The Ultimate Spine Number Collector's Question
#1
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
The Ultimate Spine Number Collector's Question
There may be more, but there are three studio series that come to mind with "spine numbers" - Criterion, Fox Studio Classics, and Fox Special Edition. How many there are is not integral to the question however.
I am almost finished collecting all the Fox Studio Classics (granted there is less than 20). I haven't seen them all yet, but I am curious what will happen when I watch one I don't like. Will I break up the series and sell/trade it?!?!? (this is asked tongue in cheek, of course).
So that's my question: if you really didn't care for a movie, would you still keep it for the spine number?
I am almost finished collecting all the Fox Studio Classics (granted there is less than 20). I haven't seen them all yet, but I am curious what will happen when I watch one I don't like. Will I break up the series and sell/trade it?!?!? (this is asked tongue in cheek, of course).
So that's my question: if you really didn't care for a movie, would you still keep it for the spine number?
#2
DVD Talk Gold Edition
People collect for all sorts of reasons. The analogy in record collecting is called "running a label", that is, collecting all of the records that were issued on a record label (usually a small label with a limited number of releases), regardless of the quality of the songs or artists represented on the records. People do this with 78s, 45s, and LPs, and perhaps for CDs, 8-tracks, etc. for all I know.
I don't collect (or accumulate, more accurately) anything this way, I care about the content of the music/movie/book or whatever, more than the idea of having all of a particular series. But everyone has their own tastes and pleasures that they derive from collecting.
I don't collect (or accumulate, more accurately) anything this way, I care about the content of the music/movie/book or whatever, more than the idea of having all of a particular series. But everyone has their own tastes and pleasures that they derive from collecting.
#3
DVD Talk Limited Edition
I have all the Fox Studio Classics, and there are a few I didn't really care for. But I'm keeping them, since I want the whole set; besides, I might enjoy the extras.
Rob
Rob
#4
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
I've got all but 3 of of the Fox Studio Classics. I enjoy all the ones I have with the exception of An Affair to Remember. Ironically, this was the one I was sure I would enjoy since I'm a big Cary Grant fan. One disc that I really liked was the Titanic. The movie is pretty ok but I didn't expect a 1-1/2 hour documentary! Great stuff.
To answer your questions, I'd probably stick with the movie just to have the whole collection since I really enjoy 97% of the releases so far.
To answer your questions, I'd probably stick with the movie just to have the whole collection since I really enjoy 97% of the releases so far.
#5
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: The Ultimate Spine Number Collector's Question
Originally posted by DVD Josh
So that's my question: if you really didn't care for a movie, would you still keep it for the spine number?
So that's my question: if you really didn't care for a movie, would you still keep it for the spine number?
Anyone want it?
#6
DVD Talk Reviewer
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 1,896
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: Region Free
I can respect that some people are completists in their approach to collecting DVDs, and that need to complete a collection may involve a particular distributor, label, director, subgenre, actor or other classification. I think such collections can be pretty fascinating.
I, however, am not a completist collector. I don't buy DVDs I don't think I'll like, and I sell off DVDs I bought but didn't care for. To each his own.
I, however, am not a completist collector. I don't buy DVDs I don't think I'll like, and I sell off DVDs I bought but didn't care for. To each his own.
#7
DVD Talk Legend
Numerical gaps in a collection don't bother me at all - I stick with the movies I like and will continue to enjoy. Hell, I can't even afford all the ones I want, so I'm not about to spend money on a DVD simply because there's a number on the spine.
#9
Suspended
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 4,533
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: You have moved into a dark place. It is pitch black. You are likely to be eaten by a grue.
I've just started picking up some of the Fox Studio Classics, and now that I have about half of them, I'm considering just getting the ones that price-dropped - most of them are total blind-buys - I haven't seen most - so they're worth getting just so I can educate myself a little better, build up my repertoire of classic films.
I'm wondering how many "Studio Classics" Fox has left. I mean, are all of their old back catalog titles considered "Classics" now?
I'm wondering how many "Studio Classics" Fox has left. I mean, are all of their old back catalog titles considered "Classics" now?
#10
Thread Starter
DVD Talk Hero
Originally posted by jough
I've just started picking up some of the Fox Studio Classics, and now that I have about half of them, I'm considering just getting the ones that price-dropped - most of them are total blind-buys - I haven't seen most - so they're worth getting just so I can educate myself a little better, build up my repertoire of classic films.
I'm wondering how many "Studio Classics" Fox has left. I mean, are all of their old back catalog titles considered "Classics" now?
I've just started picking up some of the Fox Studio Classics, and now that I have about half of them, I'm considering just getting the ones that price-dropped - most of them are total blind-buys - I haven't seen most - so they're worth getting just so I can educate myself a little better, build up my repertoire of classic films.
I'm wondering how many "Studio Classics" Fox has left. I mean, are all of their old back catalog titles considered "Classics" now?
#12
Suspended
Joined: Aug 2000
Posts: 4,533
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: You have moved into a dark place. It is pitch black. You are likely to be eaten by a grue.
Originally posted by aa-dvd
anyone have a list of the FOX studio classics???
anyone have a list of the FOX studio classics???
http://www.dvdaficionado.com/dvds.ht...tudio+classics




