DVD Talk Forum

DVD Talk Forum (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/)
-   Video Game Talk (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk-15/)
-   -   Anyone Getting Guitar Hero? (https://forum.dvdtalk.com/video-game-talk/443255-anyone-getting-guitar-hero.html)

edstein 10-04-06 11:11 AM

Thats a sweet track list. Can't wait.

xVladx 10-04-06 12:32 PM


Originally Posted by ytrez
I played the GH II Demo last night. Shout at the Devil, You Really Got Me, Strutter, YYZ were the playable songs. I thought the controls were a bit touchy, especially on the hammer ons in Shout at the Devil. Also, the timing on the strumming seemed a bit off. Or maybe I'm just so out of practice that I'm god-awful? I'm really looking forward to this one.

I've read some posts from some people on the official GH boards, and from the sounds of it, they REALLY loosened up the way HOPOs are handled. From the sounds of it, you can be completely off the beat on them and you'll still get credit, and someone has even claimed that you don't have to hold the appropriate buttons when HOPOing any longer, you can just press the buttons regularly and get credit.

I haven't been able to track down the demo yet, but if it's as bad as it sounds, then it looks like it may be another situation like the Frequency to Amplitude transition, where they improve a whole bunch of stuff yet decide to wreck a few of the things that worked fine in the original.


I don't know if I am the only one but ever since I bought Guitar Hero and played it I have been having alot of problems with my left arm. I mean severe pain from the shoulder down to numbness in my fingers. I am not 100% sure it is from Guitar Hero but after playing for a hour or so my left hand is always numb. Has anyone else had problems after using the guitar? I gave up trying to complete the hardest level a few months ago. My hand is STILL numb. I know the sequel is coming next month but I don't know if I should buy it or not! Any help?
Uhh.. yeah, that's not good. Are you tensing up your fret arm when you're playing or anything? Make sure that your wrist is as straight as possible and you're not holding it at any weird angles while you're playing.

I've had some mild hand soreness after attempting Cowboys From Hell a few times in a row, but nothing long-term, and certainly nothing that affects my whole arm.

JimmySRU 10-04-06 12:42 PM

cant wait for it

Liver&Onions 10-04-06 01:00 PM

so I wonder if I get to play Claypool's part in John the Fisherman, or if it'll be Ler's.

Oh, for those who may not have seen it - here's a review of a third party controller that we recently posted:

http://www.dvdtalk.com/reviews/games/read.php?ID=481

mkdevo 10-05-06 06:39 AM

i REALLY hope the 'search and destroy' is the RHCP version, though it seems unlikely since they had a song on the first one as well..

Wildo1966 10-05-06 02:21 PM


Originally Posted by xVladx
I've read some posts from some people on the official GH boards, and from the sounds of it, they REALLY loosened up the way HOPOs are handled. From the sounds of it, you can be completely off the beat on them and you'll still get credit, and someone has even claimed that you don't have to hold the appropriate buttons when HOPOing any longer, you can just press the buttons regularly and get credit.

I haven't been able to track down the demo yet, but if it's as bad as it sounds, then it looks like it may be another situation like the Frequency to Amplitude transition, where they improve a whole bunch of stuff yet decide to wreck a few of the things that worked fine in the original.



Uhh.. yeah, that's not good. Are you tensing up your fret arm when you're playing or anything? Make sure that your wrist is as straight as possible and you're not holding it at any weird angles while you're playing.

I've had some mild hand soreness after attempting Cowboys From Hell a few times in a row, but nothing long-term, and certainly nothing that affects my whole arm.

Seems to be that I have some mild tendonitest (SP?) in my left arm, no doubt it was aggrevated by Guitar Hero. Yes, I was putting alot of strain on my left wrist/hand while fretting. I was playing GH in high doses so I have stopped cold turkey at least until GHII comes out next month. I was also thinking about flipping the guitar and playing left handed. Anyone here can play both ways? Sucks to get out!

