DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24) (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/658993-mlb-show-24-3-19-24-a.html)

Sonny Corinthos 02-29-24 12:00 PM

MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

It doesn't appear to be any major changes in this year's version of the game.


Decker 02-29-24 12:11 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
Game Pass, Day One available!
Will definitely fire up some Ohtani/Yamamoto Dodgers.

nickdawgy 02-29-24 12:46 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
I’ll probably be the Dodgers for the first time as well. After I trade Trout there :lol:

Noonan 02-29-24 12:54 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
I wish Sony would put these on PSN+ at launch like Game Pass. I would never play a baseball game enough to justify a purchase but I always get the itch to try one when Spring rolls around.

DJariya 02-29-24 12:58 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
MLB games just take so much time. Sometimes a full game can take up to 3 hours. I used to love playing MLB games but with no clock it’s such a huge time investment for sports games.

Noonan 02-29-24 01:44 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
This is cool to see,


Maxflier 02-29-24 02:00 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
With Shohei gone, I'll likely pass as my interest in baseball went by the wayside with him.

Rival11 02-29-24 02:23 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
I thought 23 was great (never understand the amount of people who complained about it).

I loved recreating the '87 Yankees roster and playing with them - a lot of people also downloaded my team as well :)

This looks great as well.

Decker 02-29-24 02:54 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Maxflier (Post 14394562)
With Shohei gone, I'll likely pass as my interest in baseball went by the wayside with him.

I don't understand this. He's not gone, he's just on a different team this year. He's still playable, right?

nickdawgy 02-29-24 03:15 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 14394582)
I don't understand this. He's not gone, he's just on a different team this year. He's still playable, right?

I think he means baseball isn’t fun with Ohtani gone from Anaheim, so the game isn’t fun.

Noonan 02-29-24 03:15 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 14394582)
I don't understand this. He's not gone, he's just on a different team this year. He's still playable, right?

He's in the gameplay trailer in the first post. Sure hope he's playable. Also, can't you just trade him to any team you want if you're playing franchise mode or whatever it's called in this game?

Maxflier 02-29-24 03:20 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by nickdawgy (Post 14394593)
I think he means baseball isn’t fun with Ohtani gone from Anaheim, so the game isn’t fun.

Exactly.

Decker 02-29-24 03:23 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
Exactly. Plus it you like playing Ohtani, having him on a better team would be even more fun. You could totally trade him back the Halos if you want. I assume you could make him pitch as well, right?

Maxflier 02-29-24 03:46 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
It’s more that I don’t give a shit about baseball anymore period since he left.

Decker 02-29-24 04:00 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Maxflier (Post 14394605)
It’s more that I don’t give a shit about baseball anymore period since he left.

I'm sorry to hear that. I look forward to see how he performs in an MLB post-season for the first time.

Sonny Corinthos 03-01-24 07:31 AM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
Congratulations Mookie, Freddie and Shohei on being part of the exclusive MLB The Show 24 Diamond Club.


nickdawgy 03-01-24 01:21 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Decker (Post 14394609)
I'm sorry to hear that. I look forward to see how he performs in an MLB post-season for the first time.

So do I. Which is why I’m hoping the Angels tank again and somehow the Dodgers get Trout at the deadline.

DJariya 03-01-24 02:28 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Maxflier (Post 14394605)
It’s more that I don’t give a shit about baseball anymore period since he left.

I'm not sure I understand your sentiment. So you're an Angels fan? A fan of him as a 2-way player or you don't like the Dodgers? :confused: How does that affect playing this game? Because you can't use him as a pitcher in 2024?

I'm confused.

Shannon Nutt 03-01-24 04:03 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
I'm in for this one...I generally buy my sports games like this every other year, so I haven't played this since the 2022 version.

Maxflier 03-01-24 04:37 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by DJariya (Post 14395039)
I'm not sure I understand your sentiment. So you're an Angels fan? A fan of him as a 2-way player or you don't like the Dodgers? :confused: How does that affect playing this game? Because you can't use him as a pitcher in 2024?

I'm confused.

I'm an Angels fan whose favorite player is Shohei Ohtani. Sure I could trade for him and use him or whatever, but I don't play my sports games that way.
I was a Montreal Expos fan, to this day that is still my favorite sports team ever. So I'm no stranger to having a great talent in the early stages of their career and then walk once they become a big time player. The shit gets old. Between the Expos getting moved and the strikes back then, I gave up on baseball and have had a strained relationship with my fandom ever since. Having potentially the greatest player of all time walk away just sours me completely on the sport once again. So hopefully that makes sense to you for why I feel the way I do.

nickdawgy 03-01-24 11:11 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by Maxflier (Post 14395122)
I'm an Angels fan whose favorite player is Shohei Ohtani. Sure I could trade for him and use him or whatever, but I don't play my sports games that way.
I was a Montreal Expos fan, to this day that is still my favorite sports team ever. So I'm no stranger to having a great talent in the early stages of their career and then walk once they become a big time player. The shit gets old. Between the Expos getting moved and the strikes back then, I gave up on baseball and have had a strained relationship with my fandom ever since. Having potentially the greatest player of all time walk away just sours me completely on the sport once again. So hopefully that makes sense to you for why I feel the way I do.

But apparently the Angels didn’t make or match the offer to Ohtani. Blame Arte Moreno. They’re a doomed franchise til he sells the team.

Trout 03-04-24 03:21 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

Originally Posted by nickdawgy (Post 14394511)
I’ll probably be the Dodgers for the first time as well. After I trade Trout there :lol:

:(

Sonny Corinthos 03-06-24 12:20 PM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 

The create a stadium feature still needs work IMO.

Osiris3657 03-15-24 12:34 AM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
I pre-ordered so I got early access.

After the first two pitches I threw in the game, Chris Singleton says "looking back, the Rangers have been swinging at way too many pitches in this game" :lol:

I see the commentary hasn't been fixed lol. It must be just too difficult for the programmers to create a code that more accurately recognizes what's actually happening on the field and comments appropriately

Oh and funny, the time clock violation is in the game now :lol:

Man, I am so good at pitching but extremely mediocre at hitting. I can shut out a good lineup on Veteran difficulty without much trouble and a ton of K's. Meanwhile I can't string more than a couple hits together on Veteran and struggle to score lol. Need to change the difficulty setting to dynamic

Anyway, gameplay is as fun as ever

Maxflier 03-15-24 08:57 AM

Re: MLB The Show 24 (3/19/24)
 
It always takes me a little while to get back in the groove with hitting. I always struggle with scoring runs early in the season because of it.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:41 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.