DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   Bye, bye Gamestop! (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/501716-bye-bye-gamestop.html)

Puzznic 05-30-07 05:31 PM


Originally Posted by Liver&Onions
Yeah - sadly I still shop at EB/GS thanks to the sheer number of trades I have. However, I still throw my bitterness at them on occasion.

I went to buy GH2 on launch, and the dude was like "yeah, we have it. Did you pre-order?" Naturally, I said "Nope - I see no need." to which he said that i'd have to wait until the next day to get it, pre-orders get priority. So I was like "Whatever dude, see Target two doors down? I'll go there and get it." Then I did, and walked by the window and gave him a thumbs up with the case in my grubby mits. I love being petty.


My stores are notorious for that kind of thing as well. That preorder thing might have flown when EB/Gamestop got the games first but places like Best Buy get the games extremely fast now, even before Gamestop alot of the time.

Legolas 05-30-07 06:00 PM


Originally Posted by Liver&Onions
Yeah - sadly I still shop at EB/GS thanks to the sheer number of trades I have. However, I still throw my bitterness at them on occasion.

I went to buy GH2 on launch, and the dude was like "yeah, we have it. Did you pre-order?" Naturally, I said "Nope - I see no need." to which he said that i'd have to wait until the next day to get it, pre-orders get priority. So I was like "Whatever dude, see Target two doors down? I'll go there and get it." Then I did, and walked by the window and gave him a thumbs up with the case in my grubby mits. I love being petty.

I had that same problem. The day Halo 2 came out I went to EB Games. They wouldn't sell me a copy since I didn't pre-order it, so I went to Best Buy and grabbed one of their 1,000 copies.

There's a Gamestop nearby that I don't shop at, but one day I was driving by and noticed that the entire building had been demolished! I guess that's one way to get rid of a Gamestop. :)

Michael Corvin 05-30-07 07:10 PM


Originally Posted by Liver&Onions

I went to buy GH2 on launch, and the dude was like "yeah, we have it. Did you pre-order?" Naturally, I said "Nope - I see no need." to which he said that i'd have to wait until the next day to get it, pre-orders get priority. So I was like "Whatever dude, see Target two doors down? I'll go there and get it." Then I did, and walked by the window and gave him a thumbs up with the case in my grubby mits. I love being petty.

Awesome. I like it. :up:

Josh H 05-30-07 07:38 PM


Originally Posted by Liver&Onions
Then I did, and walked by the window and gave him a thumbs up with the case in my grubby mits. I love being petty.

Classic. :thumbsup: :lol:

PopcornTreeCt 05-30-07 08:38 PM

When GTA Vice City came out. I got it at Target, while all the kids who pre-ordered it at Gamestop still didn't have it yet. It was pretty awesome.

Spicollidriver1 05-30-07 09:02 PM


Originally Posted by PopcornTreeCt
When GTA Vice City came out. I got it at Target, while all the kids who pre-ordered it at Gamestop still didn't have it yet. It was pretty awesome.

My favorite was when San Andreas came out we went to toys r us and they were doing buy 2 get one free, and got 3 copies essentially for $33 a piece, after EB and gamestop both said we wouldn't find 1 .

darkside 05-30-07 09:23 PM

One of the employees told me one time about the unofficial policy not to sell on day one to people that don't preorder. It has to be the single dumbest thing I have heard of. I haven't preordered anything from them I couldn't get a nice freebie for and usually I will just take the free item and then cancel my order or return the game unopened and keep the freebie.

Yeah its uncool, but I have no sympathy for Gamestop. Especially when the constantly charge an extra $5 over everyone else on many of their DS titles.

wildcatlh 05-30-07 09:25 PM

A couple of weeks ago I was in a Gamestop at the mall looking at cheap used games and I overheard the clerk telling someone that if they didn't pre-order Mario Party 8 they weren't going to be able to find it anywhere on launch day. I nearly lost it laughing.

asianflow 05-30-07 11:33 PM

I'm surprised more people don't have a problem buying an open boxed game while paying full price for it. If there's no shrink wrap on the box, I consider it used.

darkside 05-30-07 11:45 PM


Originally Posted by asianflow
I'm surprised more people don't have a problem buying an open boxed game while paying full price for it. If there's no shrink wrap on the box, I consider it used.

I nearly got a manager fired years ago for trying to sell me an opened game new. The problem for me was I had preordered the game. You would think they could hold my preorder without opening it.

Yes, I have a problem buying an opened game as new.

Supermallet 05-30-07 11:48 PM


Originally Posted by darkside
One of the employees told me one time about the unofficial policy not to sell on day one to people that don't preorder. It has to be the single dumbest thing I have heard of.

Actually the stores get emails saying "We expect only x percent of pre-order customers to pick this up within the 48 hour hold window, so take y amount out of the reserved copies to sell to walk-ins." I think this is utter bullshit, because if they're trying to get people to reserve games, they should hold the fucking games.

