Halloween Collection
#52
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Halloween Collection
#54
Cool New Member
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Halloween Collection
Didn't realize there were that many versions of 6.

I have the Producer's Cut. Guess I better start searching some torrent sites.
#55
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
#56
Member
Joined: Aug 2008
Posts: 72
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Sunnydale
Re: Halloween Collection
Ok I'm sure this question has been asked before but I am going to finsh off my Halloween Collection soon and I was going to ask a few questions before I go out and buy them. Right now I have: Halloween: Digitally Remastered THX, Halloween (Remake) Rated and Unrated, and Halloween Resurrection.
Which (if multiple versions availabe) version of each should I buy?
Is the Halloween 25 Years of Terror DVD Worth It?
Should I get three because I've seen it and it sucked so bad so is my collection incomplete without it or is it better off?
Should I buy the 3-Disc Version of Rob Zombie's Halloween?
Which (if multiple versions availabe) version of each should I buy?
Is the Halloween 25 Years of Terror DVD Worth It?
Should I get three because I've seen it and it sucked so bad so is my collection incomplete without it or is it better off?
Should I buy the 3-Disc Version of Rob Zombie's Halloween?
I say go ahead and get Part 3 too. It got a lot of bad press, but taken on it's own, it's kind of a fun and interesting movie. It still has that great early 80s/Dean Cundey vibe to it and a great mood to it that a lot of later sequels didn't have.
#57
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
#58
Cool New Member
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 45
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Halloween Collection
And that would be a good thing...Halloween with Michael Myers is a waste of time after the second one. Just another slasher flick after that(just my opinion but true..lol). Halloween III would be considered a cult classic(to many of us still is) if it weren't for the fact it got stuck in that franchise. Had it been just called Season of the Witch it wouldn't be getting any crap. Heaven forbid we ever have an original story in horror better to have 20 sequels...ugh! 301 more days til halloween, halloween, halloween. 301 more days til Halloween, Silver Shamrock!!!
Last edited by Litfuel716; 01-03-10 at 06:06 PM.
#59
Banned
Re: Halloween Collection
I'd like to know where and how you got an anamorphic R1 cut of this film as the studio released it as non-anamorphic as 1rst described in this thread.
Mine is definately not anamorphic. And I have th 25th year anniversary Anchor Bay Divimax edition of Halloween...is this the approved version as it does not mention THX Certified. I must say though I am very pleased with the edition I have!
Mine is definately not anamorphic. And I have th 25th year anniversary Anchor Bay Divimax edition of Halloween...is this the approved version as it does not mention THX Certified. I must say though I am very pleased with the edition I have!
#60
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Halloween Collection
And that would be a good thing...Halloween with Michael Myers is a waste of time after the second one. Just another slasher flick after that(just my opinion but true..lol). Halloween III would be considered a cult classic(to many of us still is) if it weren't for the fact it got stuck in that franchise. Had it been just called Season of the Witch it wouldn't be getting any crap. Heaven forbid we ever have an original story in horror better to have 20 sequels...ugh! 301 more days til halloween, halloween, halloween. 301 more days til Halloween, Silver Shamrock!!!
#61
Senior Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 525
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Antarctica
Re: Halloween Collection
And that would be a good thing...Halloween with Michael Myers is a waste of time after the second one. Just another slasher flick after that(just my opinion but true..lol). Halloween III would be considered a cult classic(to many of us still is) if it weren't for the fact it got stuck in that franchise. Had it been just called Season of the Witch it wouldn't be getting any crap. Heaven forbid we ever have an original story in horror better to have 20 sequels...ugh! 301 more days til halloween, halloween, halloween. 301 more days til Halloween, Silver Shamrock!!!
Over the years, I appreciate HALLOWEEN 3 more and more. It's still not a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, but it is a thing of its time and does offer some original fun that #4 and on don't. People may still have hated it if it wasn't under the HALLOWEEN banner, but how anyone can defend #5, 6, or 8 and trash #3 for trying something new is beyond me.
#62
Cool New Member
Joined: Dec 2009
Posts: 45
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Halloween Collection
You're relatively new here, so welcome, and you're already contributing with an intelligent comment! I agree with you 100%. The HALLOWEEN sequels with Michael Myers are dreadful - and I mean all of them, except #2 which is decent. I saw all the HALLOWEEN films as they were released and was sick of Michael Myers from #4 on. As far as the merits (or non-merits) of HALLOWEEN 3 goes, I didn't much like the film when it first came out, but it had nothing to do with the absence of Michael Myers. I just thought the film was stupid (which it is, but at least in a fun way in the right mindset). At that point, I really appreciated the idea of their plan to do an entirely different story and screenplay each year for the HALLOWEEN franchise instead of the usual crappy sequels. Unfortunately, that never happened as #3 wasn't well received and eventually Michael Myers was resurrected for the never-ending terrible and repetitive sequels.
