Heat dvd?
#1
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Heat dvd?
My aunt brought up the movie this afternoon. Said her son recommended it despite her not being into 'action' films. He has it on dvd..& she said she's interested in seeing it now after i praised the film as a great drama(which it really is).
I have'nt seen the film since 1995 though,but remember it being pretty amazing. I saw it two times. A P&S vhs,then a OAR vhs later on.
Now i get differing opinions on the sound quality for the dvd. Many say it's state of the art reference(then,maybe not now) quality loud surround sound. While quite a few say it has horrible very low tiny,compressed sound with no surround activity at all. So whats the story on this?
Was there a bad batch of discs or did some people just not have there sound systems set up correctly?
I'm interested in picking up the disc sometime,but not if it has crappy sound.
One thing i wonder though. What is up with Micheal Mann & his alterations to many of his films?
I don't think i've seen one 'directors cut' of his films that were any good(the theatricals were near perfection!). It seems more like he just loves to experimentwith re-editing & altering to see how they turn out. Since some of his editing choices are confusing at best & ruin the impact of some sequences.
So it's a surprise that Heat is still in it's original form,but for how long? I may have to pick it up for that reason alone.
I have'nt seen the film since 1995 though,but remember it being pretty amazing. I saw it two times. A P&S vhs,then a OAR vhs later on.
Now i get differing opinions on the sound quality for the dvd. Many say it's state of the art reference(then,maybe not now) quality loud surround sound. While quite a few say it has horrible very low tiny,compressed sound with no surround activity at all. So whats the story on this?
Was there a bad batch of discs or did some people just not have there sound systems set up correctly?
I'm interested in picking up the disc sometime,but not if it has crappy sound.
One thing i wonder though. What is up with Micheal Mann & his alterations to many of his films?
I don't think i've seen one 'directors cut' of his films that were any good(the theatricals were near perfection!). It seems more like he just loves to experimentwith re-editing & altering to see how they turn out. Since some of his editing choices are confusing at best & ruin the impact of some sequences.
So it's a surprise that Heat is still in it's original form,but for how long? I may have to pick it up for that reason alone.
Last edited by Julie Walker; 10-02-07 at 11:15 PM.
#3
Member
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The audio, to me, just sounds compressed(data-wise and dynamic-wise). It's definitely not bad for when the DVD was made, but pretty bad by today's standards.
It's still acceptable though, it's not offensive by any means, just not up to today's standards. Don't let that stop you from buying it.
It's still acceptable though, it's not offensive by any means, just not up to today's standards. Don't let that stop you from buying it.
#4
DVD Talk Hero
this is one of those movies where the dialouge is very soft (it is not compressed, its called dynamic range), and when you hit the big gun fight, be prepaired to get blown away with sound. (there are a few other parts that are loud, but that is the main portion.
#7
DVD Talk Godfather
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: City of the lakers.. riots.. and drug dealing cops.. los(t) Angel(e)s. ca.
Posts: 54,199
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Sticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chicken. You are still a guy and shouldn't be called Lady.
anyhow. about this film. Who really knows if a re-release is in the works. I would love one to be since I found the extra's lacking and would shell out the $$ for that alone. I haven't heard of any plans for it though..
Should you call it as it is? Censorship? anyhow, I haven't heard of any word of this going OOP anytime soon so you are safe to hold off for a while till word of a new one is(if it is) released.
anyhow. about this film. Who really knows if a re-release is in the works. I would love one to be since I found the extra's lacking and would shell out the $$ for that alone. I haven't heard of any plans for it though..
I don't think i've seen one 'directors cut' of his films that were any good(the theatricals were near perfection!). It seems more like he just loves to experimentwith re-editing & altering to see how they turn out. Since some of his editing choices are confusing at best & ruin the impact of some sequences.
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Mar 2000
Posts: 613
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I watched it a couple of weeks ago and the sound was fine. The gunfight was firmly in the 'amazingly great' category and a couple of people there (who never notice sound quality) commented on how good it sounded.
#11
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Originally posted by Liquid Rush
There`s no reason not to pick this movie up as it usually sells for $7-9.99 most places! And it does not sound that bad, but Id sure be up for a Special Edition!!
There`s no reason not to pick this movie up as it usually sells for $7-9.99 most places! And it does not sound that bad, but Id sure be up for a Special Edition!!
I have'nt checked Wal-Mart,though have refused to shop there for a few months now.
#13
Senior Member
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Los Angeles, CA
Posts: 275
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Heat is one of my personal favorite movies of all time. Saw it in the theater a few times, bought the VHS, the Laseerdisc, and now I have the DVD.
The audio transfer on the DVD is average, I think the audio on the LD is much more punchy. In the theater this movie was just plain loud. The video transfer on the DVD is average as well.
Many people have this theory that just because Heat has a huge gun fight in it that it is "demo material". The bank robbery gun fight really isn't that dynamic of a scene, most of the sound coming from the center and fronts. Personally I find that the best scenes in that movie from an audio standpoint are the armored car C-4 explosion followed by the windows shattering, and the scene near the airport with Al and Bobby D.
