DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Comic Book Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk-57/)
-   -   December's Let's Talk Comics and Nothing Else Thread (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/comic-book-talk/447194-decembers-lets-talk-comics-nothing-else-thread.html)

MBoyd 12-01-05 01:57 PM

Well here is James' list . . . I'm sure most will come up with better stuff than I will. I only read the comic equivalent of pop music anyway.

Best On-Going Title
The Ultimates count in this section?

Best Mini
I want to say Infinite Crisis, but since it's not completed how about Villains United.

Best Collected Trade
Looks like it's going to be Absolute Crisis on Infinite Earths

Best Original Graphic Novel
Gotta leave it blank.

Publisher of the Year
DC hands down.

Writer of the Year
Geoff Johns for his hand in reshaping the DCU

Artist of the Year
I'm digging the art in Infinite Crisis so far so how about Phil Jiminez

Chew 12-01-05 02:07 PM


Originally Posted by James W. Powell
For those who have read the original Crisis that is an Absolute book now:

1) Is it "worth" $65+ if the Absolute version doesn't include crossovers?
2) Will someone who only knows a tiny bit about the old DC characters understand the story?
3) Are there other versions of the book that would be considered a better value?

1) IMO, the series is pretty well self-contained. You won't really need the crossovers. They flesh out the story more than anything. Just like the current "Crisis".
2) I don't think you're going to have nearly as much appreciation of the story and it's actual affect on the DC universe if all you've ever read is "post-Crisis" stuff. That doesn't change the fact that it's a good read.
3) Yeah, my tpb copy. :lol:

I would stop reading Infinite Crisis right now since you plan on reading CoIE. You'll appreciate both better. :)

The Antipodean 12-01-05 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by dadaluholla
Anyone pick up Tales Designed To Thrizzle by Michael Kupperman? He did that Snake N Bacon book. There is some funny funny stuff in there. I think its from Fantagraphics.

Yeah, I love his work. The <a href="http://www.amazon.com/exec/obidos/ASIN/0380807904/104-2610773-5272736">Snake and Bacon's Cartoon Cabaret</a> is fantastic, and "Thrizzle" (despite the awful title) is good so far. The guy has such a skewed sense of humor, but it works ("The adventures of ... The Manister! Half man, half banister!")

Rocketdog2000 12-01-05 09:16 PM

Ok...

Best On-Going Title
JSA

Best Mini
Villians United, since it's too early to say Infinite Crisis. That, or Green Lantern:Rebirth.

Best Collected Trade
Out of one's I bought... Batman/Superman:Supergirl or New Teen Titans:Who is Donna Troy?

Best Original Graphic Novel
didn't read any 'original' ones this year.

Publisher of the Year
DC - without a doubt

Writer of the Year
Geoff Johns

Artist of the Year
Tough call, but I think I'll give it to Ethan Van Sciver for his (always) excellent work on Green Lantern:Rebirth, and the current ongoing series.

MBoyd 12-01-05 11:01 PM

Just checked my DCBS order on DHL's site - comes in at a whopping 21 pounds!

Chew 12-02-05 06:01 AM

Delayed shipment email still didn't stop it from arriving on the regular day! :banana:

Edit: by far my lowest DCBS order total last night, only $75! Not much of interest coming out that month, I guess.

ytrez 12-02-05 07:27 AM

Haven't read any new releases but I did read the 1st collection of the new Black Panther series. I wasn't too impressed by the writing though some of the ideas were good. Romita Jr. & Janson their usual good work.

I just cracked open the Spirit Archives Vol. 1 and am excited about that. I've read the Spirit at various times through Kitchen Sink's reprints over the years but never got to go all the way back to the beginning. Can't wait to dive in.

bishop2knight 12-03-05 07:54 AM


Originally Posted by MBoyd
I think the 1.49 button is used if you want to order more than 2 copies. If you want the two covers you can use the .75 button and get both.

This is the correct answer. You order two of 'em, you use the .75 button. You order any more than that, you start using the 1.49 button too.

There's not other covers on this one.

Graftenberg 12-03-05 08:11 AM

After using Mile High Comics for about 5 years I'm switching over to DCBS after having heard so much about it here and checking out their prices I just couldn't pass it up. :up:

MBoyd 12-03-05 08:45 AM

Way to go. I don't think you will regret it.

kevin75 12-03-05 08:52 AM

yeah, mile high doesn't hold the appeal for me it once did. since they took away the big discounts on their collected editions and started charging shipping per book, it takes away any good deal. and their individual comics prices are so jacked up usually that that kills that too.

lukewarmwater 12-03-05 12:12 PM

Best On-Going Title
TIE
Solo
Usagi Yojimbo

Best Mini
TIE
We3
Smoke

Best Collected Trade
We3

Best Original Graphic Novel
TIE
Black Hole
Scott Pilgrim

Publisher of the Year
Vertigo

Writer of the Year
Grant Morrison

Artist of the Year
James Jean

Favorite Single Issue
Fell #2

Favorite New Series
Fell

Comic Most Deserving of More Attention
Usagi Yojimbo

Favorite Online Comic
Penny Arcade

Favorite Cover Artist
James Jean

Favorite Talent Deserving Wider Attention
TIE
Stan Sakai
Kyle Baker

bishop2knight 12-03-05 02:52 PM

For those still leary of DCBS, here’s a breakdown of my latest DCBS order. I'm doing this to show you what kind of discounts you might expect. Your results may vary, but the more you buy, the more you save.