Wick 10-05-06 08:47 PM

I hope it's not like the change between Frequency and Amplitude, because I didn't find it to be as fun. It was too forgiving, and it seemed a bit off (with regards to hit detection, and just the gameplay in general.) Don't get me wrong - I still really like it, but it's not as good as Frequency.

xVladx 10-06-06 08:44 AM


Originally Posted by Wick
I hope it's not like the change between Frequency and Amplitude, because I didn't find it to be as fun. It was too forgiving, and it seemed a bit off (with regards to hit detection, and just the gameplay in general.) Don't get me wrong - I still really like it, but it's not as good as Frequency.

From what I've played of the OPM demo, it looks like, as it was with Amplitude, the hit detection will be a bit looser, especially when it comes to HOPOs. The game is almost a little TOO forgiving when it comes to allowing you to hit them.

On the other hand, it really looks like they're making the solos a whole lot tougher this time out. On Expert, the solos in You Really Got Me and YYZ have some seriously rough parts. As much as I liked how HOPOs were implemented in the first GH, I imagine that if they didn't tweak them that some of these sections would be way too frustrating, even with the practice mode.

Brent L 10-06-06 12:54 PM

I got the demo in the mail today with my new issue of OPM. I'll play it later tonight. :)

Decker 10-07-06 12:52 AM

So, is there any point in me getting GH now, or should I wait for GH2? I kept waiting for a price drop and it still hasn't come.

BTW preorder GH2 at BB for $5 and you get a free GH2 concert t-shirt that actually looks to be pretty cool. It's available both in-store currently and online.

http://images.bestbuy.com/BestBuy_US...tarhero_02.jpg

BTW : The game with guitar is $79.99. Yikes.

Matt925 10-07-06 11:19 AM


Originally Posted by Decker
So, is there any point in me getting GH now, or should I wait for GH2? I kept waiting for a price drop and it still hasn't come.

GH2 has improved features like co-op play and so on, but they are essentially the same game with different songs. So if you like the songs on GH then you should pick it up. But maybe the price will drop, who knows?

The setlist looks great, but I'm really hoping that one of the unannounced songs is by Tool. -pray-

Sekots 10-07-06 02:05 PM


Originally Posted by Decker
So, is there any point in me getting GH now, or should I wait for GH2? I kept waiting for a price drop and it still hasn't come.

Well you can buy GH now and when GH2 comes out just buy the version with the game itself and no guitar and it will be cheaper.

pizzamousechips 10-08-06 04:47 AM

Just played the demo extensively. Love it already. They chose good showcasing songs for it.

Shout At The Devil is good for the basics. Pretty easy, even on Expert.
You Really Got Me has really insane solo combos.
Strutter brought in the three fret chords. It's really trippy playing it at first, but it's a good trippy.
YYZ is just plain weird. You can tell where they'd add a second guitarrist. And it's good for HOPO's. Great for it.

A-aron 10-08-06 07:46 AM

all of this news is making me even more anxious for some details on the 360 version ...

daddydaryl 10-08-06 08:25 AM

OK, I played the demo as well. It will not let me use my wireless guitar though :thmbsdwn: . It says it has to be a SG guitar. The real game hadn't better not be like this or I'm gonna be pissed. What could be in the SG that it would notice wasn't in the wireless? Did they really think that far ahead to include something in it to stop "unofficial" controllers?

Shagrath 10-08-06 10:29 AM


Originally Posted by daddydaryl
OK, I played the demo as well. It will not let me use my wireless guitar though :thmbsdwn: . It says it has to be a SG guitar. The real game hadn't better not be like this or I'm gonna be pissed. What could be in the SG that it would notice wasn't in the wireless? Did they really think that far ahead to include something in it to stop "unofficial" controllers?

As far as I know, the only thing different is that the SG controller has left on the digital pad permanently down. I would think that the third-party companies would've done the same when designing their controllers, but I'm not sure.

DVDChris 10-08-06 10:54 AM

where can one play the demo for guitar hero 2?

Sekots 10-08-06 11:44 AM


Originally Posted by DVDChris
where can one play the demo for guitar hero 2?

I got mine in the Playstation Magazine for this month.

RichC2 10-08-06 01:27 PM

To answer the title of the thread, yes, I am. But I don't think it'll catch on, which is a shame.

