Do you own the Original AND the Re-Make?
#26
DVD Talk Special Edition
Night of the Living Dead
Dawn of the Dead
Assault on Precinct 13
Thunderball/Never Say Never Again
Last Man on Earth/The Omega Man
The Thing From Another World/The Thing
Amityville
Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Dawn of the Dead
Assault on Precinct 13
Thunderball/Never Say Never Again
Last Man on Earth/The Omega Man
The Thing From Another World/The Thing
Amityville
Texas Chainsaw Massacre
#27
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
The only ones I own so far are...
Dawn of the Dead
The Blob
Invasion of the Body Snatchers
The Grudge / Ju On
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
The Thing
...and while it's not yet released. I definitely will be picking up the remake of The Hills Have Eyes since it kicked ass and I own the original(though am not impressed with that film).
And someday I'll be buying the original King Kong and I'm debating whether to pick up the two remakes or not. It all depends on my mood and finances at the time.
Dawn of the Dead
The Blob
Invasion of the Body Snatchers
The Grudge / Ju On
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
The Thing
...and while it's not yet released. I definitely will be picking up the remake of The Hills Have Eyes since it kicked ass and I own the original(though am not impressed with that film).
And someday I'll be buying the original King Kong and I'm debating whether to pick up the two remakes or not. It all depends on my mood and finances at the time.
#30
Senior Member
Joined: Aug 1999
Posts: 293
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Everybody that purchased last year's 4-DVD Ben-Hur set has both the original and the re-make of that movie (since both were included in the box)!
The only other original and re-make that I own is Planet of the Apes.
With both Ben-Hur and Planet of the Apes, I prefer the Charlton Heston version of the movie.
The only other original and re-make that I own is Planet of the Apes.
With both Ben-Hur and Planet of the Apes, I prefer the Charlton Heston version of the movie.
#31
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
As of next week:
King Kong
Planet Of The Apes
The Longest Yard
Willy Wonka/Charlie & The Chocolate Factory
Scarface
The Dukes Of Hazzard
The Bad News Bears
The Stepford Wives
The Italian Job
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Batman (1966 Movie and 1989 Movie)
The Naked Jungle / The MacGyver episode that remade The Naked Jungle and used footage from the movie
I'll add The Producers to the list when the new version comes out.
King Kong
Planet Of The Apes
The Longest Yard
Willy Wonka/Charlie & The Chocolate Factory
Scarface
The Dukes Of Hazzard
The Bad News Bears
The Stepford Wives
The Italian Job
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Batman (1966 Movie and 1989 Movie)
The Naked Jungle / The MacGyver episode that remade The Naked Jungle and used footage from the movie

I'll add The Producers to the list when the new version comes out.
#32
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 3,662
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: H-Town, TX
Ben-Hur(a given since they're on the same DVD)
Wings of Desire/City of Angels
Dawn of the Dead(1978/2004)
The Dead Zone(movie/TV show)
Insomnia(1997/2002)
The Italian Job(1969/2003)
Thunderball/Never Say Never Again
Manhunter/Red Dragon
The Manchurian Candidate(1963/2004)
Meet Joe Black/Death Takes a Holiday(again, same DVD)
The Office(BBC/NBC)
Open Your Eyes/Vanilla Sky
King Kong(1933/1976)
The Truth About Charlie/Charade(once again, same DVD)
Solaris(1972/2002)
Wings of Desire/City of Angels
Dawn of the Dead(1978/2004)
The Dead Zone(movie/TV show)
Insomnia(1997/2002)
The Italian Job(1969/2003)
Thunderball/Never Say Never Again
Manhunter/Red Dragon
The Manchurian Candidate(1963/2004)
Meet Joe Black/Death Takes a Holiday(again, same DVD)
The Office(BBC/NBC)
Open Your Eyes/Vanilla Sky
King Kong(1933/1976)
The Truth About Charlie/Charade(once again, same DVD)
Solaris(1972/2002)
#36
I own many of the previous combinations mentioned, but there's one film I own 3 different versions of:
THE LONGEST YARD (Aldrich/Reynolds version)/THE MEAN MACHINE (Soccer version with Vinnie Jones)/THE LONGEST YARD (Sandler/Reynolds version)
THE LONGEST YARD (Aldrich/Reynolds version)/THE MEAN MACHINE (Soccer version with Vinnie Jones)/THE LONGEST YARD (Sandler/Reynolds version)
#39
Member
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 141
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Other than some of the ones mentioned, I own these:
A kazillion versions of A Christmas Carol (Alastair Sim, Reginald Owen, Patrick Stewart, George C. Scott, The Muppets, Disney, Bill Murray's Scrooged, Albert Finney's Scrooge)
Front Page (1931 and 1974) / His Girl Friday
Ninotchka / Silk Stockings
Philadelphia Story / High Society
State Fair (1945 and 1962) same DVD
Pygmalion 1939 / My Fair Lady
Oliver Twist 1951 / Oliver
Mutiny on the Bounty / The Bounty
Lady for a Day / Pocketful of Miracles
Hamlet 1948 and 1991
Broadway Bill / Riding High
Postman Always Rings Twice 1946 and 1981
Love Affair 1939 and 1994 / An Affair to Remember
Cape Fear 1962 and 1991
Thomas Crown Affair 1968 and 1999
Phantom of the Opera 1925 and 2005
Imitation of Life (1934 and 1959) same DVD
To answer the original question, I think remakes are worth owning if you liked the original just for comparison, even if the remake sucks. It's fun to see what different directors do with the same basic material and catch the various homages to the original. I'm going to pick up the Born Yesterday remake for just that reason even though it pales (IMHO) against the original.
