The One And Only Star Wars Pre-Order/Bargain Thread
#126
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by NCYankee
Why would they expend a lot of effort to sell it BELOW COST and make no money?
Why would they expend a lot of effort to sell it BELOW COST and make no money?
It's a rare person who walks into, say, Best Buy to grab Star Wars and just leaves immediately. People wander. People pick up items they didn't intend to. And some people will sit there with Star Wars in their hands and think "You know, my 27 inch TV sucks and I've been meaning to replace it. Maybe I'll go look at those flat screen plasma thingies I've been thinking about."
It doesn't take too many customers buying new speakers or TVs to make up for losing a couple of bucks on a DVD box set that everyone and their monkey is selling for cheap anyway...
#127
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by bboisvert
It's a rare person who walks into, say, Best Buy to grab Star Wars and just leaves immediately.
It's a rare person who walks into, say, Best Buy to grab Star Wars and just leaves immediately.
Last edited by NCYankee; 07-06-04 at 10:30 AM.
#128
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by NCYankee
I guess that's my point - the kind of person who spends his time searching out the cheapest deal on a DVD set like this one WILL come in, grab the set and go - because if they are like me, they will need to get over to the competitor's store and get THEIR best DVD deals for that week. Deal chasers are not typically browsers.
I guess that's my point - the kind of person who spends his time searching out the cheapest deal on a DVD set like this one WILL come in, grab the set and go - because if they are like me, they will need to get over to the competitor's store and get THEIR best DVD deals for that week. Deal chasers are not typically browsers.
however, advertisements do help. If let's say Best Buy and Circuit City are in the same shopping complex, the shopper would probably go to the cheaper store since the effort in going to either store is exactly the same. That shopper will then buy everything that they need in that store at whatever price the store that they're in charges (most ppl don't price match). Walmart is notorious for doing this. They have a huge sale on let's say diapers or soda and ppl will go into that store to buy that cheap item and in the process buy other stuff where Walmart makes a profit. Naturally, some ppl may only buy the loss leader but that percentage is small. So if let's say 5% only buy the loss leader whereas 95% of the customers buy other stuff and 25% of that 95% buys something with a huge profit margin, then the loss leader effectively did its job.
#129
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Yes, I agree that Walmart is a notorious loss leader user - as I pointed out in regards to their gas pricing. The difference is, there are a lot of things people need on a daily basis at Walmart. While someone is there, they will probably grab some toothpaste, motor oil, Lysol, etc.
There is a big difference when it comes to DVDs - someone does not just walk into Best Buy and say "Well, while I am here getting this $20 DVD, I might as well buy a $3000 HDTV or a $1500 laptop". Bigger ticket items there are not impulse buys or staples.
As was mentioned before, some stores try to set up a pattern of buying there - FYE is a good example, with their constant $10 rebates on new releases. The thing is - they are using the mundane week-to-week releases to get you into the pattern of shopping there, hoping you will buy the bigger sets such as Star Wars when they come out. This trilogy is the end, not the means.
Look at the IJ TRilogy - it came out in late October, but FYE did not do their killer $25 rebate deal until 2 months later. They did not relegate it to loss leader status until the excitement over its initial release had worn off and the retail money had been made.
There is a big difference when it comes to DVDs - someone does not just walk into Best Buy and say "Well, while I am here getting this $20 DVD, I might as well buy a $3000 HDTV or a $1500 laptop". Bigger ticket items there are not impulse buys or staples.
As was mentioned before, some stores try to set up a pattern of buying there - FYE is a good example, with their constant $10 rebates on new releases. The thing is - they are using the mundane week-to-week releases to get you into the pattern of shopping there, hoping you will buy the bigger sets such as Star Wars when they come out. This trilogy is the end, not the means.
Look at the IJ TRilogy - it came out in late October, but FYE did not do their killer $25 rebate deal until 2 months later. They did not relegate it to loss leader status until the excitement over its initial release had worn off and the retail money had been made.
Last edited by NCYankee; 07-06-04 at 11:46 AM.
#130
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
This is regarding the tax FYE.com is charging to most states. I don't know about other states , but NC allows you to deduct any taxes you have paid on out-of-state mail-order purchases from your "consumer use tax", which is an estimate gotten by
AGI * .065%
So I will be able to directly deduct the $3.50 sales tax FYE is charging me on my Star Wars trilogy pre-order from my NC State income tax. This makes it a better deal for me than Amazon with STL, which is $37.xx.
