Grindhouse, both movies not on same dvd?
#27
Challenge Guru & Comic Nerd
I'd prefer an initial release that is quick to the market and has it presented as it was in the theaters. Probably would have to be two discs, so might as well throw a few special features on there like the rumored other trailers and missing reels.
Then separate 2 disc editions of each movie, with loads of special features and multiple commentaries.
Then separate 2 disc editions of each movie, with loads of special features and multiple commentaries.
#28
New Member
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 8
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I hope they make Machette into one of the next movies.
#29
The general consensus, as pasted together from Tarantino/Rodriguez interviews is:
Sometime later, there will be a first DVD release of the two movies -- not packaged as one, excluding retailer specials -- with some features. Tarantino's gets the trailers. The films will be presented as they were theatrically.
Then later there will be a set of SEs -- again not together -- with the films "digitally remastered" (no more pops, scratches and jumps and...at least ONE of the missing reels restored...). Hopefully this will be timed to co-incide with Machete on DVD (perhaps, if we're really lucky, also those Kill Bill SEs finally and perhaps FDTD anamorphic but that's just my own speculation).
Sometime later, there will be a first DVD release of the two movies -- not packaged as one, excluding retailer specials -- with some features. Tarantino's gets the trailers. The films will be presented as they were theatrically.
Then later there will be a set of SEs -- again not together -- with the films "digitally remastered" (no more pops, scratches and jumps and...at least ONE of the missing reels restored...). Hopefully this will be timed to co-incide with Machete on DVD (perhaps, if we're really lucky, also those Kill Bill SEs finally and perhaps FDTD anamorphic but that's just my own speculation).
#30
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by scott1598
exactly! the only way i would want this DVD is if it were the theatrical release on 1 dvd or at least 2 for a good DTS, but keeping the exact structure of the theatrical. on dvd anyone can do what they want and watch how they want, whether it be just one movie or whatever, that is the greatness of the DVD medium! but to split it up as two separate entities would be just wrong.
#31
Member
Joined: May 2005
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Drexl
Yeah, I look at Grindhouse as more of an anthology film like Creepshow or Twilight Zone: The Movie rather than consisting of separate films. If they're going to do an initial release and then another one later, I hope that at least the initial release will be the whole thing on one disc.
#32
First, I understand their thinking that "Grindhouse" is a recreation of a B-movie double bill in the theater and like any double feature, the films would get separate home video releases. Still, I don't agree with the idea of releasing the films "as is" (scratched up) and then re-released again as pristine special editions. To me, the scratches and such only work under the guise of the double bill they call "Grindhouse." To release them in such a state separately makes no sense other than a money grab. If you're going to release them individually, then make them finished films.
#33
Well, due to box-office failure, will people know what the hell Planet Terror and Death Proof are when they're released seperately? Looks like the company's just gonna have to play it safe and release the theatrical cut first and then go for your mega-double dip.
I like this idea. Extended editions for the 2nd and 3rd disc. Wonder what the store exclusives will be...If there are any.
Originally Posted by Cane Dewey
It should be a three-disc SE, with the both films (plus fake trailers) on the first disc, Planet Terror special features on the second disc and Death Proof special features on the third disc.
#34
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Originally Posted by Drexl
Yeah, I look at Grindhouse as more of an anthology film like Creepshow or Twilight Zone: The Movie rather than consisting of separate films. If they're going to do an initial release and then another one later, I hope that at least the initial release will be the whole thing on one disc.
The way it's all set up in theaters, makes it not 'two movies', but one big gigantic film experiance. Which is what it's supposed to be. The fact that the two directors made 90 minute films instead of the originally planned 70 minute films. Is not the studios fault, the directors for getting carried away. Since it was planned as one big double feature tribute and not just 'separate' films.
We start with Dimension logo, a fake trailer, then the GRINDEHOUSE credit sequence which fades into Planet Terror,then more fake trailers,commercials for food/restaurants,then Death Proof,then one big credit sequence that credits both films and trailers.
I'd prefer it to stay that way,instead of being split up. At the very least, the first release should be "GRINDEHOUSE" and not the films separately. And I love the 'missing reels' and grimy scratchy burning spliced up print style. And would hate to see the film(s) all cleaned up and pretty looking. That would not be any fun at all.
Last edited by Julie Walker; 04-08-07 at 08:15 PM.
#35
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 5,320
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by The Eliminator
I hope so, Death Proof rocked, Planet Terror stank.

It seems the majority of viewers loved one and hated the other, so it's a good idea to put them on separate DVD's.
#37
Although ideally I'd like to have the complete Grindhouse feature, I'm fine with just having to buy Planet Terror. Death Proof was too long and boring to begin with that I can't imagine enjoying Tarantino's extended Cannes cut.
#39
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Jun 2006
Posts: 1,664
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Cane Dewey
It should be a three-disc SE, with the both films (plus fake trailers) on the first disc, Planet Terror special features on the second disc and Death Proof special features on the third disc.
#41
DVD Talk Special Edition
Originally Posted by GreenVulture
That's not a bad idea, but I would prefer a single-disc release of Grindhouse as a whole, followed by a 3-disc set with each (extended) film on its own disc, along with the fake trailers, marketing materials, documentaries and other supplements on the third disc.
#45
DVD Talk Legend
I'll take a 2-disk double feature set.
Disk 1: Machete trailer and Planet Terror plus PT bonus features.
Disk 2: rest of the trailers and Death Proof plus DP bonus features.
The movies are short enough to where there should be enough room for bonus material on each disk.
Disk 1: Machete trailer and Planet Terror plus PT bonus features.
Disk 2: rest of the trailers and Death Proof plus DP bonus features.
The movies are short enough to where there should be enough room for bonus material on each disk.
#46
Senior Member
Joined: Nov 2005
Posts: 318
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Atlanta, GA
Originally Posted by Drexl
Yeah, I look at Grindhouse as more of an anthology film like Creepshow or Twilight Zone: The Movie rather than consisting of separate films. If they're going to do an initial release and then another one later, I hope that at least the initial release will be the whole thing on one disc.
I wonder if QT/RR will add "From Dusk till Dawn", as part of the Grindhouse anthology?
that one also overdue for a new DVD release...
Last edited by tsetse27; 04-09-07 at 09:14 AM.
#47
New Member
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Seantn
Besides, Death Proof drops the whole notion for the final hour and it looks like a brand new film (which it is!)
#48
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by Snowmaker
I'll take a 2-disk double feature set.
Disk 1: Machete trailer and Planet Terror plus PT bonus features.
Disk 2: rest of the trailers and Death Proof plus DP bonus features.
The movies are short enough to where there should be enough room for bonus material on each disk.
Disk 1: Machete trailer and Planet Terror plus PT bonus features.
Disk 2: rest of the trailers and Death Proof plus DP bonus features.
The movies are short enough to where there should be enough room for bonus material on each disk.
#49
Member
Joined: Apr 2000
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Scotch Plains, NJ
This was in today's Variety. It confirms 2 separate releases.
"Harvey Weinstein defended the decision to keep the two together Sunday, telling Daily Variety it was artistically the right move and that the movie will be a moneymaker thanks to its foreign sales as separate films and an upcoming DVD rollout, which also will release the films as two separate titles."
"Harvey Weinstein defended the decision to keep the two together Sunday, telling Daily Variety it was artistically the right move and that the movie will be a moneymaker thanks to its foreign sales as separate films and an upcoming DVD rollout, which also will release the films as two separate titles."



