $5 for any single movie.. $3 or 4 is better.. For those prices, I save money from renting (redbox excluded).
I cancelled cable long ago..Still some far less money per month buying DVDs than I ever would getting cable.
So, no brainer to me..
Box sets aside, my taste and time available to see anything is very varied. Sometime I may only have 45 minutes to watch something (TV episode fits nicely), 90 minutes (an older film, probably), or 2 hours (modern film). Or my mood might be for horror, comedy, etc...never know... Renting for me is nuts. I use to do it and then found days until I got around to watching something, and wasn't in the mood for that genre at that time!
But I don't like to pay more than $5 for any single movie.. $3 or 4 is better.. For those prices, I save money from renting (redbox excluded).
I cancelled cable long ago..Still some far less money per month buying DVDs than I ever would getting cable.
So, no brainer to me..