Fahrenheit 451 dvd review wanted please
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 674
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Fahrenheit 451 dvd review wanted please
I am looking for a review or link to a review of this just released Fahrenheit 451 dvd directed by the great Truffaut. Is this a good blind buy since I love Truffaut's films?
#2
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Olympia, WA
Posts: 2,421
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re: Fahrenheit 451 dvd review wanted please
Originally posted by insanecollector
I am looking for a review or link to a review of this just released Fahrenheit 451 dvd directed by the great Truffaut. Is this a good blind buy since I love Truffaut's films?
I am looking for a review or link to a review of this just released Fahrenheit 451 dvd directed by the great Truffaut. Is this a good blind buy since I love Truffaut's films?
You can pick this up for $9.35 at DDD. It has a score by Bernard Herrmann, cinematography by Nic Roeg, an anamorphic transfer, a commentary track, a 45 making of documentary, a fifteen minute doc on Herrmann, a 10 minute doc on the original novel, and it's a great sci-fi film, a great Truffaut film, and the only one he did in English. Really this is a no-brainer.
Pick it up!
Here's a thread on the DVD at mhvf.net
http://www.mhvf.net/cgi-bin/anyboard...Qz=&aO=1&iWz=0
& here's the disc specs.
http://www.dvdplanet.com/product_lis...roductid=29970
cheers, Tony Block
#4
DVD Talk Legend
I skimmed through this last night -- holy crap this is a great disc.
Nice anamorphic transfer, great (from what little I heard) commentary, a bunch of fantastic Laurent Bouzereau supplements (including a 45-minute "making of" documentary).
Jeez, I had no idea this thing would be so packed. Best $10 I've spent in a long time.
Nice anamorphic transfer, great (from what little I heard) commentary, a bunch of fantastic Laurent Bouzereau supplements (including a 45-minute "making of" documentary).
Jeez, I had no idea this thing would be so packed. Best $10 I've spent in a long time.
#6
DVD Talk Legend
Definitely one of the best DVD deals to come out in quite a while!
The specs all say "commentary by Julie Christie" but that commentary also features the film editor, the producer and several others including Ray Bradbury!
I've seen this film many many times, but the insights and information on this disc are nothing short of amazing - it leaps onto my "essential DVD list" !
The specs all say "commentary by Julie Christie" but that commentary also features the film editor, the producer and several others including Ray Bradbury!
I've seen this film many many times, but the insights and information on this disc are nothing short of amazing - it leaps onto my "essential DVD list" !
#10
Senior Member
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 491
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just finished watching the Movie. It was a decent flick and not a bad pickup for $10. I will go back and watch it with the comentary and the Ray B. interview.
Tell me why you liked this movie, I thought it was good but im having a problem putting my finger on why it was good.
Thanks
Tell me why you liked this movie, I thought it was good but im having a problem putting my finger on why it was good.
Thanks
#11
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Re: Fahrenheit 451 dvd review wanted please
Our local library just opened a new facility and I selected this as one of my inaugural check-outs. The novel was the first book I ever read in one setting, and even now just thinking about it can raise my blood pressure. I thoroughly enjoyed the film, and the DVD extras. Some thoughts:
I understand why they jettisoned some of the story elements for the purpose of the adaptation, but by abandoning the atomic war subplot entirely, the scene where Montag confronts his wife's friends becomes too random. Also, in the novel he is more or less seduced into bibliophilia by his neighbors; in the film his transformation is nearly arbitrary.
Still, these nitpicks aside, yes the film is clearly dated. But, remember, the novel was published in the 50s; if we can accept its vision of the future, why not the 1966 film's interpretation of that future? Besides, the moment when his wife gives him a new, switchblade straight razor to replace his electric one, I think it's clear that many of the dated items are simply "retro" things that have come back into style by the time of the film. Certainly, it's plausible enough that I went along with it.
In many ways, the film reminded me of Eyes Wide Shut--it's moody, discomforting and full of subtleties. Just as I noticed shades of blue in EWS, I saw shades of red in 451. There is a surreality to the storytelling, and its visuals, that make this an uncomfortable film to watch--which, given its content, it should be. It's not a film to watch casually. I loved the spoken credits, because they were so jarring, and set the tone from the very beginning.
The DVD extras are rewarding and insightful, though it would have been nice had they included something with Truffaut himself--even archival footage with subtitles would have been nice. The full list price is only $12.98 and even at that price I would recommend it as a blind buy--but I would also advise reading the novel first.
I understand why they jettisoned some of the story elements for the purpose of the adaptation, but by abandoning the atomic war subplot entirely, the scene where Montag confronts his wife's friends becomes too random. Also, in the novel he is more or less seduced into bibliophilia by his neighbors; in the film his transformation is nearly arbitrary.
Still, these nitpicks aside, yes the film is clearly dated. But, remember, the novel was published in the 50s; if we can accept its vision of the future, why not the 1966 film's interpretation of that future? Besides, the moment when his wife gives him a new, switchblade straight razor to replace his electric one, I think it's clear that many of the dated items are simply "retro" things that have come back into style by the time of the film. Certainly, it's plausible enough that I went along with it.
In many ways, the film reminded me of Eyes Wide Shut--it's moody, discomforting and full of subtleties. Just as I noticed shades of blue in EWS, I saw shades of red in 451. There is a surreality to the storytelling, and its visuals, that make this an uncomfortable film to watch--which, given its content, it should be. It's not a film to watch casually. I loved the spoken credits, because they were so jarring, and set the tone from the very beginning.
The DVD extras are rewarding and insightful, though it would have been nice had they included something with Truffaut himself--even archival footage with subtitles would have been nice. The full list price is only $12.98 and even at that price I would recommend it as a blind buy--but I would also advise reading the novel first.
#13
DVD Talk Hall of Fame