Disney To Halt DVD Sequels
#1
DVD Talk Legend
Thread Starter
Disney To Halt DVD Sequels
http://www.imdb.com/news/sb/2007-06-21/
The Walt Disney Co. will no longer produce direct-to-video sequels of its animated features, according to Disney watcher Jim Hill. Hill, who has had a hit-and-miss record in reporting on inside decisions at the company, said that Sharon Morrill, president of DisneyToon Studios, has been forced to step down as part of the decision to shut down the group that produces the DVD sequels. Prior to Disney's acquisition of Pixar, Pixar executives Steve Jobs and John Lasseter had publicly complained about the quality of the sequels, maintaining that they undercut the value of the original features. Disney executives had responded that the sequels had proved to be enormously successful for the studio. According to Hill, Lasseter made the decision to halt further production of the DVD sequels and fire Morrill after viewing a "work-in-progress version" of The Tinkerbell Movie, which Hill described as "an awful mess." Hill said that Lasseter complained to Disney chief Robert Iger that the movie was "virtually unwatchable." As a direct result of that meeting, Hill wrote, "some $30 million worth of animation had to be scrapped."
The Walt Disney Co. will no longer produce direct-to-video sequels of its animated features, according to Disney watcher Jim Hill. Hill, who has had a hit-and-miss record in reporting on inside decisions at the company, said that Sharon Morrill, president of DisneyToon Studios, has been forced to step down as part of the decision to shut down the group that produces the DVD sequels. Prior to Disney's acquisition of Pixar, Pixar executives Steve Jobs and John Lasseter had publicly complained about the quality of the sequels, maintaining that they undercut the value of the original features. Disney executives had responded that the sequels had proved to be enormously successful for the studio. According to Hill, Lasseter made the decision to halt further production of the DVD sequels and fire Morrill after viewing a "work-in-progress version" of The Tinkerbell Movie, which Hill described as "an awful mess." Hill said that Lasseter complained to Disney chief Robert Iger that the movie was "virtually unwatchable." As a direct result of that meeting, Hill wrote, "some $30 million worth of animation had to be scrapped."
#3
What's most disappointing is that they are giving them up because of inside pressure, NOT because the sales were bad. If the inside pressure didn't exist, they would crank these things out forever until the end of time. It's like printing money for them.
#4
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: TN
Posts: 1,326
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Disappointing news about the Tinkerbell movie as well. While I agree the sequels are mostly crap, I have daughter looking forward to this one, and I had hoped they would make a decent stand alone film of it.
#5
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Im really glad someone shows that they dont care to have just money.
If they made sequels that were really good, it wouldnt need to be DTV. They could make tons more in theaters and such wih merchandising and stuff.
Now I wont have to sit through another Mulan 2....god was that awful..
Inside pressure meaning Steve Jobs and John Lasseter firing people?
Im glad that they are putting Disney on track...
If they made sequels that were really good, it wouldnt need to be DTV. They could make tons more in theaters and such wih merchandising and stuff.
Now I wont have to sit through another Mulan 2....god was that awful..
Originally Posted by calhoun07
What's most disappointing is that they are giving them up because of inside pressure, NOT because the sales were bad. If the inside pressure didn't exist, they would crank these things out forever until the end of time. It's like printing money for them.
Im glad that they are putting Disney on track...
Last edited by TheJoker; 06-21-07 at 07:18 PM.
#7
DVD Talk Hero
John Lasseter continues to be my hero...
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Dec 2006
Posts: 641
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by The Third Jake
You didn't have to sit through it before, either.
I watched the first five minutes and then skipped chapters.....its just went downhill everytime I skipped a chapter....
#11
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 2,001
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
great news but aww man i feel sorry for that guy who was fired, why can't they fire ppl like that in FOX? lol...anyways, does anyone know how many direct to dvd sequels were there?
#12
Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 71
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From a business standpoint I wouldn't think this makes sense- I thought those direct to dvd sequels made a fortune for Disney. But maybe they don't generate that much or maybe they do "cheapen" the classics. I don't know. But I'll still be very surprised if this is true.
Last edited by PPP; 06-21-07 at 11:19 PM.
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2007
Posts: 716
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
its really sad that they do this just for money, i mean its understandable to a certain extent cause they have the power and are a company but some of these guys are so rich its mind boggling its un nessecerry to milk these timeless classics.
the most original things they've had in years have only been with pixar, and even then is probobly not there scripts to begin with. the creative juices are still there, we've seen pirates do nice numbers for disney, everyone is just so F'ing lazy now that were seeing cinderella 3. and it honestly wouldnt surprize me if they F'ed with one of my fav's, the great mouse detective.
the most original things they've had in years have only been with pixar, and even then is probobly not there scripts to begin with. the creative juices are still there, we've seen pirates do nice numbers for disney, everyone is just so F'ing lazy now that were seeing cinderella 3. and it honestly wouldnt surprize me if they F'ed with one of my fav's, the great mouse detective.
#14
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I'm glad *SOMEBODY* at Disney realized that "Cinderella" didn't really need two different sequels.
But now my hopes for "Song of the South 2" are crushed.
But now my hopes for "Song of the South 2" are crushed.

#15
Originally Posted by PPP
From a business standpoint I wouldn't think this makes sense- I thought those direct to dvd sequels made a fortune for Disney. But maybe they don't generate that much or maybe they do "cheapen" the classics. I don't know. But I'll still be very surprised if this is true.