Total comics purchased - 31 (plus one trade at 50% off)
Total cover price - $115.04
Total DCBS price before shipping - $68.32
Plus monthly shipping ($7.95) - $76.27
Plus twice a month shipping ($4) - $80.27

Total payment for comics this month: $80.27
Total cover price - $115.04
Total savings - $34.77 (I also add mylites/full-back combos, which are 50 cents each)

So after shipping, I save a little more than $1 per book. At Mile High (my LCS), I generally save about 20 - 35 cents a book on my pull list. So on this order, my Mile High cost would be about $107 (or a bit more). So I save about $27 or more by using DCBS.

That's not a huge savings. But that $27 sure goes a long way to buying other comics or going out with my wife or whatever. And since I'm on a monthly budget for all of my spending, any savings is a very good thing.

Graftenberg 12-03-05 03:08 PM

For the order I got from Mile High last month I had 28 books for a total with shipping of $83.87.

The order I just placed today I ordered 45 books + bags and boards with shipping: $95.85.:banana:

innocentfreak 12-03-05 04:31 PM

Ugh I am so tempted to get back into comics but I got into the bad habit of buying without reading. I am sure I still have books laying around I haven't read.

Is there anywhere I can just get a previews shipped to me? I would love to browse and see if there are any titles that even interest me. The problem I have is the local shop is a good distance away to browse or even pick one up.

MBoyd 12-03-05 04:46 PM

http://www.dcbservice.com/ has the same synopsis Previews does with every title. Browse around their site.

Fincher Fan 12-03-05 11:29 PM

I used to be a big X-fan back in the day but hadn't looked at an issue in some time. I saw a copy of Uncanny #466 recently and flicked through it which brings me to my next point. What the fuck is wrong with the artwork?! Seriously! It looks like they gave a coked-up child a box of crayons. The proportions of the characters are all wrong and not in the good, exaggerated-breasts sense. The colours are all round just horrible. This book looks like shit. Is this a temporary thing or is the way the book has been looking for a while?

bishop2knight 12-04-05 08:37 AM

I actually like Bachalo's art. Bought this issue just to enjoy it in fact. To each his own I suppose.

JasonF 12-05-05 01:17 AM


Originally Posted by Fincher Fan
I used to be a big X-fan back in the day but hadn't looked at an issue in some time. I saw a copy of Uncanny #466 recently and flicked through it which brings me to my next point. What the fuck is wrong with the artwork?! Seriously! It looks like they gave a coked-up child a box of crayons. The proportions of the characters are all wrong and not in the good, exaggerated-breasts sense. The colours are all round just horrible. This book looks like shit. Is this a temporary thing or is the way the book has been looking for a while?

What's "Back in the Day?" When I think of X-Men, I think Dave Cockrum and John Byrne (even though I didn't start reading until later). I read when guys like Silvestri and Lee were drawing and liked them at the time, but like their X-Men work less now that I look back on it. On the other hand, I hated John Romita Jr. when I was a kid and love him now. And then after I stopped reading, you had guys like Joe Madieura (never liked him) and Andy Kubert (he was good) and Carlos Pacheco (I think his X-Men stuff was terrible, but I like his work on Avengers Forever that he was doing at about the same time. Go figure.)

As for Bacchalo, I haven't seen his X-Men stuff, but I enjoyed his run on Shade the Changing Man from about 15 years ago. Definitely not to everyone's taste, though.

Have you checked out Astonishing X-Men? That has art by John Cassady, who's got a clean-line style that's very different from Bacchalo's.

Giantrobo 12-05-05 04:01 AM

With all due respect to my comic loving brothers here....

Can we make a seperate thread for all the <b>Online Comics Store</b> shi...stuff?

I mean I hardly come in here anymore because this is all the "Monthly comic threads" have become...."Look how much I saved!"..."My package..(he he he ;) )...Was 29 lbs this month!!"..."I spent $12,000 on comics this month, I saved $3,000 thanks to XXXXcomicstore.com, and I also saved 75% on my car insurance by switching to GIECO!!!" Ok, that last one was a joke. But you know what I mean.

All the talk of heroes, stories, and other stuff directly related to comics is just a sidebar at this point.

Rogue588 12-05-05 04:11 AM

It could be worse.

We could be talking sports. :p

But, i'm glad i'm not the only one thinking that. Then again, perhaps we should have two separate threads...one for people who get their stuff monthly through the mail and the other for those of us that buy our stuff weekly. Actually, that'd probably be a bad idea. Wouldn't want to clog up Book Talk :D

TheBang 12-05-05 05:25 AM

Continued from last month's thread...


Originally Posted by ytrez
Michael Golden did some amazing Batman (and related) work way back when.

Really? I had no idea. I'll have to look that stuff up. There's another great talent I wish were still in the biz.


Originally Posted by ytrez
I was also a big fan of Shawn Martinbrough on Detective.

Good call. I was disappointed when Dixon and Nolan left 'Tec. But then I really enjoyed Rucka and Martinbrough's run. I liked the experimental color scheme. It certainly made it stand out.

TheBang 12-05-05 05:28 AM


Originally Posted by Movie Exchange
Not a major spoiler, as it won't be permanent. A long-running franchise book like Spider-Man will never have a major permanent change to it that would affect marketed properties.

Tell that to this guy:

http://www.comicboards.com/interview...uperman123.jpg

Chew 12-05-05 06:28 AM

Has anybody else been reading Fell?

Issue #3 was another good story. Well worth the $1.99 cover price.

bishop2knight 12-05-05 07:15 AM

I missed the boat. I finally got around to reading The Dark Knight Returns and you know, I wasn't terribly impressed. I'm thinking this was groundbreaking stuff back in the day. But now, after years of "dark" comics, the book was pretty much ho hum. And pretty poorly drawn to boot.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:24 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.