Lethal Nemesis 10-08-06 03:43 PM

I'm gonna go out and try to look for the Nov issue of OPM today. I can't wait to play that bass line in YYZ.

SuperBatMan 10-08-06 08:16 PM


Originally Posted by Lethal Nemesis
I'm gonna go out and try to look for the Nov issue of OPM today. I can't wait to play that bass line in YYZ.

It's not on newsstands until Tuesday, unless you find it early.

daddydaryl 10-08-06 08:35 PM


Originally Posted by Lethal Nemesis
I'm gonna go out and try to look for the Nov issue of OPM today. I can't wait to play that bass line in YYZ.


You can't play the bass line in the demo, only the lead....

Lethal Nemesis 10-08-06 09:29 PM


Originally Posted by daddydaryl
You can't play the bass line in the demo, only the lead....

You can play the bass line in Co-Op. Sorry about not clarifying!

Lethal Nemesis 10-08-06 09:30 PM

Well, found it at my local Blockbuster. YYZ is definitely the most fun to play out of the ones on the demo. As has been said by others who already have it, HOPOs are a lot easier this time around.

Lethal Nemesis 10-08-06 09:30 PM

Oh, and Strutter is a lot of fun to play, too. It's kinda like Crossroads on steroids.

xVladx 10-08-06 10:35 PM


Originally Posted by Lethal Nemesis
Oh, and Strutter is a lot of fun to play, too. It's kinda like Crossroads on steroids.

Indeed. I think that Strutter is my favorite of the demo songs at the moment. I like YYZ, but I'm not good enough at it yet to really enjoy it. Strutter has a good balance of having some interesting note patterns without being insanely hard. I've actually come damn close to 100%ing it on Expert a few times.

ytrez 10-09-06 09:17 AM


Originally Posted by Lethal Nemesis
HOPOs are a lot easier this time around.

Unless you try to strum on those notes!

daddydaryl 10-09-06 05:09 PM

OK, I got this reply from the Wireless V people about their guitar not working with GH2:

"We are working on an adapter for it, it will be out after GH2 release, please check our website for updates, thank you"

They don't say if the adapter is free (doubtful) or what. If it isn't free I'll probably just sell it and put it towards GH2 with another controller. Do you think all the adapter will do is make it think "down" is pushed like the SG does?

devilshalo 10-09-06 05:54 PM


Originally Posted by ytrez
Unless you try to strum on those notes!

Yeah, I can't quite get used to doing HOPO's, so I strum. Actually, I can't even call it strumming, I'm playing it more like a bass, but what do I know.. I'm a percussionist.

SuperBatMan 10-09-06 08:59 PM


October 9, 2006 - After a year of wishlists, speculation and even a bit of "slipped" information, RedOctane has finally revealed to us the final licensed tracklist for Guitar Hero II. Totaling 40 tunes in all, spread over eight difficulty levels, the sequel to our Best Music Game of 2005 seems to have an even wider range of rock-oriented music than the first time out. From Guns N' Roses to the Police to Dick Dale, Guitar Hero II runs the gamut of rock.

Without further ado, here are the tracks you'll be rocking out to come November 7th.

1. Opening Licks
Motley Crue - Shout at the Devil
Danzig - Mother
Cheap Trick - Surrender
Wolfmother - Woman
Spinal Tap - Tonight I'm Gonna Rock You Tonight

2. Amp-Warmers
Kiss - Strutter
Nirvana - Heart-Shaped Box
Police - Message in a Bottle
Van Halen - You Really Got Me
Kansas - Carry on Wayward Son

3. String-Snappers
Foo Fighters - Monkey Wrench
Alice in Chains - Them Bones
Iggy Pop and the Stooges - Search and Destroy
Pretenders - Tattooed Love Boys
Black Sabbath - War Pigs

4. Thrash and Burn
Warrant - Cherry Pie
Butthole Surfers - Who Was in My Room Last Night
Mathew Sweet - Girlfriend
Rolling Stones - Can't You Hear Me Knockin'
Guns N' Roses - Sweet Child O' Mine

