Ong-Bak: The Thai Warrior --> Aug. 30th!
#51
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally Posted by nezumi
Sorry to report this, but there is nothing wrong with the R1 DVD. The third subtitle track only contains the words "NONG PRADU VILLAGE," which appear at the very beginning of the film. The English subtitle track is most likely a copy of the closed caption script (I don't have a television with closed captioning ability).
There's most definitely a problem with this release's subtitles.
-JP
Last edited by NatrlBornThrllr; 09-03-05 at 07:12 PM.
#52
New Member
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by nezumi
Sorry to report this, but there is nothing wrong with the R1 DVD. The third subtitle track only contains the words "NONG PRADU VILLAGE," which appear at the very beginning of the film. The English subtitle track is most likely a copy of the closed caption script (I don't have a television with closed captioning ability). Can anybody confirm this?
EDIT: Okay, so there's problems with the film's presentation. I only meant that there's nothing defective with the DVD's subtitle tracks.
EDIT: Okay, so there's problems with the film's presentation. I only meant that there's nothing defective with the DVD's subtitle tracks.
Randy
#53
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Well, according to http://www.dvdcompare.net/ the R-0 Australian Version is the best one to own --- unfortunately, it is a PAL version! Anybody know how to make PAL work on an NTSC DVD Player and TV?
There is an R-2 version scheduled for release on September 15th - you can check it out on Amazon.co.uk - it sounds like a better version than the R-1 version.
There is an R-2 version scheduled for release on September 15th - you can check it out on Amazon.co.uk - it sounds like a better version than the R-1 version.
Last edited by danwiz; 09-05-05 at 02:16 AM.
#54
Originally Posted by danwiz
Well, according to http://www.dvdcompare.net/ the R-0 Australian Version is the best one to own --- unfortunately, it is a PAL version! Anybody know how to make PAL work on an NTSC DVD Player and TV?
There is an R-2 version scheduled for release on September 15th - you can check it out on Amazon.co.uk - it sounds like a better version than the R-1 version.
There is an R-2 version scheduled for release on September 15th - you can check it out on Amazon.co.uk - it sounds like a better version than the R-1 version.
#57
New Member
Joined: Sep 2005
Posts: 5
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
OK,
After sending in another complaint about the subtitling issues, the same response was forwarded back to me. Going back to the website revealed a different design and I was able to find a complaint phone number to call. I placed my call and explained the problem and the rep proceeded to read me the verbatim response she e-mailed me. I told her I have complained recently and oddly, she knew about the complaint by me and even knew when I complained and who I was. I couldn't be the only one that complained about this? She explained to me that she forward the e-mail to the productions department where they check on these issues and then they get back to her, and she received no response from them after my first complaint.
I'm urging anyone who wants to get a replacement for this DVD to please call the fox number and help me to get the ball rolling on this to get what we paid for, a decent english subtitle track on the release of Ong Bak. Please call the fox consumer hotline at 1-888-223-2FOX from 8-5 PST and let them know that the disc has a problem. It wouldn't hurt to send them e-mails either at [email protected] because I know people forwarded my comments to her through there. If a lot of people are vocal about this, I'm sure we can get this fixed.
Thanks,
Randy
After sending in another complaint about the subtitling issues, the same response was forwarded back to me. Going back to the website revealed a different design and I was able to find a complaint phone number to call. I placed my call and explained the problem and the rep proceeded to read me the verbatim response she e-mailed me. I told her I have complained recently and oddly, she knew about the complaint by me and even knew when I complained and who I was. I couldn't be the only one that complained about this? She explained to me that she forward the e-mail to the productions department where they check on these issues and then they get back to her, and she received no response from them after my first complaint.
I'm urging anyone who wants to get a replacement for this DVD to please call the fox number and help me to get the ball rolling on this to get what we paid for, a decent english subtitle track on the release of Ong Bak. Please call the fox consumer hotline at 1-888-223-2FOX from 8-5 PST and let them know that the disc has a problem. It wouldn't hurt to send them e-mails either at [email protected] because I know people forwarded my comments to her through there. If a lot of people are vocal about this, I'm sure we can get this fixed.
Thanks,
Randy
#58
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Emailed to Fox as of this morning. This type of stuff is inexcusable.
Good morning,
I am writing to you to inform you of a problem with the "Ong-Bak: The Thai Warrior" DVD. One of the subtitle tracks (the third, which is supposed to be 'Standard English Subtitles') does NOT work at all. I have tried it on three separate DVD players (Panasonic, Denon, Yamaha) and all do not play any English subtitles, just the English Closed-Captioned track and the Spanish subtitles.
Please contact me as soon as possible about this issue, as it is not only with my disc, but many other people's DVDs. It is inexcusable and unwatchable to see the film in English Closed-Captioned. Thank you for your time.
Regards,
Xxxxx Xxxxxx
[email protected]
I am writing to you to inform you of a problem with the "Ong-Bak: The Thai Warrior" DVD. One of the subtitle tracks (the third, which is supposed to be 'Standard English Subtitles') does NOT work at all. I have tried it on three separate DVD players (Panasonic, Denon, Yamaha) and all do not play any English subtitles, just the English Closed-Captioned track and the Spanish subtitles.
Please contact me as soon as possible about this issue, as it is not only with my disc, but many other people's DVDs. It is inexcusable and unwatchable to see the film in English Closed-Captioned. Thank you for your time.
Regards,
Xxxxx Xxxxxx
[email protected]
Last edited by steebo777; 09-19-05 at 08:08 AM.
#59
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
My email to them is posted on page two (post number 48). In it, I specifically state that I've tried using the subtitle button on my remote, as well as the set-up menu...and that other people are having the same problem with their DVD. The response I got: identical to the cookie-cutter responses everybody else has been getting. I then wrote them back expressing zero appreciation for the way they've blown off my legitimate complaint. No response. I'll start my series of phone calls tomorrow.
I lied...I just called them before posting this reply. The lady was actually rather helpful (and answered the call directly on only the second ring...eerie). She mentioned the bit about using the menu, and I explained that I'd already done that, as have the numerous other people on the internet who are complaining about having the same problem with no response from Fox. She said that she'd forward my complaint along, and to call back near the end of the week.
-JP
I lied...I just called them before posting this reply. The lady was actually rather helpful (and answered the call directly on only the second ring...eerie). She mentioned the bit about using the menu, and I explained that I'd already done that, as have the numerous other people on the internet who are complaining about having the same problem with no response from Fox. She said that she'd forward my complaint along, and to call back near the end of the week.
-JP
#61
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I received the same cookie-cutter response as well. I replied back immediately explaining what is going on and that the track is not there.




