I don't care how late in the year it came out, The Dark Knight is in the top 10.

Juno

I only have 2 in the top 10 and 6 overall... with another 3-4 I'm thinking about picking up.

Here are the titles I DON'T own...

1. Ratatouille
2. Hairspray
3. Sex and the City: The Movie
4. The Game Plan
5. 101 Dalmations: Platinum Edition
6. Snow Buddies
7. Tinkerbell
8. The Little Mermaid: Ariel's Beginning

A random Powerpuffs DVD probably outsells most Criterion releases.

http://www.billboard.com/bbcom/yeare...we-chart.shtml

"The 2008 chart year began with last year's Dec. 1 issue and ended with the Nov. 29, 2008, issue, making it one of the rare years when the chart calendar totals 53 weeks." Not sure why so many Dark Knight fans are questioning the validity of this data because that title isn't on it. Take it up with Warner Bros., who didn't release the DVD until 9 December.

For those not in the know, Billboard's dates are not accurate. For instance, the current chart is dated 17 January 2009, and The Dark Knight is listed as having already charted for three weeks. That would put its debut week as 27 December 2008. Do the math from there. Even if the DVD had been released in mid-November, it's very unlikely it would have topped the list.

Since this chart information has sparked some curiosity, though, is anyone in favor of a thread throughout 2009 listing the weekly information?

But that's the way BILLBOARD has kept the charts from Jan. to Oct.
I think the only reason is so they can have that YEAR END ISSUE in December.
Just like we saw AFI's list of BEST MOVIES OF THE CENTURY come out before the century was over. They just can't wait and want to capitalize on it when they can.

Other than No Country for Old Men, I haven't even seen any of them, though I'll rent 3:10 to Yuma at some point.

I've seen only No Country for Old Men and Juno. Juno / Knocked Up was part of a phenomenon I watched to experience first hand. Those films, along with the media hype about a "pregnancy pact" at Gloucester High and Bristol Palin's pregnancy will, I think, be one of the defining elements of the popular American zeitgeist for '07-'08, when pop historians look back in a few years.

I don't even know where to begin in response to this post...

I know!

Anyways, I own... 21-- 20 on blu.

i own 25 of them, all on blu-ray and have watched 18 of them.

only seen 11 of em, own 5.

I own 18 now, sold off a few of them.

Wow, I own 32 of them!

I like movies, some of them porn, but not all.

Saw 21 of them, own 9. There's probably 6-10 more that I'll probably pick up when they get a little cheaper for used copies.

I own 8, I've seen 7 (the only exception being Ocean's 13).

I've seen 17 of them total.

= J

Only have No Country for Old Men

Some of those came as a real surprise to me.

I have seen 16 on that list and own only 3.

That's no reason to brag.