Am I being too anal or is is just the way this thing was poorly put together. I got one from Amazon and the bottom had a huge dent and inside 2 of the cases had the spindle broken. I send it back and got a new one today. This one has a dent on top and 2 of the cases again have parts of the spindle broken (but can still hold the dvd in place, as the old one could not). Should I send it back to Amazon again for a replacement, or just be happy with this one?

i have it. think i got it from Amazon way back when. came surprisingly perfect for such a big, heavy set. not sure what to tell you, but i wouldn't want something damaged like that if i paid some nice money for it.

Thanks, I guess I'll take my chances and send it back in the morning and hope I get a good one.

When I received mine in the mail from Amazon.com it was pretty dented, but no cases broken. I was able to push the dents out of the tin with my thumb and finger and it's okay for me - but I am not a 100% perfectionist.