With Michael Moore's presence, what would've been a runaway for Andy turns into a squeaker for him, since the only decent movies in Kate's collection were Pirates of the Caribean and Beetlejuice.

Re: Please Settle My Debate
 

As far as rewatchability...

By the way I'm 25...

Andy's sis wins....


Sorry andy but Bowling for Columbine makes you lose points

Andy wins (not a very close call, IMO)

Ditto!!!! In spades!!!!

Poorly designed poll. You didn't include a "they are equally bad" option and a "they are equally great" option. I'd choose "they are equally bad" because, for one, I refuse to vote positively for a DVD collection that includes all three American Pie movies.

Sorry, that's just the way it is in my world.

Where's the "I dont like either collection" option?

Really, the only movie off both lists that I own is Pirates of the Caribbean, so I guess by default Kate wins - but it's like coming in first at the Special Olympics. Yes, you may have a gold medal, but youre still retarded.

(and I'm a 35 year old guy)

:lol:

I like some of each.....so I'd say it's a tie

25/F
Movies I like out of each collection:
Andy's Collection
Kill Bill Vol 1
Kill Bill Vol 2
Pulp Fiction
Reservoir Dogs
Scarface
American Pie 1
American Pie 2
American Pie 3
Donnie Darko
One Hour Photo
Trainspotting
Fight Club
Shawshank Redemption

Kate's Collection
Big Daddy
American Pie 2
Mean Girls
The Day After Tomorrow- This one was ok
Top Gun
Pirates of the Caribbean
Bridget Jones Diary
Shrek 2
Beetlejuice

I voted for Andy's Collection

Everyone's forgetting the most important question. The only question that matters:

Is Kate hot?

If so, then her movie collection is better.

;)

Let's see, in both I like:

Andy's Collection
Pulp Fiction
Scarface (own myself)
Shawshank Redemption (own myself)

Kate's Collection
Top Gun
Bridget Jones Diary (just saw)
Shrek 2 (own myself)
Beetlejuice

Andy obviously wins but we won't really know until both buy several hundred more DVDs.

Really, this should be judged by size. Whose is bigger, yours or your sister's?

Andy...your collection is much better. Loose the American Pie films and Road Trip...... and I would give your collection a ****/**** :)

Why are you even debating this with her? Seems rather childish to me. You have movies you like; she has movies she likes. Neither is better. End of story.

ok maybe i didnt explain well enough... the debate was not a very serious debate lol it was just a bit of banter

to those who dont like the American Pie movies... I like these just for comedy value, other than that they're not much else.
road trip seemed a bit disjointed when i watched it too, i bought it because i'd heard good things

and for those who are wondering whether my sister is hot...
im not going to pass judgment... because...
1) SHE IS 15 YEARS OLD FFS
2) She's my sister.

so no pics will be posted of her ;)

I am going to go with your sisters. Seems like better variety.

Kate's collection is more varied and doesn't include as many of the American Pie movies. She wins.

And your point is what exactly? :) :p

No can do chief... Not voting, both are the same for that exact reason - personal taste. But, if you wanna know what kind of films <i>I</i> keep around, my collection is linked in my sig. I have, I think, eight of your films and none of Kate's.

34 BTW.

Why all the hate for Road Trip? It is so much better than the American Pie movies.

Yeah, but thats like saying "Which is better: a kick to the head or a kick to the nutsack?"

Forehead or temple? If forehead is allowed, I chose a boot to the head.

Well definitely Andy, as bar bowling for columbine and fight club, he definitely takes the cake (though I hope you made the right edition choices)

I voted for Andy's collection because I know Kate personally and to be blunt, she's far too full of herself.

K

Well. . . lets say forehead - but it's Bruce Lee thats doing the kicking.