DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   Your favorite Mario game (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/456298-your-favorite-mario-game.html)

FRwL 02-18-06 01:31 AM

Your favorite Mario game
 
What's your favorite Mario game? Obviously only the core of the series the adventure platformers starring Mario are included.

Super Mario Bros. 3 is my favorite, i think it is the apex of the series. There's so many different worlds and levels, the most massive in scope.

Michael Corvin 02-18-06 01:49 AM

No love for the original Mario Bros.?

I have to put Mario 3 after 64. I love them both, but 64 brought so much to the table, while Mario 3 was just a bigger more robust version of 1. Mario World would round out my top 3.

It's close though.

FRwL 02-18-06 02:19 AM

Well i put adventures only, Mario Bros. was the two player stuff in an arena.
Also Mario 3 pioneered rpg-ish elements like the item selection and world maps.

dcswirl 02-18-06 02:37 AM

Mario Bros 3

Josh H 02-18-06 09:33 AM

Super Mario World. Excellent graphics, excellent level design. And was probably the longest of the mario games with finding all the 96 exits and clearing every level.

Definitely the one I replay the most. Super Mario Bros 3 a close second, and Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island right behind it in third.

darkside 02-18-06 10:12 AM

Tie between Super Mario 64 and Super Mario World. Loved both of those games, mediocre DS version excluded. If I have to only pick one I guess it will be 64 since I spent so much time getting every single star.

tenaciousdave 02-18-06 11:10 AM

I have to go with Super Mario 64.

In fact, I don't know if I can say I've ever had more fun with any other game.

fumanstan 02-18-06 01:55 PM

Mario 3.

Outlaw 02-18-06 02:16 PM

Tie between Super Mario World and Super Mario 64. SMW was an incredible platformer with tons of levels, and after you've finished it (or during depending on how good you were) there were those Special stages.

Mario 64 was an incredible game, it doesn't need to be said how revolutionary it was when it came out. The gameplay was so incredibly responsive and tight that I was always amazed at the glitches people found like getting on top of the castle without the cannon or the shortcuts and then sat in awe as I tried to do them myself and was able to do it too.

Those being said, I cannot wait for New Super Mario Bros. on the DS when Mario returns to his 2D roots :D.

tanman 02-19-06 01:07 AM

I'm surprised. I thought everyones favorite would have been 64 or 3. I picked World as it was my personal favorite. I also really like 2 though. But all of them were quite good. Except for the first Super Mario Land. That one was a little odd. Definately the black sheep in the family.

lawyer goodwill 02-19-06 01:12 AM


Originally Posted by tanman
I'm surprised. I thought everyones favorite would have been 64 or 3. I picked World as it was my personal favorite. I also really like 2 though. But all of them were quite good. Except for the first Super Mario Land. That one was a little odd. Definately the black sheep in the family.

I guess I'm the black sheep of this poll. The original Super Mario Land remains my favorite, most replayable Mario game. Love the Hip Tanaka tunes, too!

However, I do agree the game is a little odd.

tofu 02-19-06 02:48 AM

Super Mario 3. At the time, It had added so many new things. But still had all of the fun of the original one.

But now, I equally love all of the Mario sports games too.

DVDFreaker 02-19-06 03:09 AM

Mario Brothers 2 because that is the only game I get to play Luigi and Luigi is my favorite and he is better than Mario!

Chris_D 02-19-06 07:26 AM

Super Mario World, I remember playing the initial Japanese release and it just looked so fine at the time. Good memories. Mario 64 is close just for being such a great realisation of platforming in 3d. It wasn't until zelda oot that I enjoyed just running around in a 3d world more than mario 64.

Of course my fav mario game is Mario kart 64 :p.

tenaciousdave 02-19-06 10:37 AM

I'm surprised that the real Super Mario Bros. 2 isn't listed. Did nobody actually play The Lost Levels on Mario All Stars?

The Bus 02-19-06 10:53 AM

You didn't list Super Mario World 2.

daniel18 02-19-06 12:12 PM

Super Mario 64.

daniel18 02-19-06 12:19 PM


Originally Posted by The Bus
You didn't list Super Mario World 2.


In Super Mario World 2 you play as Yoshi, not Mario.



Originally Posted by FRwL
What's your favorite Mario game? Obviously only the core of the series the adventure platformers starring Mario are included.

Super Mario Bros. 3 is my favorite, i think it is the apex of the series. There's so many different worlds and levels, the most massive in scope.


Josh H 02-19-06 12:29 PM


Originally Posted by tenaciousdave
I'm surprised that the real Super Mario Bros. 2 isn't listed. Did nobody actually play The Lost Levels on Mario All Stars?

I played it, but think that and SMB while great games are the weak links in the series as they were two of the first games of the type and just didn't age as well as SMB2 and beyond have.

Goldberg74 02-19-06 04:29 PM

Sunshine for me.

tenaciousdave 02-19-06 05:15 PM


Originally Posted by Josh Hinkle
I played it, but think that and SMB while great games are the weak links in the series as they were two of the first games of the type and just didn't age as well as SMB2 and beyond have.

I thought Mario 2 was the weak point in the series.

In fact, it wasn't even really a Mario game. Super Mario Bros 2 was originally Doki Doki Panic. It was reskinned to include Mario outside of Japan and they slapped the Mario Bros name on it.

You can read about it here.

http://www.progressiveboink.com/arch...dokipanic.html

Josh H 02-19-06 05:37 PM

Yeah, I know the history of SMB2. I still like it better than SMB and the Lost Levels as far as going back and playing them today. The control just isn't tight and the level design to simplistic compared to SMB3, SMW etc.

The Dude 02-19-06 05:46 PM

Just picked up Mario 3 for the DS; damn it's a hard game! Maybe I'm just out of practice with the "Mario style", but it seems that I do nothing but die during the game. Still hella fun though.

jaeufraser 02-19-06 06:43 PM

I love Super Mario World. Just a great game, imo the perfect culmination of all things Mario.

PixyJunket 02-20-06 07:56 AM


Originally Posted by FRwL
Also Mario 3 pioneered rpg-ish elements

Oh, for the love of God you have GOT to be kidding me. :lol:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:01 PM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.