ANH glaring error
 

just got the star wars trilogy on dvd last night from borders.com. tonight i watched a new hope. there seem to be quite a few problems with the video. if you have the dvds, did you notice a glaring problem with the creature outside the door of the cantina? he's missing his lower half...

keith

He is standing behind a wall, which is why you can't see his lower half.

Is anyone even ENJOYING these movies or is everyone just trying to pick everything to death?

No no no. You're missing the fun of Star Wars. The point is to bitch about Lucas changing things and updated special effects, then to go back and complain that there's a small technical defect in the presentation.

Wait you mean you actually watch the movies for like the story and stuff? Bah!

On a more serious note, I think it's just a case where these are films that many will watch over and over, and since everyone is talking about them, it's fun in some ways to pick them apart. The magic of multiple threads...you can avoid the topics we don't like.

Yeah, but which polyphonic ringtone do you think Han Solo uses?

It doesn't matter because everyone knows he doesn't get service with Cingular in outer space. That's just common sense.

uhh... take a closer look...

Another glaring error I heard in the cantina scene (while continuing to ENJOY the movie :D) is that Han says something along the lines of "I made that route in less than 30 parsecs" referring to a unit of time. A parsec is a unit of distance.

Obviously, a "parsec" is something different in the Star Wars universe than it is in our universe. ;)

Yeah, that's a wall, dude. The CGI is a tad shaky, but it's behind a wall.

From the official Star Wars FAQ:

There was an amusing story about this in one of the recent Dark Horse comics. But, then again, George is selective about which non-cinematic stories are part of the cannon [even though Lucasfilm approves every single thing..].

well do you have the special edition on vhs? take a look at that... i don't think it's a wall...

keith

This thread is useless without a screencap.

http://img80.exs.cx/img80/9642/PDVD_23.jpg

It is clearly a wall. It's as plain as the nose on my face. There was always a dewback there. This scene is the same as it was before, the only difference is the dewback is now CG.

Edit: The wall may be new, I don't remember. But it's clearly a wall he's standing behind.

It's hard to enjoy ANH when the sound has been completely butchered.

In ANH when C3-PO, and R2-D2 crash on Tat. As they are walking away and you see the pod in the back, to the right of it there is a big blue splotch, that looks to be the same blue color of a blue screen, is that suposed to be there, as in being a parashute, if it is, there doesn't seem to be any texture to it at all.

which creature in that picture is supposedly missing its lower half?

He's talking about the dewback in the background, but it's obvious he standing behind a wall.

I was hoping they would erase the R5 droid error scene when uncle owen is buying the droids. After it has blown up while still next to luke, it appears in a shot next to R2 again when it clearly cannot be. Maybe the 30th anniversary version will get rid of it as well as fixed sound and lightsabers. ;)

Also, they forgot to color chewie's feet when they are swinging on the vine in ROTJ. Doh.

As you can see he was behind the wall in 1977 and remained there in the 1997/2004 version.

http://www.siteload.com//getimg.php?...comparison.jpg

no wonder i couldnt tell...its DEFINITELY behind a wall. what the hell was he talking about?!

I thought that also when I first watched ANH on DVD, but if you watch them get into the POD, you will see that the inside of the door hatch is indeed very blue. So, it is very blue in the bright sun light.

Back in 1977 my assumption was that the line was bluster by Han Solo.

But in this DVD set Lucas addresses the issue in the ANH commentary (1:03:20) by saying that navigating around obstacles in hyperspace is difficult and the Millennium Falcon's navicomputer is the best there is, hence Solo can get between two points in a shorter distance by means of more precise navigating, making it the "fastest" ship in the galaxy. This was the reason for bragging about making "the Kessel run in less than twelve parsecs", a unit of distance (3.26 light-years).

It was clear from what Lucas said that he was well aware of the criticism of his use of the term "parsec". But he threw a lot of jargon into Star Wars (for example the term "droids"), without explanation, on purpose. He was trying to present his created universe from the point of view that everyone knew how things worked and he could just get on with telling the story, without exposition of the technical details. In 1977 this was a major departure from the norm.

I know I'm enjoying them. It must suck to be fixated on minor things and not be able to enjoy these great dvd's.