Sometimes running a business doesn't mean you focus on the fast buck you can make now but having a long term goal. It's time Disney gets back to being a name for quality and not a joke brand name for substandard product. We've got Dreamworks on that job already. It's a bummer it took them this long to get a clue...we've got what? 10 years of substandard sequels, or perhaps more? Well, if anybody can get the company back on track to creating quality movies it's Lassiter.
#16
DVD Talk God
Damn! I was so hoping for Steamboat Willie 2.......That fricking sucks!!
#17
Member
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Camp Taji,Iraq/Brandon, Fl
Posts: 217
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
To para-phrase Bill Hicks
It's Dead, it's dead, oh what a great day, after years of me and my movie fan friends shooting darts at that huge elephant like we were pygmies, it's finally dead!!!
Bought so much crap for the sake of collecting, and oh what crap it was.
It's Dead, it's dead, oh what a great day, after years of me and my movie fan friends shooting darts at that huge elephant like we were pygmies, it's finally dead!!!
Bought so much crap for the sake of collecting, and oh what crap it was.
#18
DVD Talk Hero
They wouldn't have had this problem if you parents wouldn't buy every piece of shit movie for your whining rugrats just because it said Disney on the cover.

#19
Member
Join Date: Sep 2004
Location: Camp Taji,Iraq/Brandon, Fl
Posts: 217
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yeah, agreed, we bought a few at first, not for our whining rugrats, but for my wife who collects Disney. After the first few, just kept hoping it would get better, but after 3 or four, just totally gave up on them putting any effort into this crap at all.
#22
DVD Talk Godfather
I'm going to have to quote myself from the New Goofy Short thread.
Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
John mother-fuckin' Lasseter rocks. Damn this is awesome.
#24
DVD Talk Godfather
Originally Posted by Subgeniusguy
Disappointing news about the Tinkerbell movie as well. While I agree the sequels are mostly crap, I have daughter looking forward to this one, and I had hoped they would make a decent stand alone film of it.
*edit* Quick google search reveals that this news hit around Dec. 22. Here's one article :
Disney has decided to delay next year's release of a "Tinker Bell" DVD movie that the company was counting on to drive sales of a key new line of merchandise aimed at young girls, it was reported Thursday.
The entertainment giant had been hoping Disney Fairies, introduced last year, can replicate some of the success it has enjoyed with its lucrative Disney Princesses line of dolls, clothes, videos and other merchandise, according to the Los Angeles Times.
But executives from Pixar Animation Studios, who now run Disney 's animated movies business, decided the plot of "Tinker Bell" needed some tinkering, the newspaper said.
As a result, the film, originally scheduled to release only on DVD market next fall, is being pushed back until at least 2008.
Pixar executives were tapped to turn around Disney's feature animation unit, which has struggled in recent years to turn out hits, as part of Disney's 7.4-billion-dollar acquisition of the studio early this year. Pixar's work includes such blockbusters as "Cars," "Finding Nemo," "The Incredibles" and "Toy Story."
One of the first things the Pixar executives did was to review existing Disney projects, taking an especially close look at the strength of their story lines, the newspaper report said.
"Tinker Bell" is expected to introduce new characters to pave the way for new movies and other products with the title character 's friends. Actress Brittany Murphy is scheduled to voice Tinker Bell, who doesn't speak in Disney's 1953 animated film "Peter Pan. "
It was reported that Steve Jobs, chairman of Apple Computer Inc. who swapped his stake in Pixar to become Disney's largest shareholder through the acquisition, has been a chief critic of Disney's direct-to-video strategy.
Jobs reportedly argued that Disney should make the movies better and release them to theaters, where continuing publicity would help lift DVD sales.
The entertainment giant had been hoping Disney Fairies, introduced last year, can replicate some of the success it has enjoyed with its lucrative Disney Princesses line of dolls, clothes, videos and other merchandise, according to the Los Angeles Times.
But executives from Pixar Animation Studios, who now run Disney 's animated movies business, decided the plot of "Tinker Bell" needed some tinkering, the newspaper said.
As a result, the film, originally scheduled to release only on DVD market next fall, is being pushed back until at least 2008.
Pixar executives were tapped to turn around Disney's feature animation unit, which has struggled in recent years to turn out hits, as part of Disney's 7.4-billion-dollar acquisition of the studio early this year. Pixar's work includes such blockbusters as "Cars," "Finding Nemo," "The Incredibles" and "Toy Story."
One of the first things the Pixar executives did was to review existing Disney projects, taking an especially close look at the strength of their story lines, the newspaper report said.
"Tinker Bell" is expected to introduce new characters to pave the way for new movies and other products with the title character 's friends. Actress Brittany Murphy is scheduled to voice Tinker Bell, who doesn't speak in Disney's 1953 animated film "Peter Pan. "
It was reported that Steve Jobs, chairman of Apple Computer Inc. who swapped his stake in Pixar to become Disney's largest shareholder through the acquisition, has been a chief critic of Disney's direct-to-video strategy.
Jobs reportedly argued that Disney should make the movies better and release them to theaters, where continuing publicity would help lift DVD sales.
Last edited by Michael Corvin; 06-22-07 at 09:53 AM.
#25
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Jobs reportedly argued that Disney should make the movies better and release them to theaters, where continuing publicity would help lift DVD sales.