5. Return of the Shred
Rage Against the Machine - Killing in the Name Of
Primus - John the Fisherman
Sword - Freya
Thin Lizzy - Bad Reputation
Aerosmtih - Last Child

6. Relentless Riffs
Heart - Crazy on You
Stone Temple Pilots - Tripping on a Hole in a Paper Heart
Stray Cats - Rock This Town
Allman Brothers - Jessica
Jane's Addiction - Stop

7. Furious Fretwork
Anthrax - Madhouse
Living End - Carry Me Home
Lamb of God - Laid to Rest
Reverend Horton Heat - Psychobilly Freakout
Rush - YYZ

8. Face-Melters
Avenged Sevenfold - Beast and the Harlot
Suicidal Tendencies - Institutionalized
Dick Dale - Misirlou
Megadeth - Hangar 18
Lynyrd Skynyrd - Free Bird

As for the unlockable bonus tracks, RedOctane tells us that it wants to keep those songs a secret until release as to not spoil everything for the fans. Sounds good to us, though we're certainly interested to know simply what caliber of tracks will be included. Good things come to those who wait however, and luckily we have less than a month to do so.
http://ps2.ign.com/articles/737/737921p1.html

sauce07 10-10-06 04:49 PM

Just got the demo, good stuff
Is it me or did the fret board get shorter, meaning the notes are note on the screen as long

devilshalo 10-11-06 11:54 AM

You lucky 360 bastids! :mad:

http://www.t3.co.uk/__data/assets/fp...tarii_main.jpg

edstein 10-11-06 12:00 PM

Get yourself a 360. What are you waiting for. :rock:

devilshalo 10-11-06 12:52 PM


Originally Posted by edstein
Get yourself a 360. What are you waiting for. :rock:

My PS2 is perfectly fine, just wished they would have given us users the same guitar. At least I get to play GH1 while I'm waiting for the release in Nov. :p

Wildo1966 10-11-06 02:24 PM

Hello All,
I see alot of people have the demo for GH2, is this available for free anywhere for the PS2? I can't see to find a post about where to find one. Any help would be great! Even though my hand is still numb from GH1....UGH!

xVladx 10-11-06 02:29 PM


Originally Posted by Wildo1966
Hello All,
I see alot of people have the demo for GH2, is this available for free anywhere for the PS2? I can't see to find a post about where to find one. Any help would be great! Even though my hand is still numb from GH1....UGH!

Nope, the demo is on the disc that comes with the Official Playstation Magazine. Only way to get it, as far as I know, is to be a subscriber or to buy the magazine in stores.

SuperBatMan 10-11-06 07:13 PM

Isn't the 360 version coming out in 2007?

If so, I'll buy the PS2 version in a few weeks. Then, when the 360 version is out, I'll trade in the PS2 one. Guitar Hero in 5.1 surround sound=:drool:

pizzamousechips 10-11-06 09:58 PM

[Brag post]

I'm obsessed with the demo. I five star'd everything except for YYZ. The solo isn't even that impossible. And the repeated riff is comparably easy, if it really is a last-tier song. Gah! Soon...

Josh-da-man 10-11-06 10:15 PM


Originally Posted by edstein
Get yourself a 360. What are you waiting for. :rock:

360s that don't self-destruct after six months.

xVladx 10-12-06 10:31 AM


Originally Posted by pizzamousechips
[Brag post]

I'm obsessed with the demo. I five star'd everything except for YYZ. The solo isn't even that impossible. And the repeated riff is comparably easy, if it really is a last-tier song. Gah! Soon...

IIRC, it sits somewhere in the 7th (second to last) set.

One thing I've thought about is that the GH2 demo seems easy because I've had a TON of practice on the first game. Sure, some of the passages are tricky because they're new, but since we already know the basics of playing there isn't going to be as much of a learning curve.

I remember the same thing happening when I started playing Amplitude. I had put so many hours into Frequency that I was bored with anything but the hardest difficulty on Amplitude.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:05 AM.


Copyright © 2026 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands. All rights reserved. Use of this site indicates your consent to the Terms of Use.