Over the years, I appreciate HALLOWEEN 3 more and more. It's still not a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, but it is a thing of its time and does offer some original fun that #4 and on don't. People may still have hated it if it wasn't under the HALLOWEEN banner, but how anyone can defend #5, 6, or 8 and trash #3 for trying something new is beyond me.
Over the years, I appreciate HALLOWEEN 3 more and more. It's still not a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, but it is a thing of its time and does offer some original fun that #4 and on don't. People may still have hated it if it wasn't under the HALLOWEEN banner, but how anyone can defend #5, 6, or 8 and trash #3 for trying something new is beyond me.
Oh and The Monkees yes I agree there is "tons" of people who like sequels...which is part of the problem, people keep buying into them so thats all we get. Sequels are on rare occasions done well(Aliens) but more often then not they are lazy filmmaking to make a buck. Power to you for liking them but I would rather have something original.
#63
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Halloween Collection
You're relatively new here, so welcome, and you're already contributing with an intelligent comment! I agree with you 100%. The HALLOWEEN sequels with Michael Myers are dreadful - and I mean all of them, except #2 which is decent. I saw all the HALLOWEEN films as they were released and was sick of Michael Myers from #4 on. As far as the merits (or non-merits) of HALLOWEEN 3 goes, I didn't much like the film when it first came out, but it had nothing to do with the absence of Michael Myers. I just thought the film was stupid (which it is, but at least in a fun way in the right mindset). At that point, I really appreciated the idea of their plan to do an entirely different story and screenplay each year for the HALLOWEEN franchise instead of the usual crappy sequels. Unfortunately, that never happened as #3 wasn't well received and eventually Michael Myers was resurrected for the never-ending terrible and repetitive sequels.
Over the years, I appreciate HALLOWEEN 3 more and more. It's still not a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, but it is a thing of its time and does offer some original fun that #4 and on don't. People may still have hated it if it wasn't under the HALLOWEEN banner, but how anyone can defend #5, 6, or 8 and trash #3 for trying something new is beyond me.
Over the years, I appreciate HALLOWEEN 3 more and more. It's still not a good movie by any stretch of the imagination, but it is a thing of its time and does offer some original fun that #4 and on don't. People may still have hated it if it wasn't under the HALLOWEEN banner, but how anyone can defend #5, 6, or 8 and trash #3 for trying something new is beyond me.
I also watched the TV edit of the first Halloween movie and liked it. On the other hand, I bought the box set and watched the first one, the regular version, with my wife and didn't like it nearly as much as the TV edit. I was really disappointed.
Besides the first and third movie, everything else is just a blur. I remember one of the newer ones had the girl in the clown costume at the end and I also remember their being rappers in at least one of them.
I grew up with Freddy and Jason, so I always liked them. Being more into monster movies, a guy in a mask wasn't what I was looking for.
#65
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Halloween Collection
Oh and The Monkees yes I agree there is "tons" of people who like sequels...which is part of the problem, people keep buying into them so thats all we get. Sequels are on rare occasions done well(Aliens) but more often then not they are lazy filmmaking to make a buck. Power to you for liking them but I would rather have something original.
#66
Cool New Member
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 38
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Halloween Collection
Oh, no. The cat's out of the bag. 
As a big fan of just the first two Haloween films, I'm sort of embarrassed to say that I don't own this. However, I heard that too much of it deals with the awful sequels.
Is this the case? I've been thinking about grabbing it, but I noticed that ebay lists it as having full screen and widescreen formats? Is that true? I thought it was a standard release?
Also, it had a slipcover, right? And the comic is inside the packaging...like a mini-comic? I don't wanna get hosed.
I couldn't have said it better.
I can appreciate III for what it was, but 4 and up are just terrible. I went after the Producer's Cut of 6 just to see the differences.

Is this the case? I've been thinking about grabbing it, but I noticed that ebay lists it as having full screen and widescreen formats? Is that true? I thought it was a standard release?

Also, it had a slipcover, right? And the comic is inside the packaging...like a mini-comic? I don't wanna get hosed.
And that would be a good thing...Halloween with Michael Myers is a waste of time after the second one. Just another slasher flick after that(just my opinion but true..lol). Halloween III would be considered a cult classic(to many of us still is) if it weren't for the fact it got stuck in that franchise. Had it been just called Season of the Witch it wouldn't be getting any crap. Heaven forbid we ever have an original story in horror better to have 20 sequels...ugh! 301 more days til halloween, halloween, halloween. 301 more days til Halloween, Silver Shamrock!!!