The thing about purposely holding copies that aren't reserved until the next day is not a company policy, it's idiot store managers who think it will give people incentives to reserve in the future. All it does is give people incentive to buy the game somewhere else. Those managers are schmucks.

matrixrok9 05-31-07 03:34 AM

About a year and a half ago, I called a couple of time to ask them if they got a new game in. Their reply was similar to the posters:

gs: yes, we have it but did you pre order?
me: no
gs: we have one left, next time you should pre order.
me: okay

Gamestop that is 5 minutes from my house had a cool manager though. He asked if I wanted to pre order anything everytime I made a purchase but never pressured me. He went out of his way to always give me the best deals on used dvds.

About 3 months ago, I guess he was let go and now there's a new jackass manager.

You guys should take advantage of their used item 7 day return policy. I used to buy a used game, beat it within a week and return the game. Free rental baby.

BravesMG 05-31-07 10:39 AM

Suprmallet, I know there are a lot of stories about asshole EB/GS managers floating around, but the new crew at my local GS is very cool (as I would assume you would be if you ran my local store). They help me out quite often and their customer service is top notch. Plus, they actually know what they're talking about and keep up on most of the release dates and new information.

So other than preorders, which I won't do, is there anything we might not think of that could help them out? I've asked what I can do to help their store and basically they just said preorders and trading in my stuff specifically at their place, which is no problem. Just curious to know if there may be anything else they might not be able to tell us.

mzupeman2 05-31-07 11:36 PM

I can understand the idea behind 'don't sell games on day one to those who don't pre-order'. It's a way to try and drum up business by pre-orders. 'Want it guaranteed, pre-order it'.

But as many others said, the Best Buy down the street will have eight million copies of the same game. Games aren't like consoles. If you can't find a game now... you will, very very soon.

What Gamestop needs to understand, is that although this is a nice idea to help pre-orders in theory, they're turning their backs on sales any day a game is released due to this. A pre-order should just guarantee you a copy of a game... period. It shouldn't have any extra catches just for doing so... such as getting the game on release day. Let them hold the pre-orders aside for those who figured they may be better off to make sure they'll get their hands on Halo 3 without a hassle... and if there's extra copies, throw it on the shelf and let the customer buy it if they want. Who really cares if they didn't pre-order it?

I work as an assistant manager at a toy store. It's not the same, by any means. But hey, if a customer comes in and they're looking around and they want something but perhaps they're looking like they may not buy it because of the price.... I may cut them a little break on the item. Not much, but something. Why? Because they could go across the street to Wal-Mart if they want, ya know? You shouldn't turn away business for something as petty as having a plan that is supposedly going to drive all your pre-order business through the roof.

What pre-orders SHOULD be important for... are consoles. And can we even trust that? Shit no. Why? Because of the greedy pre-order process.

My 360, I went through hell to get. I had mine at a local mom and pop game shop that had me number five on their list... they ended up getting twenty consoles altogether (don't ask me how when some stores only got a few), and I would have had it on release day.

But you know, some months before the system came out... I was at a Gamestop and I pre-ordered a game. It was near where I lived so figured it wouldn't be a hassle. I was told I could still pre-order the system with a guaranteed first shipment date. I told the employee that I had it pre-ordered already, was fifth in line, and was fine with where I pre-ordered. But you know, he talked me into it being that it was going to be conveniant to pick up the console there because I lived closer, had the game pre-ordered there, yadda yadda yadda.

Turns out after release, that my 'guaranteed first shipment' that I traded from fifth in line at another store, was so I could be 89 in THIS store. How could I have been first shipment guaranteed with a number like that?

'Oh, well there were some first shipment pre-orders left available from other stores so we took them for them'. Riiiiiiiiiiiight. After a couple of conversations with the DM, I got a console. I'll never pre-order a console again through those bastards. I'd rather wait in line all night at a Wal-Mart (a 24 hour one of course so I can be inside) than give them my pre-order money only to be screwed in the end.

Funny thing though, the DM actually admitted to me that basically Microsoft earlier that year gave an estimate... an ESTIMATE... of how many consoles they may be sending out for launch. They actually encouraged the schmucks in their business suits at the home offices not to pre-sell the consoles because nothing was set in stone. Alas, many people got that disappointing phone call about not recieving a console on launch day. All because of pre-order greed.

Josh H 05-31-07 11:45 PM

To be fair on the console preorders, they fixed that with the Wii and PS3 launches because of the 360 debacle.

They waited very late to take preorders--until they new how many they were getting. I preordered the Wii there as I amassed as they had some good trade in deals for once last fall, and decided to take advantage of that and got my Wii and Zelda for no $$ out of pocket. They knew how many they were getting and only took that many preorders the morning they did them and as such there were no problems.

One of the few good experiences I've ever had with the chain. Still haven't been back since I had a couple terrible experiences in the month after that though.

Supermallet 05-31-07 11:57 PM


Originally Posted by bravesmg
Suprmallet, I know there are a lot of stories about asshole EB/GS managers floating around, but the new crew at my local GS is very cool (as I would assume you would be if you ran my local store). They help me out quite often and their customer service is top notch. Plus, they actually know what they're talking about and keep up on most of the release dates and new information.

