DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   GHIV or RockBandII? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/536905-ghiv-rockbandii.html)

edstein 08-04-08 06:28 PM


Originally Posted by mzupeman2
Btw, what 'tighten' mods have you guys used with GhIII?

This is the mod I did. It's a real easy mod to do.

http://forums.xbox-scene.com/index.php?showtopic=628006

Joeboo835 08-04-08 07:16 PM

The real question is, will there be a drum kit for the PS3 that will work with both games?

Michael Corvin 08-04-08 08:24 PM


Originally Posted by edstein
This is the mod I did. It's a real easy mod to do.

http://forums.xbox-scene.com/index.php?showtopic=628006

Yep same here. Easy and works great.

Ghym 08-05-08 10:03 AM


Originally Posted by edstein
This is the mod I did. It's a real easy mod to do.

http://forums.xbox-scene.com/index.php?showtopic=628006

My fix was low-tech. I ripped a business card in half and stuck it in the little groove on the side of the neck, and slid it back into the body. I did that back in November, I guess. Been working great since.

Mordred 08-05-08 10:46 AM


Originally Posted by rabbit77
OP, make this a poll!

I vote GHIV. Music editor, better quality instruments. Easier to read notes. Then get the RB2 disc only.

But in the end it's the music. Wait till the songlist from GHIV comes out and make your decision on what songs you'd rather have.

Agree completely.

edstein 08-05-08 12:16 PM

Has Neversoft said when the GHIV songlist will be announced?

Michael Corvin 08-05-08 12:33 PM

Nope. It will probably be a slow trickle of announcements to detract from the RB2 launch.

fumanstan 08-05-08 12:35 PM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
Nope. It will probably be a slow trickle of announcements to detract from the RB2 launch.

Such terrible marketing -ohbfrank- :p

pinata242 08-05-08 12:36 PM

I wish they'd start already.

Michael Corvin 08-05-08 12:38 PM


Originally Posted by pinata242
I wish they'd start already.

They sorta did with the Hendrix news in Rolling Stone.

REL77 08-05-08 01:25 PM

CONFIRMED TRACKS FOR GHWT

* "Are You Gonna Go My Way" -- Lenny Kravitz
* "Beat It" -- Michael Jackson
* "Bullet With Butterfly Wings" -- Smashing Pumpkins
* "Everlong" -- Foo Fighters
* "Hot for Teacher" -- Van Halen
* "In The End" -- Linkin Park
* "Light My Fire" -- The Doors
* "Never Too Late" -- The Answer
* "Obsatcle 1" -- Interpol
* "One Armed Scissor" -- At the Drive-In
* "Purple Haze" (Live) -- Jimi Hendrix
* "Rebel Yell" -- Billy Idol
* "Santeria" -- Sublime
* "The Wind Cries Mary" -- Jimi Hendrix
* "The Joker" -- Steve Miller Band

Confirmed Bands with unknown songs are Nirvanna, Muse and Beastie Boys

http://www.joystiq.com/2008/08/05/st...d-tour-tracks/

fumanstan 08-05-08 01:30 PM

Was Beat It confirmed? That's awesome :)

Michael Corvin 08-05-08 02:30 PM

See, I don't see how anyone could write off GH:WT in the music game wars when they are bringing Michael Jackson, the Eagles, the Doors, Hendrix, Van Halen & Steve Miller together. Those are huge names that are going to appeal to a lot of people. Personal tastes aside, those six names give me the impression that GH:WT is going to demolish RB2 the way GHIII has done to RB in regards to sales. Not to mention I have zero doubt there will be bigger announcements to come.

edstein 08-05-08 02:36 PM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
See, I don't see how anyone could write off GH:WT in the music game wars when they are bringing Michael Jackson, the Eagles, the Doors, Hendrix, Van Halen & Steve Miller together. Those are huge names that are going to appeal to a lot of people. Personal tastes aside, those six names give me the impression that GH:WT is going to demolish RB2 the way GHIII has done to RB in regards to sales. Not to mention I have zero doubt there will be bigger announcements to come.

I think it's too early to tell. The investment in GH games so far have all been under $100. Not a lot of families are going to invest in $100+ video games no matter how good they are. Will the GH:WT drum set have a separate sku? If so I may just get that and the game separate to save some cash.

pinata242 08-05-08 02:38 PM

They have to sell the drums separately. They can't only sell it in a full package because they've pledged to support RB drums. If they don't offer their own, every with 1 or 2 GH guitars will just buy the standalone RB ones.

Michael Corvin 08-05-08 02:48 PM

I thought Amazon had a listing for a drum kit with the game but if they did it's not showing up now.

Jeremy517 08-05-08 03:05 PM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
See, I don't see how anyone could write off GH:WT in the music game wars

Who is writing off GH:WT :confused: Some people might choose RB2 over GHWT, but I don't think anyone thinks they won't compete and/or win.

As far as I've seen, people are only writing off Rock Revolution.

harrydoyle 08-05-08 03:10 PM

Rock Band II, because I don't own I (one) and I tried the drumming and loved it.

Michael Corvin 08-05-08 08:48 PM


Originally Posted by Jeremy517
Who is writing off GH:WT :confused: Some people might choose RB2 over GHWT, but I don't think anyone thinks they won't compete and/or win.

As far as I've seen, people are only writing off Rock Revolution.

There's been a post or two referring to GH:WT's impending doom because everyone is jumping ship to RB.

I think we can all agree on your last sentence though. :)

REL77 08-06-08 06:42 AM

I like both games, RB is way more realistic (not over charted) and has WAY more songs with available DLC. GH is way harder (way over charted), and more challenging for those great players, but generally has bigger better songs on disk since they pay more for the songs (they have the money i guess)... Both are great games though and I will own both

rabbit77 08-06-08 08:37 AM

question for those in the know - will either game support online co-op career mode? That would be a big sell for me (although I'm already getting both).

Shagrath 08-06-08 08:52 AM


Originally Posted by rabbit77
question for those in the know - will either game support online co-op career mode? That would be a big sell for me (although I'm already getting both).

RB2 is getting online BWT. I guess that's pretty much the same thing.

rabbit77 08-06-08 09:14 AM

awesome, thanks shagrath.

Michael Corvin 08-06-08 09:28 AM

It's been mentioned for GH4 as well.

RichC2 08-06-08 09:39 AM

Bah, at this rate RB3/GH5 will just be Guitar Hero Presents Rock Band World Tour: Reunion Edition.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:18 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.