|
Please Settle My Debate
ok, so me and my sister were comparing dvd collections tonight...
we both thought our collections were better... I'll tell you our collections, please vote and comment about which is better overall... and add any comments about any of the films if you feel necessary! Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 Kill Bill Vol 2 Pulp Fiction Reservoir Dogs Bowling for Columbine Road Trip Scarface American Pie 1 American Pie 2 American Pie 3 Donnie Darko One Hour Photo Trainspotting Fight Club Shawshank Redemption Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful Big Daddy American Pie 2 Mean Girls The Day After Tomorrow Top Gun How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days Pirates of the Caribbean Bridget Jones Diary Shrek 2 Don't Say A Word About A Boy Jumanji Signs Vertical Limit Deep Blue Sea Beetlejuice ————————— I got 15, she got 17 dvds. I'm 18, she's 15 yrs old. Vote! |
None of the above.
|
kate has 2 movies worth watching and andy has 5. andy wins
|
tell us which ones!
also state your age and gender... I think age and gender do affect preference significantly |
Ill take a little from column A and a little from column B. Im 27 if you must know.
Both have crap in them and some awesome movies. I choose Andy since there are a few more better titles that I like in there but still some real crap films as well. Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 - Good Kill Bill Vol 2- Good Pulp Fiction- Awesome Reservoir Dogs- Awesome Bowling for Columbine- Ok Road Trip- crap Scarface - good American Pie 1 - crap American Pie 2 - crap American Pie 3 - crap Donnie Darko - good One Hour Photo - crap Trainspotting - ok Fight Club - good Shawshank Redemption- Awesome + Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful - crap Big Daddy - crap American Pie 2 - crap Mean Girls - ok The Day After Tomorrow - good Top Gun - good How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days - crap Pirates of the Caribbean - awesome Bridget Jones Diary - crap Shrek 2 - good Don't Say A Word - ok About A Boy - good Jumanji - ok Signs - ok Vertical Limit - ok Deep Blue Sea - crap Beetlejuice - good |
Neither, it's a tie.
Andy has "movie x" because Andy likes it. Kate has "movie y" because Kate likes it. There is no better, it's a matter of personal taste. |
signs is crap :P
JohnnyZhivago ...its a poll... state your personal taste |
Anyone who has Donnie Darko and Fight Club automatically wins. :up:
Rob |
PF, RD and Shawshank are must owns for any collection.
|
this is a horrible thread and you's DVD Talkers should not condone this!!
|
Andy's has more movies i'd actually watch (some of which, I own). But Dr. Zhivago is right, it's all a matter of taste....
|
Andy by far, though I have to give props to Kate for POTC and Beetlejuice.
|
Originally posted by matome Andy by far, though I have to give props to Kate for POTC and Beetlejuice. |
Originally posted by scott1598 this is a horrible thread and you's DVD Talkers should not condone this!! As for your collections andy. I think hers fits a more female view. While I don't like all the movies on her list, hers seem more well rounded. Yours looks to lean to much to the QT side of things. There is more things in life other than Miramax films you know. Who ever wins, we all lose. |
Originally posted by Jackskeleton See, this is why I call you a noob. There is much better ways to thread crap a thread in a subtle way. D for presentation, F for effort and A for spelling your name right. |
Originally posted by scott1598 but, she doesn't have "Passion of the Christ"?? TPOTC = <b>The</b> Passion of The Christ |
I voted for Kate's collection because she is Michael Moore-free.
|
I would have voted for andy's collection, but it had that michael moore movie in it.
|
Any pics of Kate before I vote? :D
just kiddin'! I hold pretty much the same opinion as Rammsteinfan does... not totally but close :) |
trust me, you dont wana see kate ;)
|
Andy's Collection
American Pie 1, 2 & 3, Scarface - :thumbsup::thumbsup: Kill Bill Vol 1 & 2, Pulp Fiction, Reservoir Dogs, Shawshank Redemption, Donnie Darko - :thumbsup: Road Trip, Trainspotting, One Hour Photo - even Bowling for Columbine, Fight Club - :down::down: Kate's Collection Top Gun, American Pie 2, Mean Girls, Beetlejuice- :thumbsup::thumbsup: Pirates of the Caribbean, Deep Blue Sea, Jumanji, Vertical Limit - :thumbsup: Big Daddy, Signs, Shrek 2, Bridget Jones Diary - even The Day After Tomorrow, Don't Say A Word - :down: Crazy Beautiful, How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days, About a Boy - haven't seen Close, but I gotta go with Kate. |
Originally posted by AndyHome trust me, you dont wana see kate ;) |
I voted for Kate's collection because she is Michael Moore-free. way to go KATE |
Andy loses because of Donnie Darko.
|
Andy loses points because of Bowling for Columbine. Sis wins
Skip |
Originally posted by Johnny Zhivago Andy has "movie x" because Andy likes it. Kate has "movie y" because Kate likes it. There is no better, it's a matter of personal taste. |
i want my .20 secs back, neither wins cause neither has a "collection" thats more of an assortment.
|
Originally posted by evitagen Actually, Andy has more Y movies and Kate has more X movies. |
Your sister has BIG DADDY. :up:
You don't. :down: |
Originally posted by B.A. Your sister has BIG DADDY. :up: You don't. :down: |
Let's see here....
Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 +5 Kill Bill Vol 2 +5 Pulp Fiction +5 Reservoir Dogs +4 Bowling for Columbine -15 Road Trip 0 Scarface 0 American Pie 1 +1 American Pie 2 +1 American Pie 3 -6 Donnie Darko +4 One Hour Photo +2 Trainspotting +4 Fight Club +3 Shawshank Redemption +5 total: 18 points Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful +1 Big Daddy -2 American Pie 2 +2 Mean Girls +4 The Day After Tomorrow -3 Top Gun +3 How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days -5 Pirates of the Caribbean +6 Bridget Jones Diary 0 Shrek 2 0 Don't Say A Word -3 About A Boy +4 Jumanji -5 Signs +2 Vertical Limit +1 (for visuals and sound) total: 5 points Do not question the science that went into this calculation, it would be incomprehensible to any pedestrian scholar. ...not even Michael Moore could stop Andy's domination. |
Andy's Collection (good ones only)
Bowling for Columbine American Pie 1 American Pie 2 Fight Club Shawshank Redemption Kate's Collection (good ones only) American Pie 2 Top Gun (and this ones a stretch) Just my opinion :P |
Re: Please Settle My Debate
Andy's Collection
Kill Bill Vol 1 - like Kill Bill Vol 2 - like Pulp Fiction - like Reservoir Dogs - like Bowling for Columbine - never saw Road Trip - overrated Scarface - like American Pie 1 - like American Pie 2 - like American Pie 3 - like Donnie Darko - like One Hour Photo - never saw Trainspotting - never saw Fight Club - like Shawshank Redemption - like Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful - ok Big Daddy - like American Pie 2 - like Mean Girls - never saw The Day After Tomorrow - never saw Top Gun - like How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days - like Pirates of the Caribbean - like Bridget Jones Diary - never saw Shrek 2 - like Don't Say A Word - never saw About A Boy - never saw Jumanji - never saw Signs - like Vertical Limit- never saw Deep Blue Sea - never saw Beetlejuice - like I guess you win, but she's only 15 and i'm partial to a lot of those "guy" movies. |
I like Kate's selection of movies better.
Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 - like Kill Bill Vol 2 - like Pulp Fiction - never saw Reservoir Dogs - never saw Bowling for Columbine - never saw Road Trip - it was pretty funny Scarface - never saw American Pie 1 - like American Pie 2 - like American Pie 3 - like Donnie Darko - never saw One Hour Photo - never saw Trainspotting - never saw Fight Club - I thought this was overrated, prefer Mortal Kombat- SERIOUSLY! Shawshank Redemption - never saw Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful - never saw Big Daddy - like American Pie 2 - like Mean Girls - like The Day After Tomorrow - like Top Gun - like How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days - like Pirates of the Caribbean - like Bridget Jones Diary - never saw Shrek 2 - like Don't Say A Word - like About A Boy - never saw Jumanji - like Signs - like Vertical Limit- never saw Deep Blue Sea - never saw Beetlejuice - like Yeah, yeah whatever. I've never seen what some of you might consider the best movies of all time. I'm more into joe-sixpack movies, but I HATE foolscreen. If there's no chance they'd ever try and make a video game or Happy Meal toys about a movie, I've probably never seen it. |
Originally posted by scott1598 why do constantly feel the need to pick on me? it's just wrong... Hey, atleast I acknowledge you. ;) |
Kate has twice as many that I own also so my vote is for Kate.
|
wow tough crowd.
Remember that these 2 are still teenagers. Andy has guy movies Kate has girl movies. I'm a guy so I like Andy's movies. If I was a girl, I'd probably like Kate's movies. Plus, if you like your collection, who really cares what others think? The important thing is that you enjoy it. |
No one likes One Hour Photo???
|
Andy loses because he actually posted this.
Kate wins. |
Re: Please Settle My Debate
On a -2 (Awful/Very Bad) to +2 (Great/Very Good) scale
Andy's Collection Kill Bill Vol 1 Good +1 Kill Bill Vol 2 Good +1 Pulp Fiction Great +2 Reservoir Dogs Good +1 Bowling for Columbine Good +1 Road Trip Awful -2 Scarface Good +1 American Pie 1 Good +1 American Pie 2 OK +0 American Pie 3 Bad -1 Donnie Darko Good +1 One Hour Photo OK +0 Trainspotting Great +2 Fight Club Great +2 Shawshank Redemption Good +1 Total: 11 points (15 movies) Kate's Collection Crazy Beautiful Good +1 Big Daddy Bad -1 American Pie 2 OK +0 Mean Girls OK +0 The Day After Tomorrow OK +0 Top Gun OK +0 How to Lose A Guy In 10 Days Awful -2 Pirates of the Caribbean OK +0 Bridget Jones Diary Good +1 Shrek 2 Good +1 Don't Say A Word Awful -2 About A Boy Very Good +2 Jumanji OK +0 Signs OK +0 Vertical Limit OK +0 Deep Blue Sea OK +0 Beetlejuice Good +1 Total: 1 point (17 movies) Andy wins by a lot. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:39 AM. |
Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.