Heat SE (2 disc re-release) Where Art Thou? (merged)
#29
New Member
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 14
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: TX
Originally posted by Julie Walker
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO have you ever seen a Micheal Mann reedit before????
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO have you ever seen a Micheal Mann reedit before????
The theatrical version was tight and perfectly paced. Mann destroyed this with his director's cut.
(Same with Milos Foreman's 'Amadeus' director's cut. Ugh.. painful.)
#30
DVD Talk Special Edition
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,701
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by mattp
(Same with Milos Foreman's 'Amadeus' director's cut. Ugh.. painful.)
(Same with Milos Foreman's 'Amadeus' director's cut. Ugh.. painful.)
Saul Zaentz never struck me as caring much about length either way.
#31
Originally posted by Geofferson
God, I hope this includes the Director's Cut of the film!
God, I hope this includes the Director's Cut of the film!
#32
DVD Talk Special Edition
Yeah the movie doesn't need a director's cut, it's already three hours long. But I certainly won't mind seeing the deleted scenes in some form.
I also wouldn't mind a new transfer, as the current one is subpar (it's a laserdisc rehash).
I also wouldn't mind a new transfer, as the current one is subpar (it's a laserdisc rehash).
#33
DVD Talk God
Why would the WB want to wait to have it coincide with the DVD release of Collateral. It's 2 different studios......Collateral is Paramount/Dreamworks.
#34
Originally posted by DJariya
Why would the WB want to wait to have it coincide with the DVD release of Collateral. It's 2 different studios......Collateral is Paramount/Dreamworks.
Why would the WB want to wait to have it coincide with the DVD release of Collateral. It's 2 different studios......Collateral is Paramount/Dreamworks.
#35
Moderator
Originally posted by Julie Walker
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO have you ever seen a Micheal Mann reedit before????
NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO have you ever seen a Micheal Mann reedit before????
#37
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Geofferson
The reason I say that is that a while back I read an interview with him where the DC was supposed to air on NBC in a two-part series a couple years back. Eventually, NBC chose not to air the DC and stick with the theatrical version.
The reason I say that is that a while back I read an interview with him where the DC was supposed to air on NBC in a two-part series a couple years back. Eventually, NBC chose not to air the DC and stick with the theatrical version.
#38
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Originally posted by Josh Z
What NBC did was even worse. Mann gave them a cut of the film with 40 or so minutes of new footage so that the movie could be split into a 2-part miniseries. NBC decided at the last minute that they'd rather air the whole thing in a single 3-hour timeslot. If you'll recall, the movie's theatrical running time was just over 3 hours. So instead of using the version with 40 minutes of new footage, they discarded it completely and instead cut about 40 minutes of old footage from the theatrical cut. Entire characters and subplots were excised. Mann was furious, and demanded they remove his name from the film. The version that aired was credited to "Alan Smithee".
What NBC did was even worse. Mann gave them a cut of the film with 40 or so minutes of new footage so that the movie could be split into a 2-part miniseries. NBC decided at the last minute that they'd rather air the whole thing in a single 3-hour timeslot. If you'll recall, the movie's theatrical running time was just over 3 hours. So instead of using the version with 40 minutes of new footage, they discarded it completely and instead cut about 40 minutes of old footage from the theatrical cut. Entire characters and subplots were excised. Mann was furious, and demanded they remove his name from the film. The version that aired was credited to "Alan Smithee".
#40
from the digitalbits (rumor mill)
A lot of you guys have been asking us when we'll finally see Warner's TBA Heat: Special Edition. Look for it to street at the end of the year, timed to coincide with the DVD release of Michael Mann's Collateral (from DreamWorks or Paramount - we're not sure how the video rights will split).
#43
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 3,422
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: The Pacific Northwest
The Heat SE has officially joined the ranks of Duel and Ed Wood. Btw, insofar as the tie-in with Collateral goes, did anyone else think it was a pathethic attempt to replicate the style and mood (and epic quality) of Heat? I mean, Tom Cruise even looked like De Niro - same hair, same suit and everything (just not the same quality of acting). Oh well, I guess I'll just bide my time with the bare-bones version until next year.
#45
Banned
Originally posted by joliom
Btw, insofar as the tie-in with Collateral goes, did anyone else think it was a pathethic attempt to replicate the style and mood (and epic quality) of Heat? I mean, Tom Cruise even looked like De Niro - same hair, same suit and everything (just not the same quality of acting).
Btw, insofar as the tie-in with Collateral goes, did anyone else think it was a pathethic attempt to replicate the style and mood (and epic quality) of Heat? I mean, Tom Cruise even looked like De Niro - same hair, same suit and everything (just not the same quality of acting).
I agree and those are just some of my problems with Collateral which, although it's an improvement on Ali, I still think is ridiculously overrated and doesn't come close to touching Heat. From the ridiculous scene where Foxx faces those thugs in the restaurant to the nightclub shootout where miraculously NOT ONE SINGLE BYSTANDER GETS SHOT despite the hail of bullets going off to Cruise just getting up, shaking the dust off his pretty suit and running away just seconds after being in a brutal car crash to the preposterous coincidence involving Jada Pinkett Smith's character near the end to Cruise getting shot in the neck and just brushing it off like this guy's the fuckin Terminator, etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. etc. Some people think THIS was comparable to Heat???? NO FUCKING WAY. N O W A Y.
Anyways, can't wait till this SE comes out, whenever that may be.
#46
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 54,199
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: City of the lakers.. riots.. and drug dealing cops.. los(t) Angel(e)s. ca.
You have fuck'n got to be kidding me. If Cruise looks like De Niro, it's for a reason. Cruise is suppose to look like any average 9-5 worker in downtown los angeles. he is suppose to blend in.
Collateral was one hell of an amazing film using the city as an important actor that took a step forward from heat where the city was also a major factor in it.
Collateral was one hell of an amazing film using the city as an important actor that took a step forward from heat where the city was also a major factor in it.
#47
Banned
Originally posted by Jackskeleton
If Cruise looks like De Niro, it's for a reason. Cruise is suppose to look like any average 9-5 worker in downtown los angeles. he is suppose to blend in.
If Cruise looks like De Niro, it's for a reason. Cruise is suppose to look like any average 9-5 worker in downtown los angeles. he is suppose to blend in.
#49
DVD Talk Godfather
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 54,199
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: City of the lakers.. riots.. and drug dealing cops.. los(t) Angel(e)s. ca.
Originally posted by Rivero
Well he didn't do a very good job. If I saw this guy walking down the street I'd ask him, "What the fuck happened with your lousy dye job? Are you TRYING to look old or something??"
Well he didn't do a very good job. If I saw this guy walking down the street I'd ask him, "What the fuck happened with your lousy dye job? Are you TRYING to look old or something??"



