If we want to get technical....this should be thrown out also, since they are all individual releases:
Lord of the Rings Trilogy - Extended Editions (Box)

I would like to release the <b>Scarface</b> box back into the pool of available titles and replace it with <b>Armageddon</b>: Criterion Collection as my Round #3 selection. Thanks.

das

I didn't think we were going to do it that way, but if we are my trigun set needs to be thrown out as the dvds were available separately first.

4. Scarface CE (Box)

oops, 1 minute too early

Terminator 2 Ultimate Edition

Once Upon A Time In The West: Special Collector's Edition

4. Treasure of the Sierra Madre

Round 4 pick ... Donnie Darko: Director's Cut

Eraserhead (The davidlynch.com edition, of course)

4. Scarface CE (Box Set edition) ;)

Straw Dogs (CC)

Dick. ;)

das

4. John Carpenter's The Thing - Collector's Edition (Remastered)

Ben Hur - 4 Disc CE

Round #4: Baz Luhrmann's Red Curtain Trilogy

das

4. Arrested Development: Season 1 (TV)

The previously released rule does not matter this time around... but with the Seinfeld set it breaks the "only one TV set" rule since it includes 2 season sets.

Great Escape: Two-Disc SE

4. The American Friend

4. Rear Window

MATT

That does not apply to the case of the LOTR EE's, though. Which he was claiming as individual releases. And my Trigun set was all available individually and before the set. This rule in particular is what I thought we were not using this time around.

4. Sports Night (Complete Series)

Would this count as a box set, since it contains multiple movies? Isn't a silent version of Ben Hur included, too?

I didn't consider it as a box set, but if enough people make a stink, I will switch my pick.

deleted. new pick pending