So those of you making a lot of mail-order buys might want to keep track of things like that.
AGI * .065%
So I will be able to directly deduct the $3.50 sales tax FYE is charging me on my Star Wars trilogy pre-order from my NC State income tax. This makes it a better deal for me than Amazon with STL, which is $37.xx.
So those of you making a lot of mail-order buys might want to keep track of things like that.
#131
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by NCYankee
Yes, I agree that Walmart is a notorious loss leader user - as I pointed out in regards to their gas pricing. The difference is, there are a lot of things people need on a daily basis at Walmart. While someone is there, they will probably grab some toothpaste, motor oil, Lysol, etc.
There is a big difference when it comes to DVDs - someone does not just walk into Best Buy and say "Well, while I am here getting this $20 DVD, I might as well buy a $3000 HDTV or a $1500 laptop". Bigger ticket items there are not impulse buys or staples.
As was mentioned before, some stores try to set up a pattern of buying there - FYE is a good example, with their constant $10 rebates on new releases. The thing is - they are using the mundane week-to-week releases to get you into the pattern of shopping there, hoping you will buy the bigger sets such as Star Wars when they come out. This trilogy is the end, not the means.
Look at the IJ TRilogy - it came out in late October, but FYE did not do their killer $25 rebate deal until 2 months later. They did not relegate it to loss leader status until the excitement over its initial release had worn off and the retail money had been made.
Yes, I agree that Walmart is a notorious loss leader user - as I pointed out in regards to their gas pricing. The difference is, there are a lot of things people need on a daily basis at Walmart. While someone is there, they will probably grab some toothpaste, motor oil, Lysol, etc.
There is a big difference when it comes to DVDs - someone does not just walk into Best Buy and say "Well, while I am here getting this $20 DVD, I might as well buy a $3000 HDTV or a $1500 laptop". Bigger ticket items there are not impulse buys or staples.
As was mentioned before, some stores try to set up a pattern of buying there - FYE is a good example, with their constant $10 rebates on new releases. The thing is - they are using the mundane week-to-week releases to get you into the pattern of shopping there, hoping you will buy the bigger sets such as Star Wars when they come out. This trilogy is the end, not the means.
Look at the IJ TRilogy - it came out in late October, but FYE did not do their killer $25 rebate deal until 2 months later. They did not relegate it to loss leader status until the excitement over its initial release had worn off and the retail money had been made.
Now, when you go to Walmart, 95% of the customers (I initially typed employees by mistake) will buy items other than the loss leader that's being advertised. However, as noted above, the total profit on one of those items is small and you must get lots of ppl being that item for the loss leader to be effective.
Now with a store such as Best Buy, 95% of the customers will at least buy something else whether it be another DVD or a CD. Total profit on those items is small but if 95% of the customers are buying those small items it adds up like it does with Walmart. Now, let's say 25% of the customers buy mid-level items such as a $200 stereo or a $300 printer. The total profit on those items is higher and and about 33% (I'm just estimating that figure...it's probably much higher) of those ppl will buy a Best Buy extended warranty on those products which have big profit margins. Finally, about 1% of those ppl buying the loss leader DVD will buy a big $2000 - $5000 item such as a plasma TV, which will have large profit, and typically when someone buys a very expensive item, they will also buy the extended warranty (I'm assuming over 75%).
Another point about mail-in-rebate items that stores such as FYE sell, is that only about 30% or so of rebates are actually paid out (most customers don't even send in the rebate or they send it in incorrectly so that the rebate house doesn't have to pay it out). Despite this, the store can still advertise the $19.99 item as $9.99 (with the after MIR in really small font) and the customer will subconsciously see the item as being $9.99. So in reality, items like these aren't huge loss leaders for a company. Also, most customers that frequent a store such as FYE, aren't bargain hunters; they will pay MSRP for DVDs ($29.99) and CDs ($18.99) without even blinking.
Last edited by Dabaomb; 07-06-04 at 01:10 PM.
#132
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by NCYankee
This is regarding the tax FYE.com is charging to most states. I don't know about other states , but NC allows you to deduct any taxes you have paid on out-of-state mail-order purchases from your "consumer use tax", which is an estimate gotten by
AGI * .065%
So I will be able to directly deduct the $3.50 sales tax FYE is charging me on my Star Wars trilogy pre-order from my NC State income tax. This makes it a better deal for me than Amazon with STL, which is $37.xx.
