Review wanted: Natural Born Killers: DC vs. Stone collection
#1
Senior Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2000
Posts: 337
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Could someone compare these two versions. I ordered NBK from CH and they sent the Stone collection version, and I wanted to know if I should send it back to get the DC. I know the DC isn't anamorphic. What are the other major differences. Thanks
#2
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Posts: 2,158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The theatrical cut from the OS collection has a better transfer - however I don't know how much difference it would make if you don't have a HD television or watch it on a computer monitor. And this is not a movie you watch for hi-res visuals anyway...
Aside from that, I really prefer the Director's Cut myself. The three extra minutes give it an added edge...when you go back and watch the theatrical cut it seems like a little something is missing even when you can't put your finger on it.
The LFE is much more pronounced on the Director's Cut DVD which is another reason I prefer it. It may very well be a little overcooked, but adds impact and excitement in my opinion. I own both of them but if I had to get rid of a disc it would be the one from my OS collection.
Aside from that, I really prefer the Director's Cut myself. The three extra minutes give it an added edge...when you go back and watch the theatrical cut it seems like a little something is missing even when you can't put your finger on it.
The LFE is much more pronounced on the Director's Cut DVD which is another reason I prefer it. It may very well be a little overcooked, but adds impact and excitement in my opinion. I own both of them but if I had to get rid of a disc it would be the one from my OS collection.
#3
Senior Member
I did the opposite primarily because I wanted the Anamorphic transfer for my 16x9 set. It's much better than the DC version which has much pixelation.
Wolfchild, Why is this not a movie you watch for hi-res visuals anyway?
I think NBK is one of the most visually arresting and stimulating films of the 1990s - not to mention a great damn movie, period. I know the formats and grain changes radically throughout the entire movie which to me is all the more reason why you need the highest quailty visuals to capture them accurately.
Not starting an arguement - Just my two cents...
Wolfchild, Why is this not a movie you watch for hi-res visuals anyway?
I think NBK is one of the most visually arresting and stimulating films of the 1990s - not to mention a great damn movie, period. I know the formats and grain changes radically throughout the entire movie which to me is all the more reason why you need the highest quailty visuals to capture them accurately.
Not starting an arguement - Just my two cents...
#4
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I am wondering the same thing. I sold my DC version because the new one was coming out with the commentary, but didn't realize it would not be the DC. Now I want to get the movie again, but am torn. I really want to here OS's commentary on this movie, but really liked the extra 3 minutes added to the movie. AHHHHH!!!!
What else comes with the new S.E.???
What else comes with the new S.E.???
#5
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Chicago, Illinois
Posts: 4,174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by roseart
I am wondering the same thing. I sold my DC version because the new one was coming out with the commentary, but didn't realize it would not be the DC. Now I want to get the movie again, but am torn. I really want to here OS's commentary on this movie, but really liked the extra 3 minutes added to the movie. AHHHHH!!!!
What else comes with the new S.E.???
I am wondering the same thing. I sold my DC version because the new one was coming out with the commentary, but didn't realize it would not be the DC. Now I want to get the movie again, but am torn. I really want to here OS's commentary on this movie, but really liked the extra 3 minutes added to the movie. AHHHHH!!!!
What else comes with the new S.E.???
#6
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Feb 2001
Location: Austin, TX
Posts: 2,604
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Whoops I wasn't in to commentaries when I sold it, so I didn't even notice. Thanks MrBEAVis
P.S. One more thing, is it the same commentary, or a rerecorded one for the Box Sets???
[Edited by roseart on 05-15-01 at 05:00 PM]
P.S. One more thing, is it the same commentary, or a rerecorded one for the Box Sets???
[Edited by roseart on 05-15-01 at 05:00 PM]
#7
DVD Talk Godfather & 2020 TOTY Winner
I think it's the same commentary. The OS version has a Charley Rose interview, though.
#8
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Join Date: Jun 1999
Posts: 2,158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by TELawrence
I did the opposite primarily because I wanted the Anamorphic transfer for my 16x9 set. It's much better than the DC version which has much pixelation.
Wolfchild, Why is this not a movie you watch for hi-res visuals anyway?
I think NBK is one of the most visually arresting and stimulating films of the 1990s - not to mention a great damn movie, period. I know the formats and grain changes radically throughout the entire movie which to me is all the more reason why you need the highest quailty visuals to capture them accurately.
Not starting an arguement - Just my two cents...
I did the opposite primarily because I wanted the Anamorphic transfer for my 16x9 set. It's much better than the DC version which has much pixelation.
Wolfchild, Why is this not a movie you watch for hi-res visuals anyway?
I think NBK is one of the most visually arresting and stimulating films of the 1990s - not to mention a great damn movie, period. I know the formats and grain changes radically throughout the entire movie which to me is all the more reason why you need the highest quailty visuals to capture them accurately.
Not starting an arguement - Just my two cents...
NBK overall, in my opinion anyway, doesn't have a lot of photography with detail that's severely compromised by the non-enhanced transfer. Like I said, I KNOW the DC version doesn't look as good but it's 'good enough' once I start to watch it.
The sound on the DC definitely has loads more OOMPHH on my system. It may be perhaps an overcooked mix, but when some of the LFE hits me in the chest watching the DC, it definitely has more impact IMO. And like I said I prefer the original DVD's cut anyway. But I'm keeping both, maybe it's silly....if a person has a 16x9 set and the best picture is the most important thing, then I have to agree that the OS version is the way to go....
The DC could be a collector's item someday, who knows...
#9
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
Originally posted by Wolfchild
The DC could be a collector's item someday, who knows...
The DC could be a collector's item someday, who knows...
DJ
#11
DVD Talk Ultimate Edition
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Chicago, Illinois
Posts: 4,174
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by eXcentris
Isn't the extra footage on the DC available as deleted scenes on the OS anyway?
Isn't the extra footage on the DC available as deleted scenes on the OS anyway?
#12
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Central Jersey
Posts: 1,195
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I was upset at first that the version in the box set was not the Directors Cut. I have the DC VHS so that is what I am used to. As it turns out, there really isnt much difference. There aren't really any new scenes added back in. The main difference is that they show Dwight McKlusky's head getting ripped off (which does look pretty fake actually). Other than that, nothing is really that noticable. There all little shots here and there. So, I would go with the Theatrical Cut, primarily since it looks better, but I also really enjoyed the Charlie Rose Interview.
#14
Banned
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 10
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
side by side
The Told You So complete extras listings for each...
Director's Cut
vs.
Ollie Stone Collection
(fyi)
Chris
Director's Cut
vs.
Ollie Stone Collection
(fyi)
Chris
#15
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jul 2000
Location: Little Rock
Posts: 1,462
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by chuckd21
Here's our comparison review:
http://www.jaxfilmjournal.com/bmnbk.html
Hope that helps.
Here's our comparison review:
http://www.jaxfilmjournal.com/bmnbk.html
Hope that helps.