Trying to decide if it's worth saving $1.25 after tax to print this out and go to BB rather than just buying it from Amazon...

Yeah, I decided against using it in the end since Button isn't really a must-have for me. $3 off isn't tempting enough for me.

Same here. I'll own it eventually, and would have used the coupon if anyone had an exclusive. But I can wait for it to hit $10 or less.

Do Criterions ever get to that low of a price?

I picked up my copy at Fry's for $24.99 - $3 off = $21.99. I would have spent just that, but they had a bunch of Blu Ray titles for $9.99 that were too tempting.

I have about 50 Criterions for which I've paid $10 or less.

I apologize about my post on the first page, but I thought that the coupon would strictly be for the Paramount single-disc DVD and Criterion 2-disc BD.

I found a coupon myself and used it for the 2-disc DVD. Works fine.

I think odds are very good that a mainstream Criterion will be very inexpensive at some point in the future. Look at Royal Tenenbaums for an example.

Coupons.com now has the coupon available to print out (still expires 5/19), so no one else has to pursue the double-issue of People to get it.