So those of you making a lot of mail-order buys might want to keep track of things like that.
This is regarding the tax FYE.com is charging to most states. I don't know about other states , but NC allows you to deduct any taxes you have paid on out-of-state mail-order purchases from your "consumer use tax", which is an estimate gotten by
AGI * .065%
So I will be able to directly deduct the $3.50 sales tax FYE is charging me on my Star Wars trilogy pre-order from my NC State income tax. This makes it a better deal for me than Amazon with STL, which is $37.xx.
So those of you making a lot of mail-order buys might want to keep track of things like that.
#133
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Dabaomb
I don't know of any states that do this and I'm pretty sure that New York isn't one of them so New York will be taking the 8.625% tax that it charges me. Plus, deducting $3.00 is sometimes more hassle than it's worth.
I don't know of any states that do this and I'm pretty sure that New York isn't one of them so New York will be taking the 8.625% tax that it charges me. Plus, deducting $3.00 is sometimes more hassle than it's worth.
Last edited by NCYankee; 07-06-04 at 01:02 PM.
#134
DVD Talk Hall of Fame
Originally posted by NCYankee
Well, you know of one - NC. There are probably others, but hardly anyone reads the line instructions. And it is not a deduction, it is a direct credit (you deduct it from the CU tax, not from your income). And it is no trouble at all if you can use a calculator - you just figure the consumer use tax (which you must do anyway), then subtract $3.50.
Well, you know of one - NC. There are probably others, but hardly anyone reads the line instructions. And it is not a deduction, it is a direct credit (you deduct it from the CU tax, not from your income). And it is no trouble at all if you can use a calculator - you just figure the consumer use tax (which you must do anyway), then subtract $3.50.
also, these posts have nothing to do with Star Wars pre-orders.
#135
DVD Talk Legend
Originally posted by NCYankee
I guess that's my point - the kind of person who spends his time searching out the cheapest deal on a DVD set like this one WILL come in, grab the set and go - because if they are like me, they will need to get over to the competitor's store and get THEIR best DVD deals for that week. Deal chasers are not typically browsers.
I guess that's my point - the kind of person who spends his time searching out the cheapest deal on a DVD set like this one WILL come in, grab the set and go - because if they are like me, they will need to get over to the competitor's store and get THEIR best DVD deals for that week. Deal chasers are not typically browsers.
What is much more likely is Joe Sixpack or Jane Boxwine opening up their Sunday circular, seeing Star Wars for $45 at Best Buy and thinking "Great price, I'll have to stop by later in the week." Then, once in the store, Best Buy hopes to be able to gain larger purchases (TVs, PCs, audio equipment, appliances, whatever).
That's a LOT more likely than deal chasers who use STL, multiple DDD coupons, or spend all day Tuesday driving around town to save 20 cents on the latest new releases.
Also, if having a great price on a big release like Star Wars builds up some sort of brand loyalty -- even a subliminal sense that Best Buy has great prices on new DVDs -- than it'll be worth a lot more than the meager profit they could have made pricing the set a bit higher.
#136
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Dabaomb
this post has a very condescending tone directed towards me. with that, no more responses to your posts from me cuz you won't look at other opinions rationally.
also, these posts have nothing to do with Star Wars pre-orders.
this post has a very condescending tone directed towards me. with that, no more responses to your posts from me cuz you won't look at other opinions rationally.
also, these posts have nothing to do with Star Wars pre-orders.
If my tone seemed condescending, it wasn't intended to be - but your last post seemed dismissive of my previous post, basically as though you suspected that I didn't know what I was talking about, so I may have been a bit smart-ass. Sorry.
(Been doing my own taxes for 17 years, I know how to wring every last dime out of a refund check)
Last edited by NCYankee; 07-06-04 at 01:29 PM.
#137
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by bboisvert
As mentioned, "deal chasers" like you (and me!) are a rare breed. They are not a significant number for stores to really worry about.
What is much more likely is Joe Sixpack or Jane Boxwine opening up their Sunday circular, seeing Star Wars for $45 at Best Buy and thinking "Great price, I'll have to stop by later in the week." Then, once in the store, Best Buy hopes to be able to gain larger purchases (TVs, PCs, audio equipment, appliances, whatever).