A kazillion versions of A Christmas Carol (Alastair Sim, Reginald Owen, Patrick Stewart, George C. Scott, The Muppets, Disney, Bill Murray's Scrooged, Albert Finney's Scrooge)
Front Page (1931 and 1974) / His Girl Friday
Ninotchka / Silk Stockings
Philadelphia Story / High Society
State Fair (1945 and 1962) same DVD
Pygmalion 1939 / My Fair Lady
Oliver Twist 1951 / Oliver
Mutiny on the Bounty / The Bounty
Lady for a Day / Pocketful of Miracles
Hamlet 1948 and 1991
Broadway Bill / Riding High
Postman Always Rings Twice 1946 and 1981
Love Affair 1939 and 1994 / An Affair to Remember
Cape Fear 1962 and 1991
Thomas Crown Affair 1968 and 1999
Phantom of the Opera 1925 and 2005
Imitation of Life (1934 and 1959) same DVD
To answer the original question, I think remakes are worth owning if you liked the original just for comparison, even if the remake sucks. It's fun to see what different directors do with the same basic material and catch the various homages to the original. I'm going to pick up the Born Yesterday remake for just that reason even though it pales (IMHO) against the original.
Last edited by arod1171; 03-24-06 at 07:56 AM.
#41
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by eiker_ir
Dawn of the Dead
Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Night of the Living Dead
Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Night of the Living Dead
#42
Senior Member
Joined: Sep 2001
Posts: 576
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Seven Samurai/Magnificent Seven
Dawn of the Dead
Scarface
The Ring/Ringu
Invasion of the Body Snatches
Dracula/Bram Stoker's Dracula
Robin Hood
Wings of Desire/City of Angels
Romeo & Juliet/West Side Story
Yojimbo/Fistful of Dollars
Dawn of the Dead
Scarface
The Ring/Ringu
Invasion of the Body Snatches
Dracula/Bram Stoker's Dracula
Robin Hood
Wings of Desire/City of Angels
Romeo & Juliet/West Side Story
Yojimbo/Fistful of Dollars
#43
Senior Member
Joined: Dec 2005
Posts: 355
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Tampa
Just a few:
Ben-Hur
War of the Worlds
Dracula/Frankenstein/The Mummy (the 30's Universal versions and their Hammer remakes but no subsequent remakes)
I'll be picking up Kong to add to this little list.
Planet of the Apes would've been here too but I gave away the remake.
Ben-Hur
War of the Worlds
Dracula/Frankenstein/The Mummy (the 30's Universal versions and their Hammer remakes but no subsequent remakes)
I'll be picking up Kong to add to this little list.
Planet of the Apes would've been here too but I gave away the remake.
#44
AFAIK, just Solyaris/Solaris.
#46
TOTY Winner 2018 and Inane Thread Master
Joined: Dec 2003
Posts: 54,122
Received 1,721 Likes
on
1,411 Posts
From: "Are any of us really anywhere?"
"Dawn of the Dead"
"Night of the Living Dead"
"War of the Worlds"
"Meet Joe Black" / "Death Takes A Holiday"
"Assault on Precinct 13"
"The Vanishing"
"Seven Samurai" / "The Magnificent Seven"
"King Kong"
"The Virgin Spring" / "The Last House on the Left"
"Night of the Living Dead"
"War of the Worlds"
"Meet Joe Black" / "Death Takes A Holiday"
"Assault on Precinct 13"
"The Vanishing"
"Seven Samurai" / "The Magnificent Seven"
"King Kong"
"The Virgin Spring" / "The Last House on the Left"
#50
Senior Member
Joined: Apr 2002
Posts: 346
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Home of the International Balloon Fiesta
101 Dalmatians
13 Ghosts
Cape Fear
Dawn of the Dead
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
Flight of the Phoenix
The Fly
Gone in 60 Seconds
Hound of the Baskervilles
How the Grinch Stole Christmas
The Killers
The Ladykillers
The Longest Yard
The Mummy
Ocean's 11
Phantom of the Opera
Planet of the Apes
Shaft
Texas Chainsaw Massacre
The Thing
The Three Musketeers
The Time Machine
War of the Worlds
Willy Wonka / Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
13 Ghosts
Cape Fear
Dawn of the Dead
Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde
Flight of the Phoenix
The Fly
Gone in 60 Seconds
Hound of the Baskervilles
How the Grinch Stole Christmas
The Killers
The Ladykillers
The Longest Yard
The Mummy
Ocean's 11
Phantom of the Opera
Planet of the Apes
Shaft
Texas Chainsaw Massacre
The Thing
The Three Musketeers
The Time Machine
War of the Worlds
Willy Wonka / Charlie and the Chocolate Factory
Last edited by cisco1959; 03-26-06 at 01:06 PM.