For 7-10 bucks, its a great movie, but don't expect amazing sound or video transfer. I'm hoping that this eventually gets some sort of special edition with some extra footage or commentary, but I'm not counting on it, since its not something Michael Mann does
The audio transfer on the DVD is average, I think the audio on the LD is much more punchy. In the theater this movie was just plain loud. The video transfer on the DVD is average as well.
Many people have this theory that just because Heat has a huge gun fight in it that it is "demo material". The bank robbery gun fight really isn't that dynamic of a scene, most of the sound coming from the center and fronts. Personally I find that the best scenes in that movie from an audio standpoint are the armored car C-4 explosion followed by the windows shattering, and the scene near the airport with Al and Bobby D.
For 7-10 bucks, its a great movie, but don't expect amazing sound or video transfer. I'm hoping that this eventually gets some sort of special edition with some extra footage or commentary, but I'm not counting on it, since its not something Michael Mann does
#14
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by Furio
For 7-10 bucks, its a great movie, but don't expect amazing sound or video transfer. I'm hoping that this eventually gets some sort of special edition with some extra footage or commentary, but I'm not counting on it, since its not something Michael Mann does
For 7-10 bucks, its a great movie, but don't expect amazing sound or video transfer. I'm hoping that this eventually gets some sort of special edition with some extra footage or commentary, but I'm not counting on it, since its not something Michael Mann does
#15
Member
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Raleigh, NC
Posts: 134
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Rypro 525
this is one of those movies where the dialouge is very soft (it is not compressed, its called dynamic range), and when you hit the big gun fight, be prepaired to get blown away with sound. (there are a few other parts that are loud, but that is the main portion.
this is one of those movies where the dialouge is very soft (it is not compressed, its called dynamic range), and when you hit the big gun fight, be prepaired to get blown away with sound. (there are a few other parts that are loud, but that is the main portion.
As far as the dynamics being compressed, it happens in the action scenes for me. Sounds lose their liveliness and sound rather flat.
But that's just me
#16
Moderator
For the record, Heat is my favorite movie of the 90s.
The current disc is decent in the A/V department. I'd love to have this released as a full-blown SE with the addt'l footage that was left out.
From IMDB:
The current disc is decent in the A/V department. I'd love to have this released as a full-blown SE with the addt'l footage that was left out.
From IMDB:
Television version aired by NBC on January 3rd, 1999 was disowned by director Michael Mann and credited to Alan Smithee because, though Mann offered to reinstate 17 minutes of deleted footage in the film to make it fit a four hour timeslot, NBC decided to excise over 40 minutes of footage from the theatrical release in order to make it fit a three hour slot (including commercials).
#17
Banned
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: NYC
Posts: 15,957
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Jackskeleton
Sticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chicken. You are still a guy and shouldn't be called Lady.
Sticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chicken. You are still a guy and shouldn't be called Lady.
As for the DVD, I don't remember it being anything spectacular. I can say that the laserdisc was kick ass when I had it.
#18
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Thread Starter
Originally posted by Jackskeleton
Sticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chicken. You are still a guy and shouldn't be called Lady.
Sticking feathers up your butt does not make you a chicken. You are still a guy and shouldn't be called Lady.
OT: You obviouslly have a very narrow view of gender & sexuality. This mindset is also whats caused many TS's as well as homosexuals to suicide. + Whats with str8 guys preocupation with things up there butts?
Though thats a debate for a whole 'nother thread & has been discussed time & again. Yet only idiots have to keep pointing out 'No your not that,your this' in case of transsexuals. Well sorry bub,you don't know a thing about myself or ts's in general. So just give it a rest..mmkay?
Back on topic. I may just rent the dvd or try finding the laserdisc just in case. I remember The Exorcist SE dvd had pretty bad sound quality. Had no life to it at all,that i had to keep playing with the remote turning it up,then down since the sound level was either to low,or to loud at any given second. Now i really wish Warner would correct that & also include the original mono(i think) soundmix which should be far superior. I hated the alternate version & never plan on owning that,despite the soundmix being better encoded.
#19
New Member
Join Date: Feb 2001
Posts: 17
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Julie Walker
I looked at Best Buy,Borders & Target..& they were all for $14.99 or more. I could have sworn they marked it down to $9 or less,unless that was just a sale?
I have'nt checked Wal-Mart,though have refused to shop there for a few months now.
I looked at Best Buy,Borders & Target..& they were all for $14.99 or more. I could have sworn they marked it down to $9 or less,unless that was just a sale?
I have'nt checked Wal-Mart,though have refused to shop there for a few months now.
#20
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Aug 2001
Location: PA
Posts: 2,180
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
man i hope this movie is re-released, warner has been doing quite a few 2 disc re-releases. i'd love to have it in dts, plus commentary and branching with the 17 dleted minutes.