As mentioned, "deal chasers" like you (and me!) are a rare breed. They are not a significant number for stores to really worry about.
What is much more likely is Joe Sixpack or Jane Boxwine opening up their Sunday circular, seeing Star Wars for $45 at Best Buy and thinking "Great price, I'll have to stop by later in the week." Then, once in the store, Best Buy hopes to be able to gain larger purchases (TVs, PCs, audio equipment, appliances, whatever).
My whole point is that some people are sitting on their hands waiting to see what deals will come - but I doubt any in-store deal is going to beat FYE's pre-order deal, at least not at release time.
Last edited by NCYankee; 07-06-04 at 01:51 PM.
#141
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I would rather rush and get it now for $25 (actually, $28 after tax) from FYE with the preorder rebate and free $10 gift card w/$50 card purchase.
Last edited by NCYankee; 08-30-04 at 04:01 PM.
#143
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Mar 2002
Location: Chattanooga, TN
Posts: 1,555
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"I would rather rush and get it now for $25 (actually, $28 after tax) from FYE with the preorder rebate and free $10 gift card w/$50 card purchase."
That's what I did. Seems to be the best price that I can find so far.
That's what I did. Seems to be the best price that I can find so far.
#144
Cool New Member
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 19
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Is the FYE deal done in-store, or online? I noticed you can buy gift cards through their web site, but I'm not sure you can use them on the web site. Nor did I see the free $10 gift card offer there.
#147
Senior Member
Join Date: Nov 2001
Posts: 273
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can anyone STL me the starwar preorder? thank you, I want to buy it from Amazon to save me from all the trouble going through rebate or drive to Wherehouse. Thank you
[email protected]
[email protected]
#148
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: Cicely, AK
Posts: 1,487
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by NCYankee
Actually, it DOES have something to do with the Star Wars pre-orders - I had seen someone mention that they were unhappy with FYE.com charging sales tax, this is a way in which you get it back later. WITH tax, FYE.com is higher than Amazon w/STL - but if you discount the tax, it is a couple bucks cheaper. Of course, they would have to look at their own state's regs, but it should be in the instruction booklet. I don't even know if other states have a CU tax - I am pretty sure NC just started it within the last few years - but with the increasing online sales, I would imagine it will become pretty common.
(Been doing my own taxes for 17 years, I know how to wring every last dime out of a refund check)
Actually, it DOES have something to do with the Star Wars pre-orders - I had seen someone mention that they were unhappy with FYE.com charging sales tax, this is a way in which you get it back later. WITH tax, FYE.com is higher than Amazon w/STL - but if you discount the tax, it is a couple bucks cheaper. Of course, they would have to look at their own state's regs, but it should be in the instruction booklet. I don't even know if other states have a CU tax - I am pretty sure NC just started it within the last few years - but with the increasing online sales, I would imagine it will become pretty common.
(Been doing my own taxes for 17 years, I know how to wring every last dime out of a refund check)
#150
DVD Talk Special Edition
Join Date: Jun 2004
Location: Durham, NC
Posts: 1,187
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally posted by Lecithin
I am a NC taxpayer and the Consumer Use tax they put on the state tax form is pretty much ignored by most taxpayers. The few who actually claim any of the purchases they made online so they can pay the state tax on them usually opt for the flat rate of about $19 rather than actually provide receipts and and listing each and every purchase made online for that year. And even for those that choose to (or are required to because they bought $1000 or more online), they are only supposed to list the items they bought that did NOT have state sales tax added in the first place so I don't see how you would be able to "get back" the tax id you never listed it in the first place.
I am a NC taxpayer and the Consumer Use tax they put on the state tax form is pretty much ignored by most taxpayers. The few who actually claim any of the purchases they made online so they can pay the state tax on them usually opt for the flat rate of about $19 rather than actually provide receipts and and listing each and every purchase made online for that year. And even for those that choose to (or are required to because they bought $1000 or more online), they are only supposed to list the items they bought that did NOT have state sales tax added in the first place so I don't see how you would be able to "get back" the tax id you never listed it in the first place.
There is NO "flat tax" - the estimate is .065% of yor AGI, try reading the directions before correcting someone who actually does read them.
Last edited by NCYankee; 09-04-04 at 11:59 AM.