Where are you buying Star Wars - non SEs?
#26
For under $14 I'd pick 'em up. I'm keeping the SE set too. That BB tin is nice, but not worth the extra $$$. Now Paul Champgane needs to make a Episode I-VI box (which I'm sure exists, just haven't checked on it awhile)
#30
Member
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 64
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
On Sunday looking at the ads and on the net -
Circuit City is the winner at $14.99.
Best Buy is $16.99
Target is $17.87
WalMart is $19.96
maybe the Walmart will change on sales day, I don't know, I don't shop there enough to do their practices, but please someone post it they do change it.
Without the limited edition tin, CC looks to be the best best, and they DO have the lithographs, even though they will probably be pretty cheezy...
Paul
Circuit City is the winner at $14.99.
Best Buy is $16.99
Target is $17.87
WalMart is $19.96
maybe the Walmart will change on sales day, I don't know, I don't shop there enough to do their practices, but please someone post it they do change it.
Without the limited edition tin, CC looks to be the best best, and they DO have the lithographs, even though they will probably be pretty cheezy...
Paul
#31
DVD Talk Gold Edition
Joined: Mar 2005
Posts: 2,116
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by phephron
On Sunday looking at the ads and on the net -
Circuit City is the winner at $14.99.
Best Buy is $16.99
Target is $17.87
WalMart is $19.96
maybe the Walmart will change on sales day, I don't know, I don't shop there enough to do their practices, but please someone post it they do change it.
Without the limited edition tin, CC looks to be the best best, and they DO have the lithographs, even though they will probably be pretty cheezy...
Paul
Circuit City is the winner at $14.99.
Best Buy is $16.99
Target is $17.87
WalMart is $19.96
maybe the Walmart will change on sales day, I don't know, I don't shop there enough to do their practices, but please someone post it they do change it.
Without the limited edition tin, CC looks to be the best best, and they DO have the lithographs, even though they will probably be pretty cheezy...
Paul
#34
DVD Talk Limited Edition
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 5,512
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by GorillaX
there's no disc art on the original versions? I'm looking at the CC ad, it shows 2 discs, one of them is just plain with no artwork on it
#35
Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NC
Just to let everyone know, the tin at Best Buy is not as nice and you might suspect. It looks exactly like those tins you get for 12.99 at BB that have movies on Airplanes and such... To me it felt kinda cheap and thin and would look odd sitting in a collection do to its odd size...
#37
Member
Joined: Jan 2006
Posts: 231
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by TruBuffyFan
Just to let everyone know, the tin at Best Buy is not as nice and you might suspect. It looks exactly like those tins you get for 12.99 at BB that have movies on Airplanes and such... To me it felt kinda cheap and thin and would look odd sitting in a collection do to its odd size...
#38
DVD Talk Legend
I'm sure that a nice 6-movie set will be coming out in the near future, probably in '07 to coincide with the 30th anniversary of the first (fourth) movie.
I'll be waiting for that one.
I'll be waiting for that one.
#39
DVD Talk Legend
Originally Posted by JoN8282
saw the bby tin in person - it's very nice... i'll be getting that 

#40
Member
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by GorillaX
there's no disc art on the original versions? I'm looking at the CC ad, it shows 2 discs, one of them is just plain with no artwork on it
Disc Art
Originally Posted by TruBuffyFan
Just to let everyone know, the tin at Best Buy is not as nice and you might suspect. It looks exactly like those tins you get for 12.99 at BB that have movies on Airplanes and such... To me it felt kinda cheap and thin and would look odd sitting in a collection do to its odd size...
It's also worth noting that most of the film collections packaged in those generic tins can usually be found in cardboard packaging for around $6.99. So why such a huge markup for the SW tin?
#41
Originally Posted by poirot
The Jedi disc looks cool, but it's odd to see the films labeled as a "Bonus Disc", when they're the only reason anyone is buying.