So other than preorders, which I won't do, is there anything we might not think of that could help them out? I've asked what I can do to help their store and basically they just said preorders and trading in my stuff specifically at their place, which is no problem. Just curious to know if there may be anything else they might not be able to tell us.

I'm glad you have a good crew at the store near you. It is possible, it just doesn't seem to be the norm.

Honestly, the only things you can do to help the stores are buy used from them, bring in trades, get a subscription, and pre-order. There's no real "extra" things you can do that they can't tell you about. Used sales, trades, subscriptions, and pre-orders are all the company cares about.

Arpeggi 06-01-07 12:37 AM

Pre-orders are for ****s.

taffer 06-01-07 03:06 AM


Originally Posted by Arpeggi
Pre-orders are for ****s.

Thanks for the insight. :thumbsup:

Michael Corvin 06-01-07 07:43 AM


Originally Posted by mzupeman2
I can understand the idea behind 'don't sell games on day one to those who don't pre-order'. It's a way to try and drum up business by pre-orders. 'Want it guaranteed, pre-order it'.

But as many others said, the Best Buy down the street will have eight million copies of the same game. Games aren't like consoles. If you can't find a game now... you will, very very soon.

Because selling to a customer on release day doesn't earn them free interest on your money for 6 months.

Sounds petty but consider that a pre-order can be anywhere from $5 to the full price of the game. $5 doesn't sound like a lot but consider they were bragging recently about already having 1 million(or something) pre-orders for Halo 3. That is 5 million in the bank earning interest for 6 months for them. Then you multiply that by a couple dozen games you can pre-order and that free money adds up quick. I would even bet a small percentage of those forget about that $5 like people do with rebates. It's a cash cow for them.

They probably make far more money on that interest than they ever would off of SRP just selling them on release day.

Supermallet 06-01-07 10:33 AM


Originally Posted by Arpeggi
Pre-orders are for ****s.

So is trolling.

mzupeman2 06-01-07 10:38 AM


Originally Posted by Michael Corvin
Because selling to a customer on release day doesn't earn them free interest on your money for 6 months.

Sounds petty but consider that a pre-order can be anywhere from $5 to the full price of the game. $5 doesn't sound like a lot but consider they were bragging recently about already having 1 million(or something) pre-orders for Halo 3. That is 5 million in the bank earning interest for 6 months for them. Then you multiply that by a couple dozen games you can pre-order and that free money adds up quick. I would even bet a small percentage of those forget about that $5 like people do with rebates. It's a cash cow for them.

They probably make far more money on that interest than they ever would off of SRP just selling them on release day.

Oh believe me, I completely understand this aspect of it. I brought this up to the DM I talked to in matter of fact... because it engraged me not only did they pry me away from another store with a promise they didn't and weren't willing to keep under the circumstances (considering I WOULD have had a system on launch day)... but they also got my money and when I pay for a console in full, they better damn well give me what my money was supposed to promise me. Period. I wasn't happy that they were able to have that money of mine, without really being able to give me what I paid for. They were telling me 'spring'. Ridiculous.

But then again, I persuaded him to pull a console for me.

If I was just a guy who waited until whenever to pre-order the console... I wouldn't have really minded as much. But being what my circumstances were however again, I felt robbed.

fujishig 06-01-07 11:10 AM

Sure, the preorders get them money up front that they can gain interest on, or go invest, or whatever. But the point still stands that they are not only turning away sales, they are turning away potential future customers... especially if they're located in the same mall as a Target or Best Buy or something. The witholding of a product only works if the product is not easily available, otherwise, I would think the thought process of the common customer would not be "well gee, I guess I better preorder next time," it's instead "if I want a game, I'm not coming to this game store, where they don't seem to be able to stock enough to sell to people... I'll go to Target instead."

Josh H 06-01-07 12:03 PM


Originally Posted by fujishig
The witholding of a product only works if the product is not easily available,

Exactly, and this is why the stores have absolutely no use anymore since games are readily available often earlier, and occasionally cheaper, on release date in the big box stores now.

Trading and buying used games is usually a rip off as you can sell them for more and buy them for less on ebay or exachange forums on sites like this. But this will keep them in business as many don't know any better or are too lazy to deal with ebay/trading online etc.

slop101 06-01-07 12:06 PM

Yeah, stores like GS make very little on selling new games - so little, that they probably don't care if you buy it from Target or Best Buy instead - they care more about selling used games. But it does piss of customers who could be regular customers when they pull shit like holding games for pre-orders only - and it's not worth the poor relations to do so, but they don't seem to care...

jonw9 06-02-07 09:52 PM


Originally Posted by Suprmallet
The purpose of "gutting" games as Gamestop calls it is to be able to put the case out on the floor without worrying about theft. If there are some open ones in our cases, it's probably because we gutted multiple copies of the game when it was a new release to have it on the floor, and when we only needed one copy on the floor, the extras just went back in the case.


Thanks for the response, sorry I was slow returning.

My experience was Oblivion. I guess it wasn't release day, since there were used copies they tried to sell me (and allow me to save $2.47).


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:10 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.