I can appreciate III for what it was, but 4 and up are just terrible. I went after the Producer's Cut of 6 just to see the differences.
Last edited by Desolate; 01-04-10 at 12:57 AM.
#67
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Jun 2007
Posts: 2,576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Western Kentucky
Re: Halloween Collection
As a big fan of just the first two Haloween films, I'm sort of embarrassed to say that I don't own this. However, I heard that too much of it deals with the awful sequels.
Is this the case? I've been thinking about grabbing it, but I noticed that ebay lists it as having full screen and widescreen formats? Is that true? I thought it was a standard release?
Also, it had a slipcover, right? And the comic is inside the packaging...like a mini-comic? I don't wanna get hosed.
Is this the case? I've been thinking about grabbing it, but I noticed that ebay lists it as having full screen and widescreen formats? Is that true? I thought it was a standard release?

Also, it had a slipcover, right? And the comic is inside the packaging...like a mini-comic? I don't wanna get hosed.
The documentary is full frame. It was released with a slipcover, and the mini-comic is inside the case.
Anyway, seeing as how others have already, I'll go ahead and list which movies I own in the series...
Halloween (1978): 2-Disc Limited Edition (Anchor Bay)
Halloween (1978): 2-Disc 25th Anniversary Divimax Edition (Anchor Bay)
Halloween (1978) (Blu-Ray) (Anchor Bay)
Halloween II (Universal)
Halloween 4: The Return Of Michael Myers: Divimax Edition (Anchor Bay)
Halloween: 25 Years Of Terror: 2-Disc Special Edition (Anchor Bay)
Halloween (2007): 2-Disc Unrated Collector's Edition (Blu-Ray) (Dimension)
#68
Suspended
Re: Halloween Collection
Looks like Halloween 6, H20 and Ressurrection are coming out in Canada on Blu-ray from Alliance next week as well!
#69
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Halloween Collection
#70
Re: Halloween Collection
My Halloween collection is complete.
Halloween: 30th Anniversary Commemorative Set
- Halloween (1978) - Limited Edition (Discs 1 and 2)
- Halloween (1978) [Blu-Ray]
- Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988) - Divimax Special Edition
- Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989) - Divimax Special Edition
- Halloween (1978) - 25th Anniversary Edition Disc 2 (replaced Disc 1 of 25 Years of Terror and gave altered 25th Anniversary Edition to a friend who didn't mind).
Halloween II (1981)/Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982) - Double Feature
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995)
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers [Producer's Cut] (1995) (user on the Bloody-Disgusting boards was nice enough to burn a copy and mail it to me for free)
Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later (1998) - Collector's Series
Halloween: Resurrection (2002)
Halloween (2007) - Two-Disc Special Edition
Halloween [Unrated Director's Cut] (2007)
- Best Buy Exclusive Lenticular Slipcover
- Hot Topic Exclusive Rob Zombie Autographed Cover Insert
- Circuit City Exclusive Bonus Disc
Halloween [Unrated Director's Cut] (2007) - 2-Disc Collector's Edition [Blu-Ray]
Halloween: 25 Years of Terror (2006)
Halloween: 30th Anniversary Commemorative Set
- Halloween (1978) - Limited Edition (Discs 1 and 2)
- Halloween (1978) [Blu-Ray]
- Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988) - Divimax Special Edition
- Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989) - Divimax Special Edition
- Halloween (1978) - 25th Anniversary Edition Disc 2 (replaced Disc 1 of 25 Years of Terror and gave altered 25th Anniversary Edition to a friend who didn't mind).
Halloween II (1981)/Halloween III: Season of the Witch (1982) - Double Feature
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995)
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers [Producer's Cut] (1995) (user on the Bloody-Disgusting boards was nice enough to burn a copy and mail it to me for free)
Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later (1998) - Collector's Series
Halloween: Resurrection (2002)
Halloween (2007) - Two-Disc Special Edition
Halloween [Unrated Director's Cut] (2007)
- Best Buy Exclusive Lenticular Slipcover
- Hot Topic Exclusive Rob Zombie Autographed Cover Insert
- Circuit City Exclusive Bonus Disc
Halloween [Unrated Director's Cut] (2007) - 2-Disc Collector's Edition [Blu-Ray]
Halloween: 25 Years of Terror (2006)
#72
DVD Talk Gold Edition
#73
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Re: Halloween Collection
Here's my collection
Halloween: 2 Disc 25th Anniversary Edition DVD
Halloween: Extended Edition DVD
Halloween: The Criterion Collection Laserdisc
Halloween Blu-Ray
Halloween: 2 Tape Limited Edition VHS
Halloween II (Universal Release) DVD
Halloween II: The "Ultimate" Cut (Basically the TV version & the theatrical version edited together) DVD-R
Halloween III: Season of the Witch (Universal Release) DVD
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers -Divimax Special Edition- DVD
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers -Divimax Special Edition- DVD
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (Official Release) DVD
Halloween 6: The Producer's Cut DVD-R
Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later -Collector's Series- DVD
Halloween: Resurrection DVD
Halloween (2007) -Unrated Director's Cut- Blu-Ray
Halloween: 25 Years of Terror DVD
Halloween: 2 Disc 25th Anniversary Edition DVD
Halloween: Extended Edition DVD
Halloween: The Criterion Collection Laserdisc
Halloween Blu-Ray
Halloween: 2 Tape Limited Edition VHS
Halloween II (Universal Release) DVD
Halloween II: The "Ultimate" Cut (Basically the TV version & the theatrical version edited together) DVD-R
Halloween III: Season of the Witch (Universal Release) DVD
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers -Divimax Special Edition- DVD
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers -Divimax Special Edition- DVD
Halloween: The Curse of Michael Myers (Official Release) DVD
Halloween 6: The Producer's Cut DVD-R
Halloween H20: Twenty Years Later -Collector's Series- DVD
Halloween: Resurrection DVD
Halloween (2007) -Unrated Director's Cut- Blu-Ray
Halloween: 25 Years of Terror DVD
#74
Senior Member
Re: Halloween Collection
Halloween (1978) Limited Edition 2-Disc from 1999
Halloween (1978) Divimax 25th Anniversary 2-Disc from 2003
Halloween (1978) Blu-ray Disc released 2007
Halloween II (1981) Universal release from 2001
Halloween II (1981) The "Ultimate" Cut DVD-R (theatrical/TV fusion)
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988) Divimax released 2006
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989) Divimax released 2006
Halloween 6: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995) Dimension non-anamorphic release from 2000
Halloween 6: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995) Producer's Cut 5-Disc DVD-R set 16x9/anamorphic (Producer's cut, Director's cut, Rough cut, Television cut, extras disc)
Halloween 7: Twenty Years Later (H20) (1998) Dimension non-anamorphic release from 1999
Halloween 8: Resurrection (2002) Dimension release from 2002
Halloween (2007) Theatrical Cut 2-Disc 2007
Halloween (2007) Unrated Director's Cut 2-Disc 2007
Halloween (2007) workprint DVD-R
Halloween (2007) Unrated Collector's Edition (Director's cut plus 4.5 hour documentary) 3-Disc 2008
Halloween (2007) Blu-ray Disc Unrated Collector's Edition (Director's cut plus 4.5 hour documentary) 2-Disc 2008
Halloween: 25 Years of Terror 2-Disc from 2006
Halloween (1978) Divimax 25th Anniversary 2-Disc from 2003
Halloween (1978) Blu-ray Disc released 2007
Halloween II (1981) Universal release from 2001
Halloween II (1981) The "Ultimate" Cut DVD-R (theatrical/TV fusion)
Halloween 4: The Return of Michael Myers (1988) Divimax released 2006
Halloween 5: The Revenge of Michael Myers (1989) Divimax released 2006
Halloween 6: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995) Dimension non-anamorphic release from 2000
Halloween 6: The Curse of Michael Myers (1995) Producer's Cut 5-Disc DVD-R set 16x9/anamorphic (Producer's cut, Director's cut, Rough cut, Television cut, extras disc)
Halloween 7: Twenty Years Later (H20) (1998) Dimension non-anamorphic release from 1999
Halloween 8: Resurrection (2002) Dimension release from 2002
Halloween (2007) Theatrical Cut 2-Disc 2007
Halloween (2007) Unrated Director's Cut 2-Disc 2007
Halloween (2007) workprint DVD-R
Halloween (2007) Unrated Collector's Edition (Director's cut plus 4.5 hour documentary) 3-Disc 2008
Halloween (2007) Blu-ray Disc Unrated Collector's Edition (Director's cut plus 4.5 hour documentary) 2-Disc 2008
Halloween: 25 Years of Terror 2-Disc from 2006
#75
Re: Halloween Collection
It's all the movies and all the accompanying bonus features, AFAIK. I don't have things like, say, the Halloween 4 tin, but I wouldn't be getting any content out of it, just the packaging. The only thing I'd be missing is the Blockbuster Exclusive DVD of Halloween. And no, to the poster who asked, I will be picking up Halloween II at some point, because I was one of the few who thought it was good.