Furthermore, I'm thinking the original versions are being marketed this way so that Lucas can have his cake and eat it, too. If sales suck, he can claim that he was right and no one was interested in the originals except a few vocal fans. And if sales are great, he can tell himself that people were buying these sets for his glorious re-imagined versions and not the tacked-on extras.
#42
Member
Joined: Aug 2006
Posts: 55
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Preterite
If sales suck, he can claim that he was right and no one was interested in the originals except a few vocal fans.
#43
Member
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 179
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: NC
Originally Posted by Obi-Jon Kenobi
Could you be a little more descriptive? What $12.99 tins are you talking about? Are the star wars dvds in thier own respective dvd cases inside of the tin?
#44
Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 188
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
From: New York
Well it looks like preordering the tin at 89.99 did me good...For some reason when they shipped it they knocked it down to 52.99. This comes out to be 17.66 each. I know they are selling the individual double discs for 16.99 so it only cost me $2.01 extra for the tn.
1 Star Wars Set W/Tin-DVD-Star Wars Set W/Tin SKU: 7970715 $52.99
I checked the tin listing and it is still showing it at 59.99 so I don't know if they will knock it down on release day tomorrow or this is just a nice perk for those of us that preordered it at the crazy 89.99 price.
Whatever happened I'm even happier now that I only paid 2 bucks for the nice tin set.
1 Star Wars Set W/Tin-DVD-Star Wars Set W/Tin SKU: 7970715 $52.99
I checked the tin listing and it is still showing it at 59.99 so I don't know if they will knock it down on release day tomorrow or this is just a nice perk for those of us that preordered it at the crazy 89.99 price.
Whatever happened I'm even happier now that I only paid 2 bucks for the nice tin set.
#45
DVD Talk Platinum Edition
If I was to buy, it would be the BB tin. I assume it is like the Band of Brothers tin which I like alot.
But I am happy with the SE versions, so I will just hold out for the HD-DVD version.
But I am happy with the SE versions, so I will just hold out for the HD-DVD version.
#48
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Joined: Jul 2000
Posts: 9,380
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
From: In a small pocket universe hoping to someday become a Moderator Emeritus at DVDTalk.com!
Originally Posted by DarthScooby
Well it looks like preordering the tin at 89.99 did me good...For some reason when they shipped it they knocked it down to 52.99. This comes out to be 17.66 each. I know they are selling the individual double discs for 16.99 so it only cost me $2.01 extra for the tn.
1 Star Wars Set W/Tin-DVD-Star Wars Set W/Tin SKU: 7970715 $52.99
I checked the tin listing and it is still showing it at 59.99 so I don't know if they will knock it down on release day tomorrow or this is just a nice perk for those of us that preordered it at the crazy 89.99 price.
Whatever happened I'm even happier now that I only paid 2 bucks for the nice tin set.
1 Star Wars Set W/Tin-DVD-Star Wars Set W/Tin SKU: 7970715 $52.99
I checked the tin listing and it is still showing it at 59.99 so I don't know if they will knock it down on release day tomorrow or this is just a nice perk for those of us that preordered it at the crazy 89.99 price.
Whatever happened I'm even happier now that I only paid 2 bucks for the nice tin set.
#49
Originally Posted by Anubis2005X
I'm sure they have disc art. As for myself, Netflix it is. I refuse to pay money for Star Wars again until the 30th anniversay edition comes out next year. Maybe I'll even wait for the high-def versions...
Interestingly, I had all 3 at the top of my queue (after The Wild) and my next batch of discs shipped today. They shipped The Wild, but for some reason skipped over sending me any of the Star Wars DVDs and sent old catalog titles. Did they skip over Star Wars for anyone else?
#50
DVD Talk Legend
Looks like Circuit City is going to have the best price on these. All the Wal-marts in my area are stating $19.86 each and they won't price match unless the price in in the ad (and all the other ads just state "Low Price"). They also advised that they cannot price match by calling Circuit